BOOKS
Published
Read Time
8 min read
Reader ratingreader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
4.2
· 80,686 Amazon ratingsFeatured In
Share This Review
We Were Liars by E. Lockhart Review: A Gripping YA Mystery With Real Bite
E. Lockhart's We Were Liars is a critically acclaimed 2014 young-adult novel built around the wealthy, seemingly perfect Sinclair family and a summer that Cadence Sinclair Eastman cannot remember. Winner of the Goodreads Choice Award for Best Young Adult Fiction and recipient of a starred review from critical coverage, it remains a landmark of contemporary YA fiction, praised for its razor-sharp prose and a twist that author R.L. Stine called the most heartbreaking he had ever encountered.
LuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Readers aged roughly 14 and up who enjoy psychological mystery and morally complex family drama, and who are willing to surrender to an unreliable, fragmented narrator in exchange for a twist that reframes everything they've read.
Worth it if
You're drawn to narratives that weaponise form itself — where the structure, the amnesia, and the figurative prose are all doing deliberate thematic work — and you can tolerate sustained ambiguity in the early chapters.
Skip if
You prefer clear, chronological storytelling and a narrator whose descriptions of pain and emotion are literal rather than figurative, as Cadence's abstracted, memory-fractured voice may try your patience before the payoff arrives.
What readers & critics say
Kirkus Reviews awarded the novel a starred review, calling it "riveting, brutal and beautifully told," and named it among its Best Books of 2014; en.wikipedia.org's reception summary records that it won the Goodreads Choice Award for Best Young Adult Fiction and was listed as an ALA Top Ten Best Fiction for Young Adults for 2015, while also noting the ending is something Lockhart "just about manages to pull off" — a qualified compliment acknowledging the trust the novel demands of its reader.
“Riveting, brutal and beautifully told — a devastating tale of greed and secrets springs from the summer that tore Cady's life apart.”
— kirkusreviews.com“The story shines through the pages, whisking you away to Beechwood Island and throwing you right into the centre of the Sinclair family drama.”
— theguardian.com4.2from 80,686 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
In This Review
- What Works & What Doesn't
- What the Novel Is and What It Does
- Structure, Influences, and Design Intent
- Critical Reception and Awards
- Where the Novel Challenges Its Readers
- Who the Book Is Designed For and Its Ongoing Relevance
What Works & What Doesn't
What Works
- Won the Goodreads Choice Award for Best Young Adult Fiction and earned a starred review from critical coverage, which called it 'riveting, brutal and beautifully told'
- Named among the best YA books of 2014 by critical coverage, critical coverage, School Library Journal, and The Wall Street Journal, and listed as an ALA Top Ten Best Fiction for Young Adults for 2015
- Deliberately constructed with a fairy-tale structure and a central metaphor — amnesia as denial — that critics noted gives the novel uncommon thematic coherence
- The character of Gat Patil, drawn partly from Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights, adds an outsider's perspective that cuts through the Sinclair family's insular mythology
- A television adaptation in development by Julie Plec and Universal Television speaks to the story's sustained cultural traction a decade after its first publication
What Doesn't
- Cadence's highly figurative narration of pain and emotion can be disorienting — a critical coverage-published review noted readers may need a moment to register when she is speaking metaphorically rather than literally
- The novel demands sustained trust before its payoff; critics noted the ending is something Lockhart only just manages to pull off, making the experience front-loaded with ambiguity that not every reader will find rewarding
E. Lockhart's We Were Liars is a landmark of contemporary YA fiction that earns its reputation through structural precision, a memorably unreliable narrator, and a devastation that accumulates quietly before landing all at once.
What the Novel Is and What It Does
We Were Liars by E. Lockhart front cover
At the centre of We Were Liars is Cadence Sinclair Eastman, the eldest grandchild of Harris Sinclair — a wealthy, self-styled family patriarch who owns Beechwood Island, a private retreat near Martha's Vineyard divided among four mansions: Windemere, Cuddledown, Red Gate, and Clairmont. The Sinclairs, known informally as the "Royals of America," have gathered on the island every summer for generations. Cadence, her cousins Johnny and Mirren, and their close friend Gat Patil — the nephew of Carrie's partner, Ed — form the group the family calls "the Liars." The novel opens two years after something went catastrophically wrong during what Cadence calls Summer 15, when she suffered a serious head injury and lost most of her memories of that season. Returning to Beechwood Island and reuniting with the other Liars, Cadence tries to piece together what happened. The book's central engine is that reconstruction: what really occurred, what was concealed, and at what cost.
“the story shines through the pages, whisking you away to Beechwood Island and throwing you right into the centre of the Sinclair family drama.”
Structure, Influences, and Design Intent
Lockhart has spoken directly about the deliberate architecture of the novel. As a child, she was captivated by her mother's fairy-tale collections, and she built We Were Liars around a contemporary story with a fairy-tale structure — her stated aim was to write something that could unpack what she had spent years thinking about in that form. The influence is legible in the novel's moral framework: the story is organised around the consequences of one's mistakes, a classic fairy-tale preoccupation. The character of Gat — present in the Sinclair world but permanently an outsider — was drawn from Lockhart's own experience as a scholarship student at private schools and, according to Wikipedia's account of her sources, from Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights. Cadence's migraines and Percocet dependency, which shape her narration throughout, reflect Lockhart's interest in how chronic pain distorts personality and perception.
