Skip to content
Reviewed

Updated

Read Time

9 min read

Reader rating
4.7 · 346,819 Amazon ratings
reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review
The Women: A Novel by Kristin Hannah front cover

Our review

The Women

The Women: A Novel by Kristin Hannah Review: A Moving, Flawed Vietnam War Epic

Kristin Hannah's The Women is a historical fiction novel published by St. Martin's Press on February 6, 2024, following Frances "Frankie" McGrath, a young woman who serves as a U.S. Army nurse during the Vietnam War. A #1 bestseller on the New York Times, USA Today, Washington Post, and Los Angeles Times lists, the novel centers women — long absent from the canonical Vietnam War narrative — in an era of idealism, battlefield trauma, and a divisive homecoming. Critical response was mixed: major outlets praised the emotional ambition and historical reclamation, while some critics faulted the novel's reliance on familiar beats.

Our age band: Ages 16+battlefield trauma and wartime casualties · depictions of PTSD and psychological toll of war

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Readers drawn to female-centered wartime historical fiction — particularly fans of Hannah's The Nightingale or The Four Winds — who want to encounter the long-overlooked story of U.S. Army nurses in the Vietnam War told with emotional seriousness and intimate character detail.

Worth it if

Worth reading if you come to it specifically for the underrepresented story of women who served in Vietnam, and you value accessible, emotionally driven popular historical fiction over formally experimental or historiographically challenging approaches.

Skip if

Skip it if you're seeking a novel that radically reframes or interrogates the Vietnam War narrative from a new angle — critics note it affirms rather than reshapes familiar contours, and according to Wikipedia, Boston Globe's Meredith Maran found it too reliant on cliché to fully honor the complexity of its subject.

Where reviewers agree and split

Readers rate it 4.7 on Amazon. The reviews we read that discuss it in depth split on some points:

  • Positive

    The New York Times · Press review: novel vividly affirms Vietnam narrative with moving conviction (from its headline)

  • Mixed

    Studlife · Book blog: strong on friendship and trauma, but romantic elements overplayed

  • Positive

    Scattered Books · Book blog: masterful recreation of 1960s with profound respect for women's heroism

  • Mixed

    Read By Critics · Book blog: beautifully written and moving but contains some clichés and predictability

  • Positive

    San Francisco Book Review · Book blog: adored the twists and historical significance with five star rating

  • Positive

    MiMi Blog · Book blog: fantastically written plot is amazing despite tragedy and confusion

  • Positive

    The Bibliofile · Book blog: intimate drama recounting courageous overlooked stories of Vietnam nurses

    Overall verdicts are our summary of each review we read, from its headline, rating and conclusion.

    The New York Times found that Hannah "gathers women into the experience with moving conviction," though noted she does not offer "any revolutionary takes on the war and its aftermath." Via Wikipedia's coverage of critical response, The Boston Globe's Meredith Maran panned the novel for relying on the "predictable" and "matronizing," arguing tighter editing would have made it a stronger contribution to both Hannah's body of work and readers' understanding of American history. Kirkus Reviews described it as "engrossing if at times a bit formulaic," crediting Hannah with rendering the experiences of women who served in Vietnam "in all-encompassing detail."

    “Hannah may not offer any revolutionary takes on the war and its aftermath, but she gathers women into the experience with moving conviction.”

    — nytimes.com

    “Engrossing if at times a bit formulaic — Hannah renders the experiences of the young women who served in Vietnam in all-encompassing detail.”

    — kirkusreviews.com
    Sources: The New York Times, Wikipedia, Kirkus Reviews
    4.7from 346,819 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

    Camille Di Maio from Camille Di Maio - Author reviews The Women: A Novel

    Author Camille Di Maio shares a short, positive review of Kristin Hannah's novel The Women.

    A BookTube review by Camille Di Maio - Author, 2024 · 7.4K views · 555 subscribers · Watch on YouTube ·

    Their views, not ours. The points are our AI summary of what they say, each playing from where they say it.

