BOOKS
Published
Read Time
9 min read
Reader ratingreader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
4.8
· 2,122 Amazon ratingsShare This Review
A Game of Thrones: The Illustrated Edition by George R. R. Martin Review: A Landmark Fantasy Reimagined in Visual Splendor
Published by Random House Worlds on October 18, 2016, to mark the twentieth anniversary of the original 1996 Bantam Books release, A Game of Thrones: The Illustrated Edition is a hardcover collector's edition of George R. R. Martin's genre-defining fantasy novel — the opening volume of the A Song of Ice and Fire series — featuring 8 full-color illustrations and more than 70 black-and-white illustrations, alongside a foreword by John Hodgman. The underlying novel has earned a reputation as one of the most consequential works in modern epic fantasy; this edition repackages it as a prestige physical object for devoted fans and new readers alike. Because this review has not examined the physical edition firsthand, assessment of art reproduction, paper quality, and binding is deferred to the buyer's own judgment.
LuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Devoted fans of A Song of Ice and Fire or HBO's Game of Thrones who already love the novel and want a premium, anniversary-grade hardcover edition — ideally as a gift or collector's upgrade — illustrated with more than 70 black-and-white images and 8 full-color plates giving visual form to Westeros.
Worth it if
You want a celebratory, shelf-worthy physical object built around a text that earned starred and best-of-year notices at its original release, and you can assess the art reproduction and binding quality in person before buying.
Skip if
You're coming to A Game of Thrones purely for the story on a budget — the underlying text is identical to far cheaper paperback or e-book editions, and at 896 pages of dense, multi-POV narrative, the illustrated edition does nothing to ease a demanding read.
What readers & critics say
The original novel earned a starred review from critical coverage (cited on randomhousebooks.com) for its "superbly developed characters, accomplished prose, and sheer bloodymindedness," while Locus placed it "well above the norms of the genre" and BookPage called it "inventive and intricately plotted" — a chorus of approval this illustrated anniversary edition relies on. Reviewer Kitty Marie (kittymariebookreviews.home.blog) noted that 19 contributing artists produce a surprisingly consistent and harmonious result, with each illustration occupying a full page, while Novel Notions (novelnotions.net) praised the edition's production value as "freaking gorgeous" though flagged occasional misalignment between illustrated scenes and their chapter placement.
Sources: randomhousebooks.com, kittymariebookreviews.home.blog, novelnotions.net4.8from 2,122 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Look inside the book
Preview the actual pages, via Google BooksIn This Review
- What Works & What Doesn't
- What the Book Is and What It Contains
- The Novel's Standing in the Genre
- The Illustrated Edition's Design Intent
- Genuine Strengths
- Limitations and Who Should Pause
What Works & What Doesn't
What Works
- The complete, critically acclaimed text of one of modern epic fantasy's most celebrated novels, praised by critical coverage (starred review), the Denver Post, the Chicago Sun-Times, Locus, and BookPage at its original release
- Published as a twenty-anniversary collector's edition by Random House Worlds, with 8 full-color illustrations and more than 70 black-and-white illustrations giving visual form to Westeros
- A foreword by John Hodgman adds a distinct cultural framing to the volume
- Two endpaper maps extend the world-building and enhance the edition's reference value
- Book 1 of 4 in the A Song of Ice and Fire Illustrated Edition series, allowing collectors to build a matched set
What Doesn't
- The edition's value rests heavily on the physical object — art reproduction, paper, and binding — which cannot be assessed without handling the book in person
- At a premium price point over standard editions, it is a collectible upgrade rather than a practical first read for the budget-conscious
- The underlying 896-page text is unchanged from other editions; readers who found Martin's dense, multi-POV structure challenging will not find it eased here
A sweeping anniversary collector's edition of one of modern fantasy's most celebrated novels, designed for fans who want the full world of Westeros between two covers — though the physical object itself must be evaluated in person.
What the Book Is and What It Contains
A Game of Thrones: The Illustrated Edition (A Song of Ice and Fire Illustrated Edition) by George R. R. Martin front cover
A Game of Thrones is the first novel in George R. R. Martin's ongoing epic fantasy series, A Song of Ice and Fire, originally published by Bantam Books in the United States in 1996. This illustrated edition, released by Random House Worlds on October 18, 2016 — twenty years after that debut — presents the complete text of the novel in a hardcover format, accompanied by 8 full-color illustrations and more than 70 black-and-white illustrations. A foreword by writer and humorist John Hodgman opens the volume. The edition is designated Book 1 of 4 in the A Song of Ice and Fire Illustrated Edition series, placing it at the head of a matched set that continues with illustrated editions of A Clash of Kings, A Storm of Swords, and A Feast for Crows.
“the major fantasy of the decade... Compulsively readable.”
The novel itself is set in the Seven Kingdoms of Westeros, where the noble House Stark — led by Lord Eddard Stark — is drawn into the lethal political machinery of King's Landing after Eddard is summoned south to serve as Hand of the King. The publisher's synopsis describes a world of plots and counterplots, tragedy and betrayal, in which the fate of the Starks, their allies, and their enemies hangs on the deadliest of conflicts: the game of thrones. Simultaneously, across the Narrow Sea, the exiled Prince Viserys of House Targaryen schemes to reclaim Westeros with a Dothraki army — offering his sister Daenerys as the price of their loyalty. Two maps covering the territory of Westeros appear on the endpapers.