Critical Reception and Awards
The novel's reception was strong and broadly consistent. Kirkus Reviews awarded it a starred review, describing the book as "riveting, brutal and beautifully told" and specifically praising Lockhart's humanising treatment of the Sinclair family. We Were Liars was named among the best young adult books of 2014 by critical coverage, Publishers Weekly, School Library Journal, and The Wall Street Journal, and it was listed as an ALA Top Ten Best Fiction for Young Adults for 2015. It won the Goodreads Choice Award for Best Young Adult Fiction and, according to Goodreads, was the platform's most-searched standalone title of 2014. Bustle described the novel as "compulsively readable" with a "meaningful" plot. R.L. Stine praised its central twist as "the most heartbreaking twist" he had ever read. A critical coverage-published reader review noted that "the story shines through the pages, whisking you away to Beechwood Island and throwing you right into the centre of the Sinclair family drama."
Where the Novel Challenges Its Readers
The same qualities that give We Were Liars its power are the ones that require patience from the reader. Cadence's narration — shaped by memory loss, pain, and the Sinclair family's deep-seated habit of denial — is deliberately fragmented, and her descriptions of physical and emotional suffering are frequently figurative to the point of abstraction. Critical coverage-published review noted that Cadence's emotional descriptions could be momentarily disorienting, requiring readers to pause and recognise that she is speaking figuratively rather than literally. This is by design — amnesia functions, as one critic noted in Wikipedia's reception summary, as a razor-sharp metaphor for the Sinclair family's collective refusal to confront reality — but readers who prefer straightforward, chronological narration may find the novel's early sections demanding. The ending itself was described, in that same reception summary, as something Lockhart "just about manages to pull off," a qualified compliment that acknowledges the novel asks a great deal of the reader's trust before delivering its payoff.
Who the Book Is Designed For and Its Ongoing Relevance
Originally published in 2014 and available in a subsequent Ember reprint edition, We Were Liars is targeted at readers aged approximately 12 to 17, with particular resonance for the older end of that range given its themes of grief, class, complicity, and the violence of family mythology. The novel's appeal has proved durable: its television adaptation rights were acquired by Julie Plec's My So-Called Company and Universal Television, with Plec adapting both We Were Liars and its prequel, Family of Liars, for the screen. For readers drawn to psychological mystery, morally complex family dynamics, and narratives that weaponise narrative form itself as a storytelling device, this novel represents one of the more carefully constructed entries in the genre. It does not offer comfort so much as clarity — and it arrives at that clarity through precisely the kind of deception its title promises.
Frequently Asked Questions
is We Were Liars by E. Lockhart worth reading
If you're drawn to psychological mystery and narratives that weaponise their own form as a storytelling device, it's one of the more carefully constructed entries in the genre — Kirkus Reviews called it 'riveting, brutal and beautifully told' and gave it a starred review. That said, it doesn't offer comfort so much as clarity, and it earns that clarity through precisely the kind of deception its title promises, so go in with patience rather than expecting a straightforward payoff.
What is this book actually about
On the surface it follows Cadence Sinclair Eastman, eldest grandchild of wealthy patriarch Harris Sinclair, as she returns to the family's private island retreat, Beechwood, two summers after suffering a serious head injury that wiped her memories of what the novel calls Summer 15. The real engine of the book is Cadence piecing together what went catastrophically wrong that season — what was concealed, and at what cost — alongside her cousins Johnny and Mirren and their close friend Gat Patil, the four of them known within the family as 'the Liars.'
Does this book have a good ending
The ending is the book's most talked-about element — R.L. Stine called its central twist 'the most heartbreaking twist' he had ever read, which is a serious endorsement. The reviewer notes that Lockhart 'just about manages to pull off' the ending, a qualified compliment that acknowledges the novel asks a great deal of the reader's trust before the payoff arrives, so readers who stick with the fragmented early sections tend to find it worth it.
Is this book hard to read
It can be in the early sections — Cadence's narration is deliberately fragmented because it's shaped by memory loss, chronic pain, and Percocet dependency, and her descriptions of suffering are frequently figurative to the point of abstraction, which can be momentarily disorienting. Readers who prefer straightforward, chronological storytelling may find the opening demanding, but the review notes this is by design: amnesia functions as a razor-sharp metaphor for the Sinclair family's collective refusal to confront reality.
What age is this book appropriate for
Best for ages 14 and up. The novel's morally complex ending, themes of grief and complicity, and narration shaped by chronic pain and Percocet dependency suit confident older teen readers rather than younger audiences within the 12–17 range — younger readers may find both the emotional weight and the deliberately unreliable narration difficult to navigate.
Is this book similar to Wuthering Heights
There's a direct connection: the review notes that the character of Gat Patil — permanently present in the Sinclair world but always an outsider — was partly drawn from Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights, according to Lockhart's own cited sources. The class tension and sense of someone excluded from a privileged inner circle echo Brontë's novel, though We Were Liars wraps these themes in a contemporary YA psychological mystery set on Beechwood Island rather than the Yorkshire moors.
Is this book getting a tv show or movie
Yes — the review confirms that television adaptation rights were acquired by Julie Plec's My So-Called Company and Universal Television, with Plec adapting both We Were Liars and its prequel, Family of Liars, for the screen. No release details are provided in the review, but the adaptation covers both books in the series.
Sources & Further Reading
The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.
- Cited in this review
- 1
audible.com
- 2
en.wikipedia.org
- Further reading
- 3
E. Lockhart, Wikipedia
- 4
- 5
emilylockhart.com
- 6
armedwithabook.com
- 7
- 8
- 9
benjaminmcevoy.com
- 10
- 11
barnesandnoble.com
Related Reviews
Reviews of books we picked for readers who enjoyed We Were Liars.
Reader Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!