BOOKS
Published
Read Time
10 min read
Reader ratingreader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
4.4
· 18,037 Amazon ratingsShare This Review
An American Beauty by Shana Abé Review: A Forgotten Gilded Age Titan Restored
Shana Abé's An American Beauty is a sweeping historical novel published by Kensington in April 2023, tracing the extraordinary rise of Arabella Yarrington Huntington from a ramshackle Richmond, Virginia boarding house to the heights of Gilded Age New York society. Drawing on the real life of one of America's wealthiest women, Abé — a New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and USA Today bestselling author — crafts a story centered on beauty, ambition, and the steep social cost of female agency in the nineteenth century. The Historical Novel Society's review praised the novel for bringing history to life and shining a light on a largely forgotten figure, while critics noted that it offers "a fascinating look at the choices she made to become a Gilded Age titan." The multiple-perspective structure earns some criticism, but Arabella herself remains a compellingly drawn center of gravity throughout.
LuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Readers of character-driven Gilded Age historical fiction — particularly fans of Marie Benedict, Allison Pataki, or Abé's own The Second Mrs. Astor — who are drawn to rigorously researched stories of real women who built power and autonomy within systems designed to exclude them.
Worth it if
The premise of a scandalous, real rags-to-riches ascent — from boarding-house poverty to the pinnacle of Gilded Age wealth — is what you're after, and you're willing to accept occasional narrative detours into secondary viewpoints in exchange for Abé's evocative period atmosphere and a genuinely complex central character.
Skip if
Readers who strongly prefer a single, tightly focalized perspective throughout will find the shifts to Arabella's mother and Collis's adopted daughter more distracting than enriching, undercutting the novel's most compelling thread.
What readers & critics say
Kirkus Reviews called the novel "a fascinating look at the choices she made to become a Gilded Age titan," while the Historical Novel Society (review by Caroline D. Wilson) praised Abé as "an accomplished author with an evocative writing style" and described Arabella as "a sympathetic but complex character," though it flagged the multi-perspective structure as more distracting than informative. Reader blog Austenprose found the writing "beautifully propulsive," describing the novel as a page-turner.
“This story of one woman's ascent offers a fascinating look at the choices she made to become a Gilded Age titan.”
— Kirkus Reviews4.4from 18,037 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Look inside the book
Preview the actual pages, via Google BooksIn This Review
- What Works & What Doesn't
- The Story at Its Core
- Historical Significance and Subject Matter
- Abé's Craft and the Novel's Strengths
- Structural Limitations Worth Noting
- Who This Novel Is For
What Works & What Doesn't
What Works
- Centers a genuinely forgotten historical figure — Arabella Yarrington Huntington — whose real rags-to-riches story is as dramatic as any invented plot
- Critics praised the novel's detailed depiction of the specific choices that propelled Arabella to become a Gilded Age titan
- Praised by Fiona Davis as the work of 'an exquisite storyteller,' with the Historical Novel Society also commending Abé's evocative writing style
- Arabella is rendered as a sympathetic yet complex character, avoiding the trap of reducing her to either victim or villain
- Builds naturally on Abé's prior Gilded Age work, offering readers of The Second Mrs. Astor a companion novel with a consistent sense of period and voice
What Doesn't
- The Historical Novel Society found the secondary perspectives — those of Arabella's mother Catherine and Collis's adopted daughter Clara — more distracting than illuminating, undercutting the novel's strongest narrative thread
- Readers who prefer a single, tightly focalized point of view throughout may find the structural shifts interrupt the momentum of Arabella's compelling central story
An American Beauty is a richly researched historical novel that resurrects one of the Gilded Age's most extraordinary — and largely overlooked — figures, making a persuasive case for why Arabella Huntington's story deserves a wider audience.
