Skip to content
LuvemBooks
LuvemBooks

Who it's for. Who should skip it. What to read next.

L

Loreth Anne White

About This Author
Reviewed

Read Time

9 min read

Age & reading levelAdult
Reader rating

4.4

· 38,801 Amazon ratings
reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
$8.71 on Amazon
Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review
Front cover of The Patient's Secret: A Novel

Our review

The Patient's Secret

The Patient's Secret by Loreth Anne White Review: Dark Suburban Suspense

by Loreth Anne White

Loreth Anne White's Montlake thriller opens with a female jogger's battered body found beneath the cliffs of an idyllic coastal community, then unspools the secrets of three Story Cove households — including psychotherapist Lily Bradley and her professor husband Tom — through a multiple point-of-view structure investigated by detective Rue Duval. Inspired by a horrific true crime, the novel leans into themes of justice, family loyalty, and whether people can escape their pasts, and its shifting perspectives and twists are its most praised assets. The trade-offs are real: the tone is unrelentingly dark, and the perfect-family-hiding-secrets premise is a crowded one in domestic suspense. Best suited to committed psychological thriller readers who don't mind a grim, morally tangled ride.

$8.71 on Amazon
Adultmurder of a female jogger with a battered body · backdrop of sexual assaults on women

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Readers of multi-POV domestic and psychological thrillers who want morally shaded suburban noir with thematic ambitions — nature versus nurture, redemption, buried family lies — woven through the whodunit, including existing fans of Loreth Anne White's bleaker recent work.

Worth it if

Worth reading if you enjoy untangling competing points of view and can handle grim material — the craft of its interlocking perspectives, pressure-cooker setting, and true-crime-rooted moral questions rewards patient, attentive readers.

Skip if

Skip it if you're fatigued by the perfect-family-hiding-secrets premise, prefer lighter mysteries, or would rather avoid subject matter involving a murdered jogger and a backdrop of sexual assaults — even admiring reviewers flag how very dark it is.

Critical response split along tonal lines: Criminal Element praised the "palpable accuracy" of its true-crime foundation and Red Carpet Crash called it a twist-packed novel that "starts off strong and never lets up," while an All About Romance reviewer who had counted it among her most anticipated reads of 2022 found it "didn't fulfill the hopes I had for it." Bookclubs.com's reader coverage echoes the enthusiasm — "messy, twisty, and full of morally questionable people" — while conceding the story "did feel a little long in places."

Sources: All About Romance, Criminal Element, Red Carpet Crash, Bookclubs.com
4.4from 38,801 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

Ask LuvemBooks

Was this helpful?

