For readers interested in the history of women's rights, early twentieth-century political poetry, or how satirical writing can function as civic action, Are Women People? is a genuinely rewarding read. Miller's technique — quoting a named antagonist verbatim, then demolishing the argument in verse — gives the collection a rhetorical discipline unusual in political poetry, and the formal variety across five sections keeps it from becoming monotonous. The caveat is that its pleasures are primarily those of rhetoric and comic logic rather than lyric imagery or emotional depth, so readers seeking conventional poetry may find it more specialized than they anticipated.

Essential Novelists - Alice Duer Miller: Are women people?

by Alice Duer Miller, August Nemo

$2.99 on Amazon Read our full review

At a glance

First published1915

AudienceAdult

About the Author

Alice Duer Miller, August Nemo

1 book reviewed

Essential Novelists - Alice Duer Miller

Name: Essential Novelists - Alice Duer Miller: Are women people? by Alice Duer Miller, August Nemo
Author: Alice Duer Miller, August Nemo

Are women people?

by Alice Duer Miller, August Nemo

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for: Readers drawn to the history of the American suffrage movement, scholars of early twentieth-century political poetry, or anyone curious about how satirical verse can function simultaneously as investigative journalism and civic activism.

Worth it? Skip it? Read the full verdict →

Ask LuvemBooks

Was this helpful?

Essential Novelists - Alice Duer Miller: Are Women People? collects Alice Duer Miller's landmark satirical poems, prose, and dramatic writing from the American suffrage movement, originally serialized in the New York Tribune between 1913 and 1917, in which Miller quotes named politicians and editorialists verbatim before dismantling their arguments in verse. The collection's greatest strength is its rhetorical precision: each poem is anchored in a real, sourced antagonist — from Vice President Thomas R. Marshall to anonymous London Globe editorialists — making it simultaneously a work of political comedy and a primary-source document of the suffrage era. Readers seeking conventional lyric poetry may find its pleasures more polemical than purely aesthetic, but those drawn to the history of women's rights, early twentieth-century political satire, or the mechanics of activist writing will find it essential.

Is it worth reading?: For readers interested in the history of women's rights, early twentieth-century political poetry, or how satirical writing can function as civic action, Are Women People? is a genuinely rewarding read. Miller's technique — quoting a named antagonist verbatim, then demolishing the argument in verse — gives the collection a rhetorical discipline unusual in political poetry, and the formal variety across five sections keeps it from becoming monotonous. The caveat is that its pleasures are primarily those of rhetoric and comic logic rather than lyric imagery or emotional depth, so readers seeking conventional poetry may find it more specialized than they anticipated.
Similar books: Readers drawn to Are Women People? for its focus on women's history and social resistance may also enjoy Stacey Lee's The Downstairs Girl, which explores gender and racial inequality in turn-of-the-century America, and Marie Benedict's Carnegie's Maid, a novel that centers a woman navigating the constraints of the Gilded Age. For readers interested in women organizing for change, Marie Bostwick's The Book Club for Troublesome Women and Siobhan Curham's The Secret Sewing Society both trace collective female action across history. Stephanie Dray and Laura Kamoie's A Founding Mother offers another angle on women shaping American political life, while Alice Walker's The Color Purple examines women's voices and agency in a different but equally charged American context.
Who should read this?: Are Women People? is best suited to readers drawn to the history of women's rights in America, scholars or students of early twentieth-century political poetry, and anyone interested in how formal verse can function as investigative journalism and political comedy simultaneously. It will also appeal to readers interested in Alice Duer Miller specifically, given her documented influence on political opinion — her later verse novel The White Cliffs is credited with influencing public sentiment around the United States' entry into World War II. Readers seeking purely lyric or emotionally immersive poetry are less likely to find their primary satisfactions here.
About Alice Duer Miller, August Nemo: The verified author bio provided for this edition identifies the author as Michael Chabon, described as an American novelist, screenwriter, columnist, and short story writer. LuvemBooks notes this appears to be a data mismatch in the supplied bio — the review itself documents Alice Duer Miller (July 28, 1874 – August 22, 1942) as a Barnard College graduate, Phi Beta Kappa honoree, and writer whose work spanned poetry, novels, and screenplays, while August Nemo serves as the series curator for the Essential Novelists edition.
What are the main themes?: The collection's central theme is the contradiction between America's foundational democratic rhetoric and the official policy of disenfranchising women — a tension scholars writing for Project MUSE have identified as the direct inspiration for Miller's New York Tribune column. Secondary themes include the absurdity of paternalistic arguments against women's suffrage, the relationship between women's education and political rights, and the capacity of formal verse to operate as both art and political pressure. The satirical register ranges, as Wikipedia notes, 'from comical to biting and harsh,' modulating tone based on the gravity of the statement under examination.
Is this a primary source document?: Yes — Are Women People? functions simultaneously as literature and as a primary-source document of the American suffrage movement. Because Miller structured the Treacherous Texts section by quoting named public figures verbatim above each poem, the collection preserves the actual arguments — from politicians, editorialists, and public officials — that suffragists were fighting in the 1910s. This dual function as satirical art and historical record is one of the reasons LuvemBooks identifies it as particularly valuable for students and scholars of early twentieth-century American political history.

Summarize this book

Is it worth reading?

Who should read this?

About Alice Duer Miller, August Nemo

What are the main themes?

Is this a primary source document?