    Another view · didn't like it
    Kristen was deeply disappointed by "The Women," rating it around one and a half to two stars despite being a devoted fan of Kristin Hannah's previous novels. While Kristen praised the decision to honor female nurses who served in Vietnam, they felt the execution suffered from jarring pacing, an overreliance on cliché romance, and an unbelievable depiction of the protagonist's training and deployment. Because of what they viewed as forced emotion and shallow character depth, Kristen found the novel frustrating and would not recommend it. Enter the Book on YouTube

    Frankie McGrath's journey

    The first half focuses on Frankie leaving a sheltered life in California in 1966 to serve as a military nurse in Vietnam despite her family's disapproval.

    Balanced depiction of war

    Hannah balances the harsh, tragic realities of the Vietnam War with an engaging narrative tone that avoids being overly graphic.

    Difficult homecoming and PTSD

    The second half powerfully portrays the lack of recognition and support for female veterans returning home, as well as the struggle with PTSD.

    Ask LuvemBooks

    Was this helpful?

    The Women is Kristin Hannah's sweeping historical fiction novel following Frances "Frankie" McGrath, a U.S. Army nurse who serves in Vietnam and returns home to a nation unwilling to acknowledge her sacrifice. The novel earns consistent praise for centering the long-overlooked experience of military women in the Vietnam War narrative with emotional sincerity and conviction. Readers already drawn to Hannah's female-centered wartime fiction — particularly The Nightingale and The Four Winds — are the novel's most natural audience, though those seeking a formally experimental or historiographically challenging take on the war may find its emotional framework more conventional than expected.
    Is it worth reading?
    For readers drawn to emotionally ambitious historical fiction that recovers overlooked perspectives, The Women delivers on its central promise: it brings the experience of Vietnam War nurses — women who worked under fire to patch soldiers back together — into a national story that has long left them out. Critics credited Hannah with gathering women into the Vietnam experience "with moving conviction," and its status as a #1 bestseller on the New York Times, USA Today, Washington Post, and Los Angeles Times lists reflects extraordinary popular reach. The key caveat, per The Boston Globe's Meredith Maran, is that the novel leans on familiar emotional beats and can feel over-long — readers seeking a formally experimental or historiographically radical treatment may find it more conventional than hoped.
    Similar books
    Readers who respond to The Women's female-centered wartime perspective will find a natural companion in Hannah's own The Four Winds, a Dust Bowl epic that similarly places a woman at the center of national crisis. Kate Quinn's The Alice Network and Georgia Hunter's We Were the Lucky Ones both center women navigating the upheaval of World War II with the same blend of intimate character and large-canvas history. For readers drawn to the moral weight of wartime suffering, Heather Morris's The Tattooist of Auschwitz and Geraldine Brooks's March — which reframes the American Civil War through a peripheral perspective — offer similarly ambitious acts of historical reclamation.
    Who should read this?
    The Women is most naturally suited to readers who have already found Hannah's female-centered wartime fiction — particularly The Nightingale and The Four Winds — rewarding, and to anyone drawn to the specific, underrepresented story of Vietnam War nurses. It is an especially strong fit for readers who prioritize emotional resonance and historical recovery over formal experimentation. Those who want a formally inventive or historiographically challenging treatment of the Vietnam War, or who are sensitive to the Boston Globe critic's concern about over-familiar narrative beats, may find the experience more comfortable than revelatory.
    About Kristin Hannah
    Born in 1960, Kristin Hannah has become one of America's most beloved contemporary novelists, captivating millions of readers with her emotionally powerful storytelling.
    Tell me about the adaptation
    Warner Bros. Pictures preemptively acquired the screen rights to The Women ahead of the novel's February 2024 publication — a move that signals significant industry confidence in the story's cinematic potential. The preemptive acquisition, made before the book had even reached readers, reflects both Hannah's established track record and the broad appeal of Frankie McGrath's story. Specific details regarding casting, director, or a projected release date had not been confirmed at the time of LuvemBooks' coverage.
    Is this a good book club pick?
    The Women is a well-suited book club selection, particularly for groups with an interest in American history, women's wartime contributions, or the social fractures of the Vietnam era. Its subject — the U.S. Army nurses who worked under fire in field hospitals — is historically substantive and underrepresented in popular culture, providing discussion material that extends well beyond the novel's pages. The tension between its extraordinary popular reach (a #1 bestseller on four major lists) and the critical reservations raised by The Boston Globe's Meredith Maran — who argued the novel underestimates its readers — also offers groups a productive entry point for debating what popular historical fiction owes its audience.
    How does this compare to her other books?
    The Women sits firmly within the tradition Hannah established with The Nightingale — her acclaimed female-centered WWII novel — and The Four Winds, her Dust Bowl epic: big history, intimate character, and a focus on the cost borne by women that history tends to forget. Where The Nightingale brought two French sisters into the shadow of the Nazi occupation and The Four Winds centered an American mother during the Great Depression, The Women extends that project to the Vietnam War — a conflict whose literary legacy has been even more exclusively male-dominated. Critics noted that this consistency is both a strength and a limitation: Hannah operates in recognizable territory, with the same emotional ambition, but without the revolutionary formal or historiographical departures that might surprise longtime readers.
    Summarize this book