Loreth Anne White's The Patient's Secret opens with a female jogger's battered body found beneath the cliffs of Story Cove, then unspools the secrets of three affluent households — including psychotherapist Lily Bradley and her professor husband Tom — through a multiple point-of-view investigation led by detective Rue Duval. LuvemBooks' verdict: a tightly constructed, thematically ambitious domestic thriller whose shifting perspectives and well-regarded twists are its greatest assets, inspired by a true crime that gives it real moral weight. The caveat is real too — the tone is unrelentingly dark and the perfect-family-hiding-secrets premise is a crowded one, so this suits committed psychological thriller readers rather than the faint of heart.
Is it worth reading?
For readers of domestic and psychological thrillers, yes — the multiple-POV architecture is the book's most frequently praised asset, with distinct, morally complex characters and genuinely exciting twists, and it reaches for meatier ideas about nature, nurture, and redemption than the average suburban thriller. The reservations are twofold: the tone is very dark (an admiring All About Romance reviewer still found it did not meet her expectations), and the perfect-family-hiding-secrets premise is heavily trafficked in the subgenre. It's distinguished by craft rather than reinvention of the formula.
Similar books
Readers drawn to this book's suburban facades and buried secrets should look at Mary Kubica's Every Last Lie, Rosie Walsh's The Love of My Life, Lisa Jewell's Then She Was Gone, and Freida McFadden's Never Lie — all of which work the same vein of marriages under the microscope and unreliable perspectives. For another thriller from White herself, Beneath Devil's Bridge also draws on true-crime territory, while Alex Michaelides' The Silent Patient shares the psychotherapist-with-secrets angle.
Who should read this?
This is aimed squarely at readers of domestic and psychological thrillers — the audience for suburban facades, unreliable narrators, and marriages under the microscope — particularly those who like their suspense multi-stranded and morally shaded rather than puzzle-box clean. Existing fans of White's backlist will find the bleak intensity she has become known for. Readers who prefer lighter mysteries, or who are fatigued by the perfect-neighbors-with-secrets setup specifically, should look elsewhere.
Is this a good book club pick?
It is a solid discussion pick for the right group: the multiple-POV structure invites debate over whose account to trust, and the book's preoccupations — whether people are defined by the past or genetics, and whether blood bonds strengthen or strain — are genuinely arguable. The moral tangles are the draw; as one genre reviewer observed, the characters are caught in the middle rather than simple villains, which makes their choices more unsettling and more human. Just brief the group on the dark subject matter beforehand.
Where should I start with this author?
White is a veteran of the genre described by her publisher as a Washington Post and Amazon Charts bestselling author with millions of books sold, so there is a deep backlist to explore. For readers who liked The Patient's Secret's true-crime foundation, Beneath Devil's Bridge is a natural next step — it shares the same interest in real-crime-inspired suspense. Be aware that reviewers note her recent novels have grown progressively darker, so earlier entries may read somewhat lighter.
Summarize this book

Summarize this book

When the battered body of a female jogger is found beneath the cliffs of the idyllic coastal community of Story Cove, detective Rulandi "Rue" Duval investigates three households whose secrets prove worth dying — and killing — for. At the center are psychotherapist Lily Bradley and her professor husband Tom, whose dream-house life conceals darker currents, while Duval's own history as press liaison during a string of deadly sexual assaults on joggers hangs over the case. Structured across multiple points of view, the standalone 2022 Montlake novel puts its characters on what one reviewer called a collision course that will not end at just murder.

Follow up

Is The Patient's Secret part of a series?
Where does the story take place?
Is it based on a true story?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

Ask LuvemBooks

What would you like to know about The Patient's Secret?

Answers come from our editorial notes on this book. If we haven't covered something, we'll say so.

Readers often ask

Our Review

We review the evidence: published critics, reader verdicts and BookTube reviews, gathered and weighed with AI assistance and edited by LuvemBooks, rather than one reader's first-hand take.

A tightly constructed domestic thriller with a true-crime foundation, Loreth Anne White's novel rewards patient readers even as its unrelenting darkness and crowded premise will not suit everyone.

What the Book Is

Published by Montlake in March 2022, The Patient's Secret is a standalone novel of psychological suspense from Loreth Anne White, described by her publisher's retail copy as a Washington Post and Amazon Charts bestselling author. The setup is classic domestic noir: when the battered body of a female jogger is found beneath the cliffs of an idyllic coastal community, the perfect neighbors suddenly do not seem so perfect.
At the center of the ensemble is Lily Bradley, a respected psychotherapist married to Tom Bradley, a distinguished professor at the local university; the couple live in a dream house with their two children in the comfortably affluent Story Cove community. The investigation is handled by detective Rulandi "Rue" Duval, a high-profile figure who had served as police press liaison during a string of deadly sexual assaults on female joggers — a history that hangs over the new case.
Structured as a multiple point-of-view narrative, the novel interweaves the lives of three women and three households in the neighborhood, setting them on what one reviewer described as a collision course that will not end at just murder.

