Skip to content
Reviewed

Updated

Read Time

8 min read

Our age bandAdult
Reader rating
4.4 · 38,198 Amazon ratings
reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review
The Dictionary of Lost Words: Reese's Book Club: A Novel by Pip Williams front cover

Our review

The Dictionary of Lost Words

The Dictionary of Lost Words by Pip Williams Review: A Richly Researched Historical Fiction Debut

Pip Williams's debut novel, a New York Times bestseller and the first Australian novel selected for Reese Witherspoon's Book Club, weaves a fictional narrative through the real history of the Oxford English Dictionary's creation, centering the women and words that were left out of the official record.

Our age band: Adultwartime death and loss · women's suffrage-era political violence

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Readers drawn to character-driven historical fiction with an intellectual backbone — particularly those with an interest in language, literary history, the women's suffrage movement, or the making of the Oxford English Dictionary.

Worth it if

You want to be fully absorbed into a richly detailed period world that smuggles serious questions about power, gender, and whose language gets to be recorded into an emotionally resonant story.

Skip if

You prefer plot-driven momentum over immersive, deliberately expansive pacing — the novel commits fully to a 19th-century narrative tempo that may test readers who like a faster-moving story.

Kirkus Reviews called the novel "a satisfying amalgam of truth and historical fiction," noting that Williams illuminates why women needed to be present when history was being written, while bookmarks.Reviews aggregate critics' praise for an "exuberant, meticulously researched debut" whose "feminist take on language will move readers," even as both note the narrative takes some time to build momentum. The Guardian situated the novel within the real history of the OED's compilation, framing it as a "gentle, hopeful story" exploring how words take on different meanings for men and women.

“A satisfying amalgam of truth and historical fiction. Williams illuminates why women needed to be in the room where, and when, it's written.”

— kirkusreviews.com
Sources: Kirkus Reviews, bookmarks.reviews, The Guardian
4.4from 38,198 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

Christina from Christina Campbell Books reviews The Dictionary of Lost Words

Christina reviews Pip Williams' historical fiction novel The Dictionary of Lost Words.

A BookTube review by Christina Campbell Books, 2022 · 3.5K views · 1.8K subscribers · Watch on YouTube ·

Their views, not ours. The points are our AI summary of what they say, each playing from where they say it.

Another view · mixed feelings
The presenter has a strong personal fondness for the book because its Oxford setting helped them get acquainted with the city after relocating there. However, they found the writing and overall narrative far from exceptional. They note that the novel feels rather plotless and attempts to cover too many themes without giving them sufficient depth. Ultimately, while they enjoyed the exploration of language and social history, they feel the book may not work for readers who prefer tightly plotted stories. Coynie Reads on YouTube

Emotional character journeys

Christina formed a deep attachment to Esme and the surrounding cast as Esme aged, which made the story poignant enough to bring them to tears repeatedly.

Linguistics and words focus

Christina appreciated how central words and dictionary compilation were to the premise, noting that lovers of linguistics will especially appreciate the novel.

Blending real history with fiction

Christina praised how Williams used real-life details, such as the missing word 'bondmaid' from the Oxford English Dictionary and historical figures, to anchor the fictional story.

Mid-book pacing lull

Around one-third into the novel, Christina found the pace slowed and their interest waned, though the narrative quickly drew them back in by the middle.

Ask LuvemBooks

Was this helpful?

