BOOKS
Published

Read Time

3 min read

Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review

A Clash of Kings: The Illustrated Edition by George R. R. Martin Review: A Collector's Showcase of Westeros at War

Published by Random House Worlds in November 2019, this hardcover illustrated edition of A Clash of Kings — the second novel in George R. R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire — pairs the full text of the Locus Award-winning epic fantasy with over twenty new illustrations by artist Lauren K. Cannon, alongside a foreword by Bernard Cornwell, making it the definitive collector's presentation of the War of Five Kings.

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Dedicated fans of A Song of Ice and Fire who already own or have read A Game of Thrones and want a premium, display-worthy hardcover of A Clash of Kings enriched with Lauren K. Cannon's newly commissioned illustrations and Bernard Cornwell's foreword.

Worth it if

You are an existing series devotee seeking a collector's centrepiece that pairs the complete, Locus Award-winning text of A Clash of Kings with over twenty all-new illustrations in a major-publisher hardcover format — and you are prepared to verify the physical production quality through hands-on collector impressions before buying.

Skip if

If you are new to Westeros and plan to start here, or if the illustrated edition's higher price point is only justified for you by exceptional print and binding quality that this editorial review cannot independently confirm.

What readers & critics say

Wikipedia's reception record shows the underlying novel earned strong critical praise on original publication, with Bradley H. Sinor of the Tulsa World crediting Martin for keeping "readers balanced on a sword's edge" and judging that A Clash of Kings "grips the reader whether or not they read the earlier book." Kirkus Reviews, while flagging the book's demanding 896-page length and its lack of any recap for new readers, acknowledged that fans of the inaugural volume "will certainly plunge right in," implicitly endorsing the series' grip on its audience.

Martin keeps readers balanced on a sword's edge — the novel grips, tells a satisfying story, and leaves you wanting the next book.

Bradley H. Sinor, Tulsa World (via Wikipedia)

The inaugural volume was both admirable and eye-popping, so fans will certainly plunge right in — all 896 pages of it.

Kirkus Reviews
Sources: Wikipedia – A Clash of Kings, Kirkus Reviews
4.8from 1,161 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

Look inside the book

Preview the actual pages, via Google Books
In This Review
  • What Works & What Doesn't
  • What the Book Contains and What It Depicts
  • The Novel's Standing in the Genre
  • The Illustrated Edition's Distinctive Additions
  • Honest Limitations for Prospective Buyers
  • Who This Edition Is For

What Works & What Doesn't

What Works
  • Pairs the full, Locus Award-winning text of A Clash of Kings with over twenty all-new illustrations by Lauren K. Cannon, in both color and black-and-white — a visual addition entirely new to this Random House Worlds edition
  • Includes a foreword by Bernard Cornwell, reinforcing the novel's reputation for historical texture and moral complexity within the epic fantasy genre
  • The underlying novel earned widespread critical praise on original publication, with reviewers citing Martin's world-building as lending 'the feeling of medieval history rather than fiction'
  • Part of an ongoing illustrated series covering multiple A Song of Ice and Fire titles, making it a natural centerpiece for a series collection
  • Brings together one of the most consequential multi-POV narratives in modern fantasy — the War of Five Kings — in a premium hardcover format from a major publisher
What Doesn't
  • Readers new to the series will find this edition assumes prior knowledge of A Game of Thrones, as it is the second volume in a seven-book sequence
  • The purchase decision for this illustrated edition rests significantly on the physical production quality — paper, reproduction, and binding — which this editorial review cannot assess from the published record alone
  • At over twenty illustrations across nearly 900 pages of dense, multi-threaded narrative, the visual additions are relatively sparse relative to the novel's full scope
  • The premium hardcover format and collector positioning carry a higher price point than standard trade editions of the same text
This illustrated edition of A Clash of Kings is the collector's format that dedicated fans of Martin's series have been waiting for, pairing one of epic fantasy's most acclaimed novels with original visual art in a substantial hardcover package from Random House Worlds.

