BOOKS
Published
Read Time
3 min read
Share This Review
They Both Die at the End by Adam Silvera Review: A Devastating, #BookTok-Beloved YA Romance
Adam Silvera's third novel, They Both Die at the End, is a young adult romance built on an unflinching premise: two teenage boys, Mateo Torrez and Rufus Emeterio, each receive a call from Death-Cast informing them they will die before the day is out, and choose to spend those final hours together. Originally published by HarperTeen in September 2017 and later reissued by Quill Tree Books, the novel earned a #1 New York Times bestseller designation, four starred reviews, and a wave of renewed readership driven by #BookTok — making it one of the defining YA novels of its era.
LuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Teen and adult readers who want a LGBTQ+ YA story that confronts mortality and the meaning of connection with emotional directness, and who are comfortable entering a novel already knowing its ending.
Worth it if
You respond to high-stakes, emotionally compressed narratives where the journey matters more than the destination — particularly if queer representation, grief, and the urgency of human connection are themes you actively seek out in YA fiction.
Skip if
You rely on narrative uncertainty to sustain tension, or find it difficult to accept that two strangers could form a deeply credible bond within the span of a single day.
What readers & critics say
Kirkus Reviews called it "another standout from Silvera who here grapples gracefully with heavy questions about death and the meaning of a life well-lived," concluding it is "engrossing, contemplative and as heart-wrenching as the title promises." The novel's author site documents an exceptional awards haul — a #1 New York Times bestseller designation, four starred reviews, and recognition from School Library Journal, Kirkus, Booklist, and Book Riot, among others.
“Silvera grapples gracefully with heavy questions about death and the meaning of a life well-lived.”
— Kirkus Reviews“Engrossing, contemplative and as heart-wrenching as the title promises.”
— Wikipedia (citing Kirkus Reviews)“The Last Friend App — I kind of loved how touching this idea is. Rated 8/10: Excellent.”
— SFF Book Review“The switching in narration helped me to see how Mateo and Rufus view and understand each other.”
— Teen Ink4.6from 42,366 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
In This Review
- What Works & What Doesn't
- The Premise and What the Novel Contains
- Significance and Reception
- Craft and Emotional Register
- Genuine Limitations and Who May Struggle With It
- Who This Book Is For and Its Broader Life
What Works & What Doesn't
What Works
- #1 New York Times bestseller with four starred reviews and sustained readership across multiple years, including a major #BookTok-driven resurgence
- Kirkus Reviews praised Silvera for grappling 'gracefully with heavy questions about death and the meaning of a life well-lived'
- BuzzFeed credited Silvera with creating 'entirely relatable and authentic characters' while capturing 'the raw emotion of facing your own mortality'
- Central LGBTQ+ romance between two fully realized protagonists, Mateo Torrez and Rufus Emeterio, with a supporting ensemble whose subplots enrich the world
- A screen adaptation in development with Bridgerton creator Chris Van Dusen, with Silvera himself attached as executive producer
What Doesn't
- The title is an explicit spoiler by design — readers who rely on narrative uncertainty for emotional engagement may find the known ending diminishes tension
- The entire emotional arc between Mateo and Rufus unfolds within a single day, a compressed timeline that asks readers to accept an accelerated bond as fully credible
A book that announces its ending in its title and still, according to Kirkus Reviews, delivers something "engrossing, contemplative and as heart-wrenching as the title promises" — that is the particular achievement at the center of They Both Die at the End.
The Premise and What the Novel Contains
The novel is set in a near-future New York City where a company called Death-Cast contacts individuals — known as Deckers — shortly after midnight on the day they will die, giving them up to twenty-four hours of forewarning. Mateo Torrez, described as introverted and cautious, receives his call and decides to push against his own nature, downloading an app called Last Friend that connects lonely Deckers with companions for their End Day. Rufus Emeterio, by contrast, is caught mid-confrontation with his ex-girlfriend's new boyfriend when Death-Cast calls; he flees police involvement and turns to Last Friend so he won't face his last hours alone. The two meet through the app and spend their End Day together — visiting Mateo's comatose father in the hospital, saying goodbye to Mateo's best friend Lidia and her infant daughter, and confronting the unlived futures they had each imagined for themselves. Silvera structures the narrative around this single compressed day, weaving in subplots through secondary characters whose lives intersect with Mateo and Rufus as the hours count down.
Significance and Reception
Originally published on September 5, 2017, by HarperTeen, They Both Die at the End is Silvera's third novel. It earned a #1 New York Times bestseller designation and collected four starred reviews, along with recognition as a School Library Journal Best Book of the Year, a Kirkus Best Book of the Year, a Booklist Editors' Choice, and a Book Riot Best Queer Book, among other citations. Its cultural reach extended significantly in April 2020, when the #BookTok community on TikTok drove a major resurgence in readership, returning the novel to the New York Times Best Seller list years after its debut — a relatively rare trajectory that cemented its status as a generational YA touchstone rather than a single-season success.