The Dictionary of Lost Words is Pip Williams's debut historical novel, following Esme — a girl raised among the editors of the Oxford English Dictionary — as she secretly collects the words deemed unworthy of the official record, weaving together the women's suffrage movement and the First World War into a richly researched portrait of whose language gets preserved and whose gets erased. A New York Times bestseller and the first Australian novel selected for Reese Witherspoon's Book Club, it earns praise from critics as "an imaginative love letter to dictionaries" with genuine emotional and political weight. Readers who prize immersive, character-driven historical fiction with an intellectual backbone will find it deeply rewarding — but those who prefer fast-paced plotting should be aware that Williams commits fully to the expansive, detail-dense tempo of 19th-century storytelling.
Is it worth reading?
For its intended audience, The Dictionary of Lost Words delivers handsomely. Bookreporter notes that Williams 'will convince you of a word's importance in a most lovely and charismatic story,' and fellow author Marie Benedict described it as 'a delight and an education.' The key caveat: those who prefer plot-driven momentum over the immersive, detail-dense pacing of a 19th-century-style novel may find the tempo a challenge.
Similar books
Readers who enjoy The Dictionary of Lost Words tend to gravitate toward historical fiction that centers women's voices in richly researched period settings. Carnegie's Maid by Marie Benedict — who herself praised Williams's novel — similarly reconstructs the hidden contributions of a woman operating in the shadow of a famous man. The Alice Network by Kate Quinn shares the suffrage-era and wartime backdrop alongside a focus on women whose work went unacknowledged. March by Geraldine Brooks, like Williams's novel, reimagines a familiar history from a perspective the official record left out. Trust by Hernan Diaz is another formally inventive literary novel that interrogates whose version of events gets written down and preserved. All five are rendered on the cards below.
Who should read this?
The Dictionary of Lost Words is designed for readers drawn to character-driven historical fiction with an intellectual backbone — those who enjoy novels that, as the review puts it, 'smuggle serious questions about power, gender, and representation into richly detailed period settings.' Readers with a particular interest in language, literary history, or the Edwardian suffrage era are especially well served. Those who prefer faster-paced plotting over immersive, detail-dense prose are the one group most likely to find it a mismatch.
What are the main themes?
At its core, The Dictionary of Lost Words interrogates who holds the power to define a language — and by extension, to define history itself. The novel argues that the OED's official record reflects a history written by men, and that an entire parallel vocabulary of women's experience was quietly discarded. Woven through this are the interconnected themes of gender and class (the words excluded belong to women and the working class), the politics of knowledge and representation, and the way institutional authority shapes cultural memory. The suffrage movement and the First World War amplify these themes by showing Esme's world in active, violent transformation.
Is this a good book club pick?
The Dictionary of Lost Words is a strong book club choice, particularly for groups who enjoy discussing questions of power, representation, and history alongside character-driven storytelling. Its selection for Reese Witherspoon's Book Club — a programme built around communal reading and discussion — signals that the novel's themes translate well into group conversation. The interplay between Esme's personal stakes, the OED's real editorial history, and the suffrage and wartime context gives clubs rich thematic terrain. The novel's deliberately expansive pace also rewards the kind of close, attentive reading that book club formats encourage.
Is this Pip Williams's only book?
The review covers The Dictionary of Lost Words as Pip Williams's debut novel. No other works by Williams are discussed in LuvemBooks' coverage, so readers curious about her broader bibliography are encouraged to check a bookseller or library catalogue for her most current titles. The debut's reception — a New York Times bestseller, Reese's Book Club pick, and warm critical response — has given Williams a substantial platform for any subsequent work.
Summarize this book

Summarize this book

Set during the decades-long creation of the Oxford English Dictionary, The Dictionary of Lost Words follows Esme, who grows up literally beneath the table where her father and his colleagues assemble the great lexicographical project. She begins collecting the words that fall through the cracks — terms used by women, the working class, and those whose speech the official compilers judged unworthy of record. Against the backdrop of the women's suffrage movement and the approaching First World War, the novel builds a fictional 'shadow dictionary' that poses the question: who decides which words — and whose experiences — deserve to be preserved in the historical record?

Follow up

What is the 'shadow dictionary' idea?
Is the OED history in the novel real?
How does the First World War fit in?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

Ask LuvemBooks

What would you like to know about The Dictionary of Lost Words?

Answers come from our editorial notes on this book. If we haven't covered something, we'll say so.

Readers often ask

Our Review

We review the evidence: published reviews and reader verdicts, gathered and weighed with AI assistance and edited by LuvemBooks, rather than one reader's first-hand take.

A New York Times bestseller and Reese's Book Club pick, The Dictionary of Lost Words is a work of historical fiction grounded in the actual archives of the Oxford English Dictionary and inspired by real events.