    Summarize this book

    The Women follows Frances "Frankie" McGrath, a young woman who enlists in the United States Army Nurse Corps and serves during the Vietnam War, spanning the turbulent arc of the 1960s — from her departure as an idealistic nurse to her harrowing work in field hospitals and her deeply fraught return home. Published by St. Martin's Press on February 6, 2024, the novel interweaves personal story with national reckoning, centering women in a conflict whose literary legacy has long been dominated by the male combat experience.

    Follow up

    Is it based on a true story?
    How does the story end?
    How long is the book?

    Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

    Ask LuvemBooks

    What would you like to know about The Women?

    Answers come from our editorial notes on this book. If we haven't covered something, we'll say so.

    Readers often ask

    Our Review

    We review the evidence: reader verdicts, gathered and weighed with AI assistance and edited by LuvemBooks, rather than one reader's first-hand take.

    The Women succeeds as an emotionally ambitious act of historical reclamation, even if it occasionally trades the revolutionary for the familiar.

    What the Novel Is and What It Does

    Published by St. Martin's Press on February 6, 2024, The Women is a work of historical fiction built around Frances "Frankie" McGrath, a young woman who enlists in the United States Army Nurse Corps and serves during the Vietnam War. The novel spans the turbulent arc of the 1960s — from Frankie's departure as an idealistic young nurse to her time working under fire in field hospitals, and through the deeply fraught experience of returning home to a nation divided over the war.
    The publisher describes it as "at once an intimate portrait of a woman coming of age in a dangerous time and an epic tale of a nation divided by war and broken by politics, of a generation both fueled by dreams and lost on the battlefield." In scope and structure, it sits firmly in the tradition of large-canvas American historical fiction: personal story interwoven with national reckoning.

    Significance and Cultural Placement

    The novel arrived with considerable cultural weight behind it, debuting at number one on the New York Times bestseller list and reaching the same position on the USA Today, Washington Post, and Los Angeles Times lists. Hannah — already known as the #1 New York Times bestselling author of The Nightingale and The Four Winds — has made a career of centering women in historical moments where their contributions have been overlooked or minimized.
    The Women extends that project to the Vietnam War, a conflict whose literary and cinematic legacy has been dominated by the male combat experience. According to Read By Critics, Hannah "re-centers the story on the experience of women — in this instance, the military nurses who worked under fire, on bases and in field hospitals, to patch soldiers back together."
    The Women was also among the most-borrowed books from U.S. Public libraries in 2024, according to NPR, a signal of its broad popular reach. Warner Bros.
    Pictures preemptively acquired the screen rights for a film adaptation ahead of publication.

    Strengths: Emotional Conviction and Historical Recovery

    Where the novel draws the most consistent praise is in the sincerity and force with which it brings women into the Vietnam story. Critics observed that Hannah "gathers women into the experience with moving conviction," affirming the contours of the Vietnam narrative rather than radically dismantling them — and doing so with evident emotional seriousness.
    The publisher characterizes it as "a novel of searing insight and lyric beauty" featuring "a memorable heroine whose extraordinary idealism and courage under fire define a generation." For readers drawn to Hannah's previous work — the female-centered WWII story of The Nightingale, the Dust Bowl epic of The Four Winds — The Women operates in recognizable territory: big history, intimate character, and the cost borne by those history tends to forget.
    Back cover with praise quotes on red textured background highlighting the novel's Vietnam War nursing narrative.
    Back cover with praise quotes on red textured background highlighting the novel's Vietnam War nursing narrative.