The Novel's Standing in the Genre
The underlying text is, by any measure, one of the defining works of contemporary epic fantasy. Publishers Weekly awarded it a starred review, citing its superbly developed characters, accomplished prose, and — in their words — sheer bloodymindedness. The Denver Post called it "the major fantasy of the decade... Compulsively readable." The Chicago Sun-Times described Martin's achievement as "an intensely realized, romantic but realistic world." Locus placed it "well above the norms of the genre." BookPage named it a Best Book of 1996 and praised it as inventive and intricately plotted. That chorus of critical approval, accumulated at the novel's original release, is what this illustrated edition is banking on — the text itself arrived fully formed and well-regarded from the start.
George R. R. Martin is the #1 New York Times bestselling author of the A Song of Ice and Fire series, a credential that reflects the enormous popular audience the books have sustained across decades, amplified further by HBO's television adaptation.
The Illustrated Edition's Design Intent
This edition exists explicitly as a celebration — Random House Worlds positioned it as a dazzling anniversary release for readers of the series and fans of HBO's Game of Thrones. The illustration program is substantial: more than 70 black-and-white images woven through the text, plus 8 full-color plates, together designed to give visual form to a world that millions of readers have long inhabited only in imagination. The two endpaper maps extend that world-building function. Because LuvemBooks has not examined the physical edition firsthand, no judgment is offered here on the quality of color reproduction, paper weight, or the integration of illustrations with the text — those remain the buyer's own assessment to make, ideally by handling the volume before purchase.
Genuine Strengths
For fans who have read the novel in its standard paperback or e-book form, the illustrated edition offers a clear value proposition: a premium hardcover object, built around an anniversary milestone, with a named foreword contributor and a generous illustration count. The foreword by John Hodgman adds a distinct cultural voice to frame the text's significance. The edition's place as Book 1 of 4 in a matched illustrated series means collectors can assemble a visually unified set across the first four volumes. The novel's own merits — its densely realized political intrigue, its large and carefully differentiated cast, its willingness to overturn conventional fantasy expectations — are intact and unchanged, as confirmed by the critical record.
Limitations and Who Should Pause
The illustrated edition's most honest limitation is structural: it is a premium-priced physical collectible built around a text available in far less expensive formats. Readers coming to A Game of Thrones purely for the story have no shortage of accessible options. The value of this edition rests almost entirely on the physical object — the reproduction quality, the feel of the illustrations on the page, the heft and presentation of the hardcover — and that is precisely what a written review cannot reliably convey. Readers who have found Martin's densely plotted, multi-POV narrative demanding in the standard edition will not find it transformed here; the text is the same, and at 896 pages in hardcover, it remains a substantial commitment. This is a gift-tier purchase or a collector's upgrade, not an entry point for the casually curious.
Frequently Asked Questions
is A Game of Thrones: The Illustrated Edition by George R. R. Martin worth buying if i already own the regular version
It depends on whether you want a premium physical collectible or just the story. The review is clear that this edition's value rests almost entirely on the physical object — the reproduction quality, the feel of the illustrations on the page, the heft and presentation of the hardcover — and describes it as a gift-tier purchase or a collector's upgrade, not an entry point for the casually curious. If you already own a cheaper copy, the text is identical, so the upgrade only makes sense if the illustrated format genuinely appeals to you.
What is this book actually about
At its core, it follows House Stark — led by Lord Eddard Stark — being dragged into the lethal political machinery of King's Landing after Eddard is summoned south to serve as Hand of the King. Simultaneously, across the Narrow Sea, the exiled Prince Viserys of House Targaryen schemes to retake Westeros using a Dothraki army, offering his sister Daenerys as the price of their loyalty. The review describes it as a world of plots and counterplots, tragedy and betrayal, set across the Seven Kingdoms of Westeros.
Is this book appropriate for teens
This edition is rated for adults and mature readers 16 and older. The review flags graphic violence, political brutality, and sexual content — including scenes involving a young teenage character — as reasons this isn't suitable for younger readers. Parents should weigh those elements carefully before handing it to a teenager.
Is this book too long
At 896 pages in hardcover, the review is straightforward that it remains a substantial commitment, and that readers who have found Martin's densely plotted, multi-POV narrative demanding in the standard edition will not find it transformed here — the text is the same. That said, the Denver Post called it "compulsively readable" and Publishers Weekly gave it a starred review, so the length hasn't stopped dedicated readers.
How many illustrations are in this book
The edition includes 8 full-color illustrations and more than 70 black-and-white illustrations woven through the text, plus two endpaper maps covering the territory of Westeros. The review notes this is a substantial illustration program designed to give visual form to a world that millions of readers have long inhabited only in imagination, though it cautions that the actual quality of color reproduction and paper can only be judged by handling the book in person.
What should i read after this book
The review places this as Book 1 of 4 in the A Song of Ice and Fire Illustrated Edition series, so the natural next steps in the same matched collector's set are the illustrated editions of A Clash of Kings, A Storm of Swords, and A Feast for Crows. Collectors can assemble a visually unified set across all four volumes, which the review identifies as a clear part of this edition's value proposition.
Is this book good for people who haven't read the series before
The review says the edition was positioned by Random House Worlds for both readers of the series and fans of HBO's Game of Thrones, so new readers are welcome — the complete original text is intact. However, the honest caveat is that this is a premium-priced collectible, and readers coming to A Game of Thrones purely for the story have no shortage of far less expensive options in paperback or e-book form.
Sources & Further Reading
The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.
- Cited in this review
- 1
- 2
- Further reading
- 3
George R. R. Martin, Wikipedia
- 4
- 5
en.wikipedia.org
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
bookmarks.reviews
- 11
- 12
- 13
Related Reviews
Reviews of books we picked for readers who enjoyed A Game of Thrones.
Reader Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!