An American Beauty: A Novel of the Gilded Age Inspired by the True Story of Arabella Huntington Who Became the Richest Woman in the Country by Shana Abe front cover
The Story at Its Core
At the heart of An American Beauty is Arabella Yarrington, known as Belle, a young woman of exceptional beauty and even more exceptional determination growing up in poverty in post-Civil War Richmond, Virginia. When she agrees to become the mistress of railroad magnate Collis Huntington, she and her mother, Catherine Yarrington, are lifted from deprivation into a world of wealth — but not without consequence. Arabella's new life in a sumptuous New York City townhouse places her directly under the scrutiny of New York society and, more pointedly, under the eye of the real Mrs. Huntington, Collis's legal wife. The novel traces how Arabella navigates this precarious "shadow wife" existence, leveraging her business acumen and artistic sensibility alongside her celebrated looks, ultimately becoming the wealthiest self-made woman in America. That specific arc — from boarding house to Gilded Age titan — is the novel's engine, and Abé keeps it moving with the pace one would expect from an author with more than a dozen novels to her name.
“an accomplished author with an evocative writing style”
Historical Significance and Subject Matter
Arabella Huntington is a genuine historical figure who amassed extraordinary wealth and wielded real cultural influence, yet she has largely faded from popular memory. Abé, whose previous novel The Second Mrs. Astor also mined the Gilded Age for a forgotten woman's story, clearly has a sustained interest in recovering these lives. The novel sits comfortably alongside the current wave of Gilded Age fiction aimed at readers of Marie Benedict, Karen Harper, and Allison Pataki, and has been positioned as a companion piece of sorts to the cultural conversation sparked by HBO's The Gilded Age. The themes SuperSummary identifies — the influence of beauty and wealth on social mobility, the tension between societal expectation and personal ambition, and women's agency within a patriarchal society — are not merely decorative. They are structural to a story in which Arabella must constantly calculate the value and cost of every choice she makes.
Abé's Craft and the Novel's Strengths
The Historical Novel Society's review, written by Caroline D. Wilson, describes Abé as "an accomplished author with an evocative writing style," and the novel's reception reflects that assessment. Fiona Davis, the New York Times bestselling author of The Magnolia Palace, calls Abé "an exquisite storyteller," a quotation that publisher materials foreground prominently. Arabella herself is described by the Historical Novel Society as "a sympathetic but complex character," and it is this complexity — a woman who is neither purely victim nor purely opportunist, but a strategic survivor — that gives the novel its staying power. Critical coverage, for its part, noted the book's strength in depicting the specific choices that define Arabella's ascent, framing her as a Gilded Age titan whose path to power is traced with genuine attention to the social mechanics of the era.
Structural Limitations Worth Noting
Not every element of the novel's architecture earns equivalent praise. The Historical Novel Society's review specifically flags the multi-perspective structure as a weak point: while the story is primarily told from Arabella's point of view, Abé also gives sections to Catherine Yarrington, Arabella's mother, and to Clara Prentice Huntington, the adopted daughter of Collis Huntington. The intent, as the review notes, was to provide counterpoint to Arabella's perspective. In execution, however, the Historical Novel Society finds these shifts "more distracting than informative" — a meaningful critique given that Arabella's own narrative is described as the more compelling thread. Readers who prefer tightly focalized historical fiction may find the secondary viewpoints dilute rather than deepen the central story.
Who This Novel Is For
An American Beauty is designed for readers who gravitate toward character-driven historical fiction with a strong biographical foundation — particularly those drawn to stories of women who carved out power and autonomy within systems built to exclude them. Its Gilded Age setting, with all the social stratification and conspicuous wealth that entails, will appeal to fans of the current boom in that subgenre. For readers who came to Abé through The Second Mrs. Astor, this novel extends a recognizable sensibility: meticulous period atmosphere, a real woman at the center, and an interest in what it actually cost to become extraordinary. Those seeking a single, immersive point of view throughout may find the structural shifts a mild impediment, but the novel's core subject — Arabella Huntington's improbable, scandalous, triumphant rise — remains the genuine draw.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is An American Beauty worth reading?
LuvemBooks describes it as a richly researched historical novel that makes a persuasive case for why Arabella Huntington's story deserves a wider audience. The review highlights Arabella's complexity as a character — neither purely victim nor purely opportunist — as the element that gives the novel its staying power. Readers drawn to character-driven historical fiction with a strong biographical foundation are likely to find it a rewarding read.
Who is the target audience for An American Beauty?