True-Crime Roots and Thematic Ambitions

The publisher positions the book as a novel of suspense inspired by a horrific true crime — secrets worth dying, and killing, for. Reader takeaways and review coverage consistently highlight the thematic weight White piles onto that foundation: the search for truth as the engine of the plot, and explorations of justice, redemption, and the consequences of uncovering buried lies.
The book is also preoccupied with family dynamics — how bonds of blood can both strengthen and strain individual ties — and with the question of whether a person is defined by the past or by genetics, or can instead choose to change. These are meatier concerns than the average suburban thriller reaches for, and they give the murder investigation a moral dimension beyond simple whodunit mechanics.
Readers who want their suspense to interrogate nature, nurture, and reinvention will find that agenda woven deliberately through the story rather than pasted on.

Where It Delivers

The multiple-POV architecture is the book's most frequently praised asset. Coverage of the novel notes that each character emerges distinctly, with layers of complexity that reveal genuine struggles and stark moral dilemmas, and that the shifting perspectives generate some truly exciting twists.
White is a veteran of the genre with millions of books sold, and that experience shows in the construction: the confined suburban atmosphere of Story Cove, where urban professionals perform respectability for one another, gives the revelations a pressure-cooker quality. The book also resists easy heroism — as one genre reviewer observed, thrillers tend to be peopled by psychos doing bad things to each other, while the characters in this novel are caught in the middle, which makes their choices more unsettling and more human.
For readers who enjoy untangling competing accounts of the same events, the structure is built to reward attention.

Where It Falters

The honest reservations are twofold. First, the darkness.
A reviewer at All About Romance — who came to the book as one of her most anticipated reads of 2022 and counts herself a friend of the author — reported that it did not fulfill her hopes, noting that White's recent novels have grown progressively darker and that this one continues the trend. Second, familiarity.
The picture-perfect family hiding appalling secrets is, as that same reviewer pointed out, an extremely crowded premise in current domestic suspense, and readers who have consumed a lot of the subgenre may find the contours recognizable even when the specific twists land. Neither is a fatal flaw, but together they define the book's limits: this is a grim read working a well-worn vein, distinguished by craft rather than by reinvention of the formula.

Who It Is For

The Patient's Secret is aimed squarely at readers of domestic and psychological thrillers — the audience for stories of suburban facades, unreliable narrators, and marriages under the microscope — and particularly at those who like their suspense multi-stranded and morally shaded rather than puzzle-box clean. Existing fans of White's backlist will find the bleak intensity she has become known for.
Readers sensitive to violence against women should note that the premise involves a murdered jogger and a backdrop of sexual assaults, and that at least one sympathetic reviewer found the tone very dark. Those who prefer lighter mysteries, or who are fatigued by the perfect-neighbors-with-secrets setup specifically, should calibrate expectations accordingly — but for its intended audience, the record shows a competently engineered, thematically ambitious entry in the genre.

Sources & Further Reading

The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

  1. Cited in this review
  2. 1
    The Patient's Secret: A Novel by Loreth Anne White

    bookclubs.com

  3. 2
    Book Review: The Patient’s Secret by Loreth Anne White

    criminalelement.com

  4. 3
    The Patient's Secret: A Novel by Loreth Anne White, Paperback | Barnes & Noble®

    barnesandnoble.com

  5. Further reading
  6. 4
    THE PATIENT'S SECRET | Loreth Anne White

    lorethannewhite.com

  7. 5
    [Review] The Patient's Secret: A Novel (Loreth Anne White) Summarized

    9natree.castos.com

  8. 6
    The Patient's Secret by Loreth Anne White : All About Romance

    allaboutromance.com

  9. 7
    Book Review: 'The Patient's Secret: A Novel' By Loreth Anne White - RedCarpetCrash.com

    redcarpetcrash.com

  10. 8
    The Patient's Secret: A Novel by Loreth Anne White ...

    barnesandnoble.com

Age & Reading Level

Recommended age

Adult

Browse all adult books

Content to know about

murder of a female jogger with a battered body
backdrop of sexual assaults on women
unrelentingly dark, grim tone throughout

Skip if you prefer lighter mysteries or are fatigued by the perfect-neighbors-with-appalling-secrets setup in domestic suspense.

From our readers

Reader reviews

Be one of the first readers to answer.

Read it? Was it right for you?