What the Novel Is and What It Argues

The Dictionary of Lost Words is a historical novel set during the making of the Oxford English Dictionary, spanning the height of the women's suffrage movement and the approach of the Great War. Its central character, Esme, grows up literally beneath the table where the great lexicographical project is being assembled — her father one of its editors — and she begins collecting the words that fall through the cracks: terms used by women, by the working class, by those whose speech the official compilers deemed unworthy of record.
The novel's animating argument, embedded in its fiction, is that the English language as codified in the OED reflects a history written by men, and that an entire parallel vocabulary of women's experience was quietly left behind. As publisher Penguin Random House describes it, the novel "reveals a lost narrative, hidden between the lines of a history written by men."

The Research and Historical Foundation

This depth of preparation is visible in the novel's construction: as penguinrandomhouse.com notes, Williams "provides readers with detailed background and biographical information pointing to extensive research about the Oxford English Dictionary and its editors." The result is a dual portrait — of one of the English-speaking world's most ambitious intellectual undertakings and of the women who contributed to it largely without credit.
The suffrage movement and the First World War are not backdrop decoration but structural forces that shape Esme's world and the fate of the words she is trying to preserve.

Critical Reception and Distinction

The novel earned significant recognition on publication. It became a New York Times bestseller and holds the distinction of being the first Australian novel selected for Reese Witherspoon's Book Club.
Critical commentary from named outlets has been warm. Critics called it "a lexicographer's dream of a novel" and "an imaginative love letter to dictionaries."
Bookreporter described how Williams "will convince you of a word's importance in a most lovely and charismatic story." The New York Times, as quoted by Penguin Random House's promotional materials, called it "delightful… a captivating and slyly subversive fictional paean to the real women whose work on the Oxford English Dictionary" shaped the language.
Reviewing the novel for The Sydney Morning Herald, Jo Case wrote that Williams "combines the storytelling scale and intimate detail of a 19th-century novel" with a contemporary sensibility. Blurb praise from fellow authors has also been notable: Marie Benedict, author of The Mystery of Mrs. Christie, described it as "a marvelous exploration into the ways in which spoken and written language impact us" that is "a delight and an education."
Interior page with a decorative bracket and descriptive text about the book's celebration of language and words.
Interior page with a decorative bracket and descriptive text about the book's celebration of language and words.

Strengths: Concept, Voice, and Scope

The novel's central conceit — that an ordinary girl raised among lexicographers becomes the archivist of a shadow dictionary — is both inventive and emotionally coherent. Susan Wiggs, author of The Lost and Found Bookshop, called it "charming, inventive, and utterly irresistible," adding that it is "the story we all need right now."
The dual timelines of the OED's compilation and the suffrage movement give the book its structural tension, while Esme's personal stakes — what language we keep, what we discard, and who decides — give it contemporary resonance. Williams's debut is notable precisely because it transforms what could have been a niche historical curiosity (the making of a dictionary) into a story with broad emotional and political stakes.

Who This Novel Is Best Suited For

The Dictionary of Lost Words is designed for readers drawn to character-driven historical fiction with an intellectual backbone — those who enjoy novels that smuggle serious questions about power, gender, and representation into richly detailed period settings. Readers with an interest in language, literary history, or the suffrage era are particularly well served.
Those who prefer faster-paced plotting over immersive, detail-dense storytelling may find the novel's deliberately expansive pace a challenge; the book commits fully to the tempo and texture of its 19th-century narrative model. But for its intended audience — readers who want to be absorbed into a world as much as driven through a plot — Williams's debut delivers a narrative that multiple critics have described as both educational and genuinely compelling.

Sources & Further Reading

The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

  1. Cited in this review
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. Further reading
  5. 3
  6. 4
  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8
  11. 9
  12. 10
  13. 11

    Kirkus Reviews

  14. 12

    bookmarks.reviews

  15. 13

    The Guardian

Age & Reading Level

Our age band

Adult

Our age band groups books for browsing; it isn't an age a review gave.

Content to know about

wartime death and loss
women's suffrage-era political violence

Skip if you want a fast-paced, plot-driven story rather than a slow-burn, immersive historical narrative.

From our readers

Reader reviews

No LuvemBooks readers have answered yet.

Read it? Was it right for you?

Books like The Dictionary of Lost Words

Curated picks for readers who enjoyed The Dictionary of Lost Words, with our reasoning for each match.

If you liked The Dictionary of Lost Words

Discussion

Reader comments