Skip to content
Reviewed

Read Time

8 min read

Our age bandAdult
Reader rating
3.9 · 28,909 Amazon ratings, as of Nov 2026
reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review
The Sanatorium: Reese's Book Club: A Novel (Detective Elin Warner Series) by Sarah Pearse front cover

Our review

The Sanatorium

The Sanatorium by Sarah Pearse Review: Atmospheric Alpine Thriller

Sarah Pearse’s debut thriller traps a detective and her guests in a converted Alpine sanatorium during a blizzard. The novel delivers a chilling, mood-driven mystery where the setting generates more dread than the plot. Readers seeking atmospheric suspense will find it compelling, though those prioritizing airtight plotting should temper expectations.

Our age band: Adultgraphic violence · sexualized threats

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Its masterful use of a converted sanatorium as a claustrophobic, Gothic setting delivers a compelling ride for readers seeking a tightly wound, isolated mystery.

Worth it if

Worth reading if you enjoy Gothic suspense and are willing to overlook predictable character logic.

Skip if

Skip it if you prioritize airtight plotting and airtight character arcs, as the resolution feels rushed and implausible to some.

Where reviewers agree and split

Readers rate it 3.9 on Amazon. The reviews we read that discuss it in depth split on some points:

  • Negative

    Kirkus Reviews · Press review: finds the plot silly and twists unbelievable

  • Positive · 4.5/5

    Crime by the Book · Book blog: A gripping, atmospheric winter thriller highly recommended

  • Mixed

    Fictionophile · Book blog: enjoyable fast read with implausible plot and ending

  • Mixed

    The Standard · Book blog: praises setting but finds tone shifts jarring and sequel-baity

  • Positive

    BookTrib · Book blog: highly recommends the atmospheric gothic thriller for fans (from its headline)

  • Mixed

    Amazon Adviser · Book blog: A chilling thriller let down by predictability (from its headline)

  • Positive

    What Makes You Curious · Book blog: enthusiastically praises the debut gothic thriller (from its headline)

  • Positive

    The Lit Bitch · Book blog: highly anticipates and praises the atmospheric debut (from its headline)

  • Positive

    Lark's Edition · Book blog: quickly becomes a captivating and devouring read (from its headline)

    Overall verdicts are our summary of each review we read, from its headline, rating and conclusion.

    Kirkus Reviews dismissed the plot as overloaded and silly. Fictionophile praised the atmosphere but noted the ending felt rushed, while The Standard highlighted the incredible setting despite jarring tonal shifts.

    “overloaded, grisly, and ultimately silly”

    — Kirkus Reviews
    Sources: Kirkus Reviews, Crime by the Book, Fictionophile, The Standard
    3.9from 28,909 Amazon ratings, as of Nov 2026— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

    Ask LuvemBooks

    Was this helpful?

    Sarah Pearse’s debut thriller traps Detective Elin Warner and her guests in a converted Alpine sanatorium during a blizzard. The novel delivers a chilling, mood-driven mystery where the setting generates more dread than the plot. Readers seeking atmospheric suspense will find it compelling, though those expecting straightforward resolutions should temper expectations.
    Is it worth reading?
    It delivers a compelling experience for readers who prioritize atmospheric dread. The claustrophobic setting and relentless premise create genuine tension, though those expecting a tightly resolved mystery may find the ending divisive.
    Similar books
    Readers who enjoy this blend of isolated suspense and Gothic architecture will also appreciate Riley Sager’s The Only One Left and Home Before Dark, both of which use claustrophobic settings to heighten psychological dread. Alex Michaelides’ The Silent Patient offers a similarly tense narrative with a focus on a protagonist navigating a confined, high-stakes environment. For fans of atmospheric winter thrillers, Alex North’s The Whisper Man and Loreth Anne White’s The Patient’s Secret provide comparable pacing and mood-driven suspense.
    Who should read this?
    This novel suits readers who enjoy Gothic suspense, crime thrillers, and atmospheric thrillers that lean heavily on setting to generate dread. It works well for book clubs looking for a tense, wintry read that sparks discussion about unreliable clues and plot decisions. It is less ideal for those who prefer straightforward, meticulously plotted whodunits.
    What age is it for?
    Written for adults, the novel contains graphic violence and sexualized threats consistent with the thriller genre. The complex plot and psychological tension are best suited for mature readers comfortable with suspense that occasionally relies on conventional tropes and predictable narrative developments.
    Does atmosphere outweigh the plot?
    Critics and readers note a clear divide on this point. While BookBrowse and Crime by the Book praised how the mountain setting and isolation effectively drive the suspense, Kirkus Reviews found the plot silly and the twists unbelievable. The narrative intentionally leans into suspense, sometimes sacrificing psychological consistency for plot convenience.
    How is the main character received?
    Detective Elin Warner’s competence draws mixed reactions. Everand readers expressed frustration with her lack of detective-like confidence, suggesting the book would have benefited from heavy-handed editing. Conversely, other readers appreciated her personal journey as she reconnects with her gut instincts while shedding closely held beliefs.
    Is this part of a series?
    This is the first entry in the Detective Elin Warner series. The narrative leaves its door open for future installments, establishing Elin as a recurring protagonist. Readers can start here without prior knowledge, as the story functions as a standalone psychological thriller.
    Summarize this book

    Summarize this book

    Detective Elin Warner travels to Le Sommet, a converted tuberculosis sanatorium in the Swiss Alps, for her brother’s engagement party. A sudden blizzard traps the guests inside, and when her sister-in-law Laure vanishes, Elin must investigate while the storm closes in. The narrative alternates between Elin’s search and the perspective of a masked killer wearing vintage gas masks.