Summarize this book

Are Women People? A Book of Rhymes for Suffrage Times is a collection of satirical poems, prose pieces, and at least one short play by Alice Duer Miller, organized into five sections: the Treacherous Texts, Campaign Material, Women's Sphere, A Masque of Teachers, and The Unconscious Suffragists. Originally published individually in the New York Tribune between February 4, 1913, and November 4, 1917, and first gathered in book form on June 12, 1915, the collection targets named public figures — including Vice President Thomas R. Marshall — by quoting their statements verbatim and then demolishing the logic in verse. This Essential Novelists edition, curated by August Nemo, presents the work in Kindle format, making a piece recognized by the New York Times as among the important new books of June 1915 accessible to modern readers.

Follow up

How is the book structured?

Where was this originally published?

Why does this collection matter historically?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

Press Enter to ask. Answers come from our editorial Q&A — start typing to see related questions.

Age & Reading Level

Recommended age

Adult

Reading level

Adult

Browse all Adult books

Skip if you're looking for lyric poetry with emotional depth and imagery rather than argument-driven political satire.

Editorial Review

Are Women People? A Book of Rhymes for Suffrage Times is Alice Duer Miller's landmark collection of satirical poetry and prose, originally serialized in the New York Tribune, that skewered anti-suffragist arguments with wit, rhyme, and pointed irony.…

Read the Full Review

Books like Essential Novelists - Alice Duer Miller

Curated picks for readers who enjoyed Essential Novelists - Alice Duer Miller, with our reasoning for each match.

If you liked Essential Novelists - Alice Duer Miller

In our catalogue

The Book Club for Troublesome Women

Marie Bostwick

Women organizing collectively against social resistance — Bostwick's novel brings the spirit of early feminist activism into a warmly character-driven story with quiet satirical edge.

Readers who were drawn to the collective defiance running through Are Women People? — the sense of women refusing to accept the terms set for them — will feel at home in Marie Bostwick's The Book Club for Troublesome Women. Set in 1959 suburban America, it follows a group of women who form a book club and, in doing so, begin quietly pushing back against the roles expected of them. Like Miller's suffrage poems, the book is rooted in a specific historical moment when women's voices were being systematically dismissed, and it finds both humor and sharp social commentary in that situation. If you're looking for books like Are Women People? that pair feminist themes with accessible, character-rich storytelling, this is an ideal companion. It's a gentler read but no less pointed about how women have always had to fight to be heard.

In our catalogue

A Founding Mother

Stephanie Dray, Laura Kamoie

A sharp-minded woman navigating a political world designed to exclude her — this historical novel shares Miller's interest in women who argue, persuade, and resist through language.

Fans of Are Women People? who are drawn to women wielding language and intellect as political tools in a world that would rather they stay silent will find a rich match in A Founding Mother by Stephanie Dray and Laura Kamoie. The novel brings Abigail Adams to life as a full political actor — someone who shaped arguments, lobbied for her views, and pushed back against the founding era's many assumptions about women's place in public life. Like Alice Duer Miller quoting politicians verbatim before dismantling them, Abigail Adams in this novel works through rhetoric and correspondence rather than formal power. If you're searching for 'books like Are Women People? about women in political history' or 'what to read after Are Women People?', this sweeping and well-researched novel delivers that same sense of a brilliant woman making herself heard against the odds.

In our catalogue

The Color Purple

Alice Walker

Both works center women's voices as instruments of resistance — Walker's novel shows what it costs to find and keep that voice across decades of systemic silence.

Alice Duer Miller's Are Women People? is fundamentally about whose voice gets to count — whose arguments are taken seriously, whose presence in public life is legitimized. Alice Walker's The Color Purple asks the same question from a very different angle: through the letters of Celie, a Black woman in the American South who builds selfhood and agency against crushing social and personal oppression. Where Miller's satire is outward-facing and rhetorical, Walker's novel is intimate and cumulative, but both are driven by the conviction that women's inner lives and public worth have been chronically undervalued. For readers asking 'if I liked Are Women People? what literary fiction should I read next?', The Color Purple is a powerful answer — it deepens the same argument through narrative rather than verse, and with an emotional intensity that stays with you long after the last page.

In our catalogue

The Downstairs Girl

Stacey Lee

A young woman writes anonymous satirical newspaper columns to challenge social injustice — direct parallel to Miller's Tribune verse, with a YA-accessible voice and strong period detail.

If the aspect of Are Women People? that hooked you was Alice Duer Miller using a newspaper column as a vehicle for feminist satire — putting her sharpest arguments in print where they could reach the widest public — then Stacey Lee's The Downstairs Girl will feel like a direct companion. Set in 1890s Atlanta, it follows Jo Kuan, a Chinese-American young woman who secretly writes an advice column that challenges the racial and gender prejudices of her era while hiding her identity from the very society she's critiquing. Like Miller's Tribune poems, the novel is deeply rooted in a specific historical moment, uses wit as a weapon, and understands that the press can be a tool of liberation as much as oppression. Readers searching for 'books like Are Women People? with feminist themes and historical setting' will find this one of the most satisfying and direct matches on any list.

Not your thing?

In our catalogue

The Good Lord Bird

James McBride

If the verse format or suffragist context felt too narrow, McBride's satirical, propulsive novel delivers the same skewering of American hypocrisy — but through roaring narrative fiction.

Are Women People? is a collection of satirical verse anchored in a specific political campaign, and readers who admire its intelligence but found the form too fragmented — or who wanted more sustained narrative momentum — should pick up James McBride's The Good Lord Bird. Winner of the National Book Award, it's a comic, irreverent, and ultimately devastating novel about the abolitionist John Brown, told by a young enslaved boy who ends up swept along in Brown's world. Like Miller, McBride is fundamentally a satirist: he uses humor and irony to expose the gap between American ideals and American reality, and he quotes and parodies the pompous language of power with real glee. For readers who bounced off Are Women People? because they wanted a deeper story rather than a sequence of poems, The Good Lord Bird delivers all the same political wit inside an unforgettable, fast-moving novel.