    Genuine Limitations: Cliché and Craft Criticism

    Not all critical voices shared the popular enthusiasm. Critics noted that while the novel vividly affirms the known contours of the Vietnam narrative, Hannah does not put forward any groundbreaking new interpretations of the war and what followed it.
    The more pointed criticism came from Meredith Maran in The Boston Globe, who panned the novel for what she described as a reliance on cliché, concluding that Hannah risked "underestimating her readers." Maran argued that, cut and edited to remove "the predictable, the 'matronizing,' and the obvious," the book would have been a stronger contribution both to Hannah's body of work and to readers' understanding of American history.
    These critiques point to a tension that runs through popular historical fiction at scale: the impulse to make history emotionally accessible can, in some hands, smooth over the complexity that makes the history matter.

    Who This Book Is For

    Readers who come to The Women for the specific, underrepresented story of Vietnam War nurses — a chapter of American history that has received far less literary attention than the soldier's experience — will find a novel designed with that gap firmly in mind. Those who have found Hannah's earlier works rewarding, particularly The Nightingale with its female-centered wartime perspective, are the novel's most natural audience.
    Readers seeking a formally experimental or historiographically challenging treatment of the Vietnam War may find the novel's emotional framework more conventional than they'd hoped. At its core, The Women is a work of popular historical fiction with serious intent: it names women into a national story that has long left them out, and it does so — as its bestseller performance and library circulation figures both suggest — with an audience clearly ready to receive it.

    Sources & Further Reading

    The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

    1. Cited in this review
    2. 1
    3. 2
    4. Further reading
    5. 3

      Kristin Hannah, LuvemBooks

    6. 4
    7. 5
    8. 6
    9. 7
    10. 8
    11. 9
    12. 10
    13. 11
    14. 12
    15. 13
    16. 14
    17. 15

      Kirkus Reviews

    Age & Reading Level

    Our age band

    Ages 16+

    Reading level

    Older teens & adults

    Our age band groups books for browsing; it isn't an age a review gave.

    Content to know about

    battlefield trauma and wartime casualties
    depictions of PTSD and psychological toll of war
    social hostility toward Vietnam veterans

    Best for: Adults / mature 16+ — depictions of battlefield trauma, wartime casualties, and the psychological aftermath of the Vietnam War.

    Skip if you want a formally experimental or historiographically challenging treatment of the Vietnam War rather than an emotionally accessible popular historical novel.

    Kristin Hannah on The Women

    Kristin Hannah discusses the inspiration, historical research, and combat nurses behind her novel "The Women" in an interview with Walter Isaacson.

    Uploaded by Amanpour and Company, 2024 · Watch on YouTube ·

    More from this interview on Kristin Hannah's page →

    Pitching "The Women" in 1997

    Hannah says she first pitched the novel in 1997, but her editor told her that neither she nor the country was ready for that story yet.

    Inspiration from pandemic healthcare workers

    Hannah says witnessing the sacrifices and struggles of healthcare workers during the March 2020 COVID-19 lockdown convinced her it was time to write the novel.

    Deliberately visceral combat medical scenes

    Hannah says she deliberately portrayed surgical and trauma scenes as brutal and visceral because female veterans were often dismissed with claims they were never in combat.

    Spotlighting female wartime camaraderie

    Hannah explains that while wartime media frequently emphasizes male camaraderie, she wanted to depict the intense bonds, survival, and lifelines formed between women in war.

    Dismissal of nurses' wartime experience

    Hannah says many returning Vietnam nurses had their extensive combat medical skills disregarded by civilian hospitals and were treated as beginners, leading many to leave nursing entirely.

    From our readers

    Reader reviews

    No LuvemBooks readers have answered yet.

    Read it? Was it right for you?

    Books like The Women

    Curated picks for readers who enjoyed The Women, with our reasoning for each match.

    Discussion

    Reader comments