    Follow up

    How is the pacing?
    How important is the setting?

    Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

    Ask LuvemBooks

    What would you like to know about The Sanatorium?

    Answers come from our editorial notes on this book. If we haven't covered something, we'll say so.

    Readers often ask

    Our Review

    We review the evidence: reader verdicts, gathered and weighed with AI assistance and edited by LuvemBooks, rather than one reader's first-hand take.

    Sarah Pearse’s debut thriller delivers a claustrophobic mystery where a chilling setting outpaces a predictably resolved plot, though.
    Readers seeking a tightly wound, isolated mystery will find a compelling ride, though those prioritizing airtight plotting should temper their expectations. The novel functions best as a mood-driven suspense story rather than a rigorous whodunit.

    Plot and Premise

    Detective Elin Warner arrives at Le Sommet, a converted five-star hotel built inside a former tuberculosis sanatorium in the Swiss Alps. She has taken time off from her job to attend her estranged brother Isaac and his fiancée Laure’s engagement party.
    An imposing and isolated getaway, the mountain location is exactly where Elin does not want to be. She immediately feels on edge upon arrival.
    A threatening storm quickly closes off all access to the hotel. The following morning, the guests discover that Laure has vanished.
    Elin must rely on her instincts to find her missing sister-in-law. Panic spreads among the remaining guests as the storm intensifies.
    Elin faces mounting pressure to solve the disappearance. She soon learns that another woman has gone missing.
    The narrative shifts between Elin’s investigation and the perspective of a masked killer. The killer wears a vintage gas mask from the building’s medical past.
    The locked-room premise traps the characters with a shadowy antagonist.

    Critical Reception

    Kirkus Reviews gave a negative verdict, finding the plot silly and twists unbelievable, and called the book "overloaded, grisly, and ultimately silly." Crime by the Book offered a positive assessment, concluding it was a gripping, atmospheric winter thriller highly recommended, and labeled it a "gripping locked room mystery."
    Fictionophile delivered a mixed review, calling it an enjoyable fast read with an implausible plot and ending, while noting it was "found lacking in some small ways." The Standard provided a mixed take, praising the setting but finding tone shifts jarring and sequel-baity, and observing that "ultra-violent torture scenes carried out by a gas mask-wearing villain can sometimes be jarring."
    Several readers expressed frustration with Elin’s lack of detective-like confidence. One reader suggested the book would have benefited from heavy-handed editing.
    Interior page with a synopsis describing a detective investigating a disappearance at a converted sanatorium.
    Interior page with a synopsis describing a detective investigating a disappearance at a converted sanatorium.

    Atmospheric Strengths and Narrative Flaws

    The Sanatorium leans heavily into its unique architectural history. Pearse transforms medical equipment and sterile corridors into unsettling museum pieces.
    The prose captures the desolate, snowy landscape with sharp, crisp imagery. The isolation of the Swiss Alps creates a genuine sense of claustrophobia.
    The minimalist luxury of the hotel contrasts sharply with the building’s dark past. This architectural duality serves as the novel’s primary engine for tension.
    The locked-room structure forces the characters to confront their own anxieties. Elin’s personal growth becomes intertwined with her investigation.
    She must reconnect with her gut instincts while shedding closely held beliefs. The pacing relies on short, suspenseful chapters that escalate the stakes.
    The killer’s masked presence keeps the threat immediate and terrifying. The narrative occasionally sacrifices character logic for plot convenience.
    Elin’s actions sometimes contradict her established professional background. The romantic subplots follow a conventional trajectory that undercuts the tension.
    The ending resolves the mystery in a way that feels rushed to some readers. A few reviewers felt the conclusion prioritized shock value over narrative payoff.
    The heavy use of red herrings can frustrate readers who prefer straightforward clues. The book leaves its door open for future installments in the Detective Elin Warner series.

    Is The Sanatorium Worth Reading?

    The critical responses reveal a clear divide between atmosphere and execution. The novel excels at building dread through its setting and pacing.
    Readers who enjoy Gothic suspense and isolated thrillers will find the experience highly engaging. The atmospheric writing successfully transports the audience into a chilling environment.
    Those who prioritize tight plotting and airtight character arcs will likely find the resolution lacking. It functions primarily as a wintry read for fans of locked-room mysteries.
    The novel serves as a strong debut that establishes a compelling recurring protagonist. Readers looking for a heavy psychological thriller might find the scares too conventional.
    The atmospheric strengths ultimately carry the narrative past its predictable plotting. The book remains a solid entry point for new readers of the genre.

    Sources & Further Reading

    The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

    1. Cited in this review
    2. 1
    3. 2
    4. Further reading
    5. 3
    6. 4
    7. 5
    8. 6
    9. 7
    10. 8
    11. 9
    12. 10
    13. 11
    14. 12

      Kirkus Reviews

    15. 13

      Fictionophile

    16. 14

      The Standard

    Age & Reading Level

    Our age band

    Adult

    Our age band groups books for browsing; it isn't an age a review gave.

    Tropes

    locked room

    From how readers describe it, not our own reading.

    Content to know about

    graphic violence
    sexualized threats
    unreliable character logic

    Best for: Adults 18+ — contains graphic violence and sexualized threats consistent with the thriller genre.

    Skip if you prioritize airtight plotting and airtight character arcs, as the resolution feels rushed and implausible to some.

    From our readers

    Reader reviews

    No LuvemBooks readers have answered yet.

    Read it? Was it right for you?

    Books like The Sanatorium

    Curated picks for readers who enjoyed The Sanatorium, with our reasoning for each match.

    Discussion

    Reader comments