The review identifies the ideal reader as someone who gravitates toward character-driven historical fiction with a strong biographical foundation, particularly stories of women who carved out power and autonomy within systems built to exclude them. Fans of the current Gilded Age fiction boom — including readers of Marie Benedict, Karen Harper, and Allison Pataki — are specifically called out as natural fits. Those who came to Shana Abe through her previous novel The Second Mrs. Astor will also find a recognizable sensibility here.
What are the main themes in An American Beauty?
The review identifies three structural themes: the influence of beauty and wealth on social mobility, the tension between societal expectation and personal ambition, and women's agency within a patriarchal society. These are described as not merely decorative but structural to a story in which Arabella must constantly calculate the value and cost of every choice she makes. The novel frames her rise as a deliberate, strategic negotiation with the social mechanics of the Gilded Age.
What is the central story of An American Beauty?
The novel follows Arabella Yarrington, known as Belle, a young woman of exceptional beauty and determination growing up in poverty in post-Civil War Richmond, Virginia. She agrees to become the mistress of railroad magnate Collis Huntington, which lifts her and her mother from deprivation into wealth — but places her under intense social scrutiny, including from Collis's legal wife. The arc traces her navigation of this precarious existence, leveraging business acumen and artistic sensibility alongside her looks, ultimately becoming the wealthiest self-made woman in America.
Who was Arabella Huntington, and why does she matter?
Arabella Huntington was a genuine historical figure who amassed extraordinary wealth and wielded real cultural influence during the Gilded Age, yet she has largely faded from popular memory. The review notes that Shana Abe makes a persuasive case for why her story deserves a wider audience, framing her as a Gilded Age titan whose path to power is traced with genuine attention to the social mechanics of the era. Her rise from a boarding house to becoming the wealthiest self-made woman in America is described as the novel's engine.
How is Arabella portrayed as a character in the novel?
The Historical Novel Society, as cited in the review, describes Arabella as a sympathetic but complex character. LuvemBooks elaborates that she is neither purely victim nor purely opportunist, but a strategic survivor — and it is this complexity that gives the novel its staying power. The review credits Abe with depicting the specific choices that define Arabella's ascent with genuine attention to the social mechanics of the era.
What is the novel's narrative structure, and does it work?
The novel primarily follows Arabella's point of view but also gives sections to two secondary characters: Catherine Yarrington, Arabella's mother, and Clara Prentice Huntington, the adopted daughter of Collis Huntington. The intent was to provide counterpoint to Arabella's perspective, but the Historical Novel Society's review, as cited by LuvemBooks, finds these shifts more distracting than informative. Readers who prefer tightly focalized historical fiction may find the secondary viewpoints dilute rather than deepen the central story.
Are the secondary character perspectives in An American Beauty worth reading?
The review flags the multi-perspective structure as one of the novel's notable weak points. While Catherine Yarrington and Clara Prentice Huntington are given their own sections, the Historical Novel Society finds these shifts more distracting than informative, with Arabella's own narrative described as the more compelling thread. Readers sensitive to point-of-view consistency may experience the secondary viewpoints as a mild impediment rather than an enrichment.
What is Shana Abe's writing style like in this novel?
The Historical Novel Society's reviewer Caroline D. Wilson describes Abe as an accomplished author with an evocative writing style, a characterization the review endorses. New York Times bestselling author Fiona Davis is also quoted calling Abe an exquisite storyteller. The review notes that the novel maintains the pace one would expect from an author with more than a dozen novels to her name.
How does An American Beauty compare to Shana Abe's previous novel The Second Mrs. Astor?
The review positions An American Beauty as an extension of the sensibility established in The Second Mrs. Astor, which also mined the Gilded Age for a forgotten woman's story. Both novels share meticulous period atmosphere, a real woman at the center, and an interest in what it actually cost to become extraordinary. LuvemBooks notes that Abe clearly has a sustained interest in recovering the lives of overlooked Gilded Age women across both books.
Sources & Further Reading
The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.
- Cited in this review
- 1
historicalnovelsociety.org
- 2
- 3
- Further reading
- 4
- 5
bookbrowse.com
- 6
- 7
Related Reviews
Reviews of books we picked for readers who enjoyed An American Beauty.
Reader Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!