What the Book Contains and What It Depicts

A Clash of Kings: The Illustrated Edition (A Song of Ice and Fire Illustrated Edition) by George R. R. Martin front cover
A Clash of Kings: The Illustrated Edition (A Song of Ice and Fire Illustrated Edition) by George R. R. Martin front cover
At its core, this is the complete text of A Clash of Kings, the second of seven planned novels in George R. R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire series. The story depicts the Seven Kingdoms of Westeros plunged into civil war following the death of King Robert Baratheon. With Robert's purported son Joffrey seated uneasily on the Iron Throne, both of Robert's brothers — Renly and Stannis Baratheon — press rival claims, while Robb Stark is proclaimed King in the North and Balon Greyjoy declares himself king of the Iron Islands. This conflict, known as the War of Five Kings, forms the central dramatic engine of the novel. Simultaneously, Jon Snow rides north with the Night's Watch on a reconnaissance into wildling territory, and Daenerys Targaryen pursues her own campaign to reclaim the Iron Throne from across the Narrow Sea. Key figures navigating these interlocking crises include Tyrion Lannister, who arrives in King's Landing to serve as Hand of the King; Catelyn Stark, who attempts — and fails — to broker alliances between the rival claimants; Brienne of Tarth; and the mysterious Melisandre, a foreign priestess whose belief that Stannis is a prophesied messianic figure drives some of the novel's most consequential and violent turns. The publisher's description frames the whole against "a backdrop of incest and fratricide, alchemy and murder," with the moral that "victory may go to the men and women possessed of the coldest steel… and the coldest hearts."

The Novel's Standing in the Genre

A Clash of Kings first appeared in the United Kingdom in November 1998, with the first United States edition following in February 1999. Like its predecessor, A Game of Thrones, the novel won the Locus Award for Best Novel (in 1999) and received a Nebula Award nomination the same year — a double achievement that underscored Martin's rapid ascent as a defining voice in epic fantasy. As Wikipedia's reception summary notes, Dorman Shindler of The Dallas Morning News described the novel as "one of the best [works] in this particular subgenre," praising "the richness of this invented world and its cultures… [that] lends Mr. Martin's novels the feeling of medieval history rather than fiction." Bradley H. Sinor of the Tulsa World credited Martin with keeping "readers balanced on a sword's edge." That critical foundation, established more than two decades ago, is what this illustrated edition invites readers to revisit in a new format. Martin is identified by his publisher as the #1 New York Times bestselling author of the series.

The Illustrated Edition's Distinctive Additions

What separates this hardcover from standard trade editions is the commissioning of Lauren K. Cannon as illustrator, producing over twenty all-new illustrations rendered in both color and black-and-white. These images are designed to bring the action of the War of Five Kings to life visually — representing an interpretive layer that no previous standard edition of A Clash of Kings has offered. (A separate limited illustrated edition, produced by Meisha Merlin in 2005, featured artwork by John Howe, making Cannon's contribution entirely original to this Random House Worlds release.) The edition also includes a foreword by Bernard Cornwell, the celebrated author of the Sharpe and Saxon Stories historical fiction series — a pairing that speaks to the novel's reputation for grounding high fantasy in the texture and moral complexity of medieval history. This is part of an ongoing illustrated series from the same publisher covering multiple A Song of Ice and Fire titles.

Honest Limitations for Prospective Buyers

Because this review is prepared from the published record rather than from firsthand examination of the physical object, an honest scope statement is warranted: the quality of Cannon's illustration reproduction, the paper stock, and the overall production values of this hardcover edition cannot be assessed here as observed fact. Readers making a purchase decision primarily on the strength of the visual component — which is, after all, the edition's defining addition — are advised to seek out hands-on impressions from collectors who have handled the book. What the verified record confirms is the illustration count (over twenty) and the mixed color-and-black-and-white format; beyond that, the physical reading experience remains outside the scope of this editorial review. Additionally, readers new to the series should note that this is the second volume — the narrative assumes familiarity with the events and cast of A Game of Thrones.

Who This Edition Is For

This illustrated edition is squarely aimed at existing fans of the series who want a premium, display-worthy version of a novel they already prize, rather than at first-time readers approaching Westeros cold. The combination of Cannon's newly commissioned art, Cornwell's foreword, and the Random House Worlds hardcover format positions it as a collector's object first. For readers who have long inhabited Martin's world of shifting alliances, shadow assassins, and five kings jockeying for a single throne, this edition offers a reason to return to A Clash of Kings with fresh eyes — and now, with original images to accompany one of epic fantasy's most consequential second acts.

Sources & Further Reading

The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

  1. Cited in this review
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. Further reading
  5. 3

    George R. R. Martin, Wikipedia

  6. 4
  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8
  11. 9
  12. 10
  13. 11
  14. 12