How to Be a Stoic: Using Ancient Philosophy to Live a Modern Life by Massimo Pigliucci cover

How to Be a Stoic: Using Ancient Philosophy to Live a Modern Life

by Massimo Pigliucci

$12.00 on AmazonRead our full review

At a glance

Pages240
First published2017
AudienceAdult
ISBN1541644530

About the Author

Massimo Pigliucci

1 book reviewed

View author →

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Readers new to Stoic philosophy who want a serious, philosophically grounded introduction — not a motivational quick-fix — and who are navigating real questions about control, resilience, and ethical living.

Worth it if

You want more than a motivational gloss on Stoicism and are willing to engage with philosophical argument, including an imaginary dialogue with Epictetus, as a vehicle for understanding how ancient ideas apply to modern dilemmas.

Skip if

You're looking for a purely prescriptive, step-by-step self-help manual, or you're already deeply versed in academic Stoic scholarship — the pace will feel introductory and Pigliucci's comparative case against Buddhism and Aristotelianism may feel brisk rather than balanced.

What readers & critics say

The Philosopher's Magazine praises the book as "an excellent advertisement to general audiences not only for Stoicism, but also for philosophy in general," singling out its success in moving beyond the cold, caricatured image of Stoic thought. Donald Robertson, writing on his own site (donaldrobertson.name), describes it as a lucid, engaging, and persuasive guide to pursuing Stoic ideals in the present day, noting Pigliucci's candour in committing to Stoicism while remaining open to revision where modern science or philosophy has advanced beyond the ancients.

Sources: The Philosopher's Magazine (archive), Donald Robertson (donaldrobertson.name), Immoderate Stoic, StoryGraph, Words Like Silver
4.5from 1,587 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

Look inside the book

Preview the actual pages, via Google Books

Ask LuvemBooks

Was this helpful?

How to Be a Stoic: Using Ancient Philosophy to Live a Modern Life by Massimo Pigliucci is a philosophically rigorous yet accessible primer that walks readers through the core tenets of Stoicism — the dichotomy of control, virtue as the highest good, and the Stoic approach to emotion and mortality — via an imaginary dialogue with the ancient teacher Epictetus. Praised by Donald J. Robertson as "a lucid, engaging, and persuasive" guide, the book distinguishes itself from motivational self-help by offering intellectual honesty, including Pigliucci's own admission that ancient Stoics were "overly optimistic about how much control human beings have." It is best suited to curious general readers who want a serious, author-credentialed entry into Stoic practice; those expecting a step-by-step self-help manual may find the philosophical scaffolding demanding.
Is it worth reading?
For readers curious about Stoicism who want more than a motivational gloss, How to Be a Stoic offers a well-regarded, philosophically grounded entry point that has earned endorsements from serious voices in the field. Donald J. Robertson — author of How to Think Like a Roman Emperor — has described it as "a lucid, engaging, and persuasive book about what it means to pursue Stoic ideals in the here and now," and The Philosopher's Magazine credits it with moving beyond stereotypical readings of Stoicism. The book's intellectual honesty, including its own acknowledgment of the limits of classical Stoic thinking, distinguishes it from more evangelistic self-help fare. Readers already steeped in academic Stoic scholarship may find the pace introductory, but as a credentialed, accessible primer it remains a frequently cited starting point in the genre.
Similar books
Readers who enjoy How to Be a Stoic will find rich companions in the primary Stoic sources Pigliucci draws upon: Marcus Aurelius's Meditations is the foundational Stoic text most directly referenced, and Seneca's Letters from a Stoic offers the same blend of philosophical depth and personal application from another towering classical voice. For those drawn to resilience and meaning-making under adversity, Viktor E. Frankl's Man's Search for Meaning approaches similar existential territory from a psychological rather than philosophical angle. Jonathan Haidt's The Righteous Mind pairs well for readers interested in how moral psychology and ethics intersect in modern life. Ryan Holiday's The Daily Stoic covers adjacent ground in a more accessible, aphorism-driven format, though it is not currently in the LuvemBooks catalogue.
Who should read this?
How to Be a Stoic is best suited to general readers who are curious about ancient philosophy's most practical tradition and want a serious, intellectually honest introduction — not a motivational quick-fix. People navigating questions of control, resilience, and ethical living will find a structured, philosophically grounded companion. It is also a strong choice for readers who have encountered Stoic ideas through popular culture and want the philosophical substance behind them. Those already deeply versed in academic Stoic scholarship, or committed practitioners of Buddhism or Aristotelianism who may find Pigliucci's dismissals of those traditions brisk, are less obvious fits.
What are the main themes?
The book's central themes are control, virtue, resilience, and the examined life. The dichotomy of control — distinguishing what is genuinely within our power from what is not — anchors the practical framework, while the cultivation of virtue as the highest good provides its ethical core. Pigliucci also engages with Stoic perspectives on emotion (rejecting the caricature of Stoicism as joyless emotional suppression), social relationships, mortality, and the question of how ancient wisdom can be adapted honestly to modern dilemmas. The book's meta-theme is philosophical integrity: how to adopt a life framework without ignoring its known limitations.
Is it philosophically rigorous or dumbed down?
The book's primary design achievement, as the LuvemBooks review describes it, is bridging rigorous philosophical source material and a general readership without sacrificing intellectual seriousness. The Philosopher's Magazine credits Pigliucci with moving beyond stereotypical readings of Stoicism, and the book's own candid acknowledgment that the ancient Stoics were "overly optimistic about how much control human beings have" signals the kind of intellectual honesty absent from more evangelical popular treatments. Pigliucci draws directly on Epictetus's Discourses and Marcus Aurelius, giving full credit to original source material rather than paraphrasing without attribution — a discipline noted approvingly by readers on StoryGraph. It is accessible, but not oversimplified.
Where should I start with Pigliucci?
How to Be a Stoic is widely regarded as an accessible and representative entry point into Pigliucci's work for readers new to philosophy. His other books include Nonsense on Stilts: How to Tell Science from Bunk, which reflects his background in the philosophy of science, though that title is not currently in the LuvemBooks catalogue. For readers drawn specifically to his Stoic work, How to Be a Stoic remains the most frequently cited starting point, with his broader philosophical output rewarding those who want to follow the intellectual journey he outlines in the book.
Summarize this book