Craft and Emotional Register
Kirkus Reviews described the novel as "another standout from Silvera who here grapples gracefully with heavy questions about death and the meaning of a life well-lived," while BuzzFeed wrote that Silvera "not only poignantly captures the raw emotion of facing your own mortality but also creates entirely relatable and authentic characters you'll want to follow on their journey." The audiobook adaptation, narrated by Michael Crouch, Robbie Daymond, and Bahni Turpin — voicing Mateo, Rufus, and additional perspectives respectively — received a favorable notice from Booklist, which noted that the voice actors brought "the full range of this story's anguish and joy to the listener," with Crouch and Daymond emphasizing "how the characters change yet remain true to themselves." The novel's thematic territory — mortality, the meaning of connection, personal choices and their consequences — is handled across both the central relationship and the supporting ensemble of characters whose stories briefly intersect with Mateo and Rufus's.
Genuine Limitations and Who May Struggle With It
The title is, by design, a spoiler — Silvera plants the ending in the book's name and never pretends otherwise. For readers who need narrative uncertainty to sustain emotional investment, that transparency may flatten tension across the novel's middle sections. The single-day structure, while thematically purposeful, also means the entire emotional arc — the development of Mateo and Rufus's relationship from strangers to deeply bonded companions — must be accepted as credible within an accelerated timeline. Readers who find compressed, high-stakes bonding narratives implausible may find the pacing demands more suspension of disbelief than they're willing to extend. This is a structural feature rather than a flaw, but it is worth naming honestly for prospective readers.
Who This Book Is For and Its Broader Life
Recommended for readers ages 13 and up, They Both Die at the End sits squarely in the YA romance and contemporary fiction space, with LGBTQ+ representation central to its story. A screen adaptation is in development with Bridgerton creator Chris Van Dusen attached to executive produce and write alongside Silvera himself. The novel is the first entry in a series. Readers drawn to YA that takes mortality and queer identity seriously — without flinching from grief but also without abandoning warmth — will find this book precisely calibrated to that intersection. Its longevity on bestseller lists and its #BookTok resurgence suggest it continues to find new readers well beyond its original publication window, which is itself a form of verdict.
Frequently Asked Questions
is They Both Die at the End by Adam Silvera worth reading if you already know how it ends
Yes — and that foreknowledge is actually the point. Kirkus Reviews called it "engrossing, contemplative and as heart-wrenching as the title promises," meaning Silvera earns the emotional payoff even though the ending is planted right in the title. That said, if you need narrative uncertainty to stay emotionally invested, the review honestly flags that the transparency can flatten tension in the middle sections.
what is They Both Die at the End by Adam Silvera actually about
It's set in a near-future New York City where a company called Death-Cast calls people — known as Deckers — shortly after midnight on the day they will die, giving them up to twenty-four hours of warning. Mateo Torrez and Rufus Emeterio each get that call and find each other through an app called Last Friend, then spend their End Day together visiting Mateo's comatose father, saying goodbye to his best friend Lidia and her infant daughter, and confronting the unlived futures they'd each imagined. The story is really about what it means to connect with someone — and to live fully — when time has already run out.
is They Both Die at the End by Adam Silvera ok for 13 year olds
Yes, ages 13 and up is the recommended starting point. The novel's sustained focus on mortality, grief, and the emotional weight of two teenagers facing certain death on the same day means it suits readers with some emotional maturity — younger readers may find the themes heavy rather than meaningful. There's no graphic violence or explicit content flagged, but the subject matter is unflinching throughout.
does the relationship between Mateo and Rufus in They Both Die at the End by Adam Silvera feel believable
This is the book's biggest ask of the reader. Because the entire story takes place in a single compressed day, the full emotional arc — from strangers to deeply bonded companions — has to land within an accelerated timeline, which the review honestly names as a structural feature that requires suspension of disbelief. BuzzFeed noted that Silvera "creates entirely relatable and authentic characters you'll want to follow on their journey," so many readers find it convincing, but if you're skeptical of high-stakes fast-bonding narratives, that's worth knowing going in.
is They Both Die at the End by Adam Silvera good for fans of LGBTQ+ YA
It's considered one of the defining examples of the genre — the review notes that LGBTQ+ representation is central to the story, not incidental, and it was recognized as a Book Riot Best Queer Book. Kirkus called it "another standout from Silvera who here grapples gracefully with heavy questions about death and the meaning of a life well-lived," and its #BookTok resurgence years after its 2017 debut suggests it keeps finding new queer readers who connect deeply with it.
is there a They Both Die at the End by Adam Silvera movie or TV adaptation coming
Yes, a screen adaptation is in development with Bridgerton creator Chris Van Dusen attached to executive produce and write alongside Silvera himself. No release date has been confirmed, but the creative pairing has generated significant anticipation among the book's fanbase.
is They Both Die at the End by Adam Silvera part of a series
Yes — it's the first entry in a series, so there's more story in that world if the premise grabs you. The novel stands fully on its own, though; nothing about the central story of Mateo and Rufus is left unresolved in a cliffhanger way, which fits with the fact that the title tells you exactly how their day ends.
Sources & Further Reading
The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.
- Cited in this review
- 1
- 2
en.wikipedia.org
- 3
- Further reading
- 4
Adam Silvera, Wikipedia
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
openbooksummary.com
- 9
thegrizzlynews.org
- 10
- 11
- 12
- 13
- 14
thestorysanctuary.com
- 15
barnesandnoble.com
Related Reviews
Reviews of books we picked for readers who enjoyed They Both Die at the End.
Reader Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!