Summarize this book

How to Be a Stoic is a work of popular philosophy structured as an extended imaginary dialogue between Pigliucci and the Stoic slave-turned-teacher Epictetus. Through this conversational device, Pigliucci guides readers through Stoicism's core pillars — the dichotomy of control (what is and is not "up to us"), the cultivation of virtue as the highest good, and Stoic approaches to adversity, relationships, and mortality. The book also serves as a philosophical argument for Stoicism's advantages over alternatives Pigliucci explored personally, including Aristotelian ethics, Buddhism, and secular humanism, before arriving at Stoicism as his framework of choice. Published by Basic Books, it is designed to make Stoic ethics accessible without flattening their nuance.

Follow up

Who is Epictetus and why does Pigliucci use him?
What is the dichotomy of control?
Why did Pigliucci choose Stoicism over Buddhism or Aristotelianism?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

Press Enter to ask. Answers come from our editorial Q&A — start typing to see related questions.

Age & Reading Level

Recommended age

Adult

Reading level

Adult

Skip if you want a prescriptive, step-by-step self-help manual rather than a philosophical argument grounded in ancient Stoic texts.

Editorial Review

Massimo Pigliucci's How to Be a Stoic: Using Ancient Philosophy to Live a Modern Life, published by Basic Books, is a philosopher's structured invitation to apply Stoic principles to contemporary existence, framed around an imaginary dialogue with the ancient Stoic teacher Epictetus. Praised by Donald J. Robertson as "a fine primer for the aspiring Marcus Aurelius," the book is designed to make Stoic ethics accessible without flattening its nuance, and it draws on Pigliucci's own intellectual journey through Aristotelianism, secular humanism, and Buddhism before he settled on Stoicism as his framework of choice.

Read the Full Review

Books like How to Be a Stoic

Curated picks for readers who enjoyed How to Be a Stoic, with our reasoning for each match.

If you liked How to Be a Stoic