BOOKS
Published
Read Time
7 min read
Reader ratingreader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
4.6
· 23,503 Amazon ratingsFeatured In
Share This Review
Mindset: The New Psychology of Success by Carol S. Dweck Review: A Million-Copy Bestseller Still Essential Today
Carol S. Dweck's Mindset: The New Psychology of Success is a landmark work of popular psychology from a Stanford University researcher that has sold over a million copies, introducing a generation of readers to the distinction between fixed and growth mindsets and arguing that how people think about their abilities shapes nearly every domain of their lives — from school and work to sports, leadership, and relationships.
LuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Curious general readers — whether in education, business, sport, or parenting — who want a research-grounded introduction to how beliefs about ability shape achievement across virtually every life domain.
Worth it if
You want a single, coherent psychological framework — backed by decades of Stanford research and illustrated across school, sport, leadership, and relationships — that you can genuinely apply to your own thinking and behaviour.
Skip if
You're already well-versed in the academic literature on self-theories, or you need detailed institutional protocols for deploying growth-mindset interventions in classrooms or organisations — this general-audience overview won't go deep enough.
What readers & critics say
Critical coverage, as quoted on annas-archive.org, praised Dweck's "wonderfully elegant idea" and called it "a serious, practical book," welcoming her assertion that rigid thinking benefits no one and that a change of mind is always possible. Psychiatryresource.com found it "a fascinating and popular book" while also noting that some critics have been unable to replicate her research in educational settings — a caveat that underscores the gap between the book's accessible framework and the more contested science that has followed it.
Sources: psychiatryresource.com, annas-archive.org4.6from 23,503 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Look inside the book
Preview the actual pages, via Google BooksIn This Review
- What Works & What Doesn't
- What the Book Actually Argues
- Scope and Structure
- Reception and Significance
- Genuine Strengths
- Who May Find Limitations Here
What Works & What Doesn't
What Works
- Grounded in Carol S. Dweck's decades of original research at Stanford University, giving it more empirical credibility than most popular-psychology titles
- Covers an unusually broad range of life domains — school, sports, leadership, relationships, and parenting — under a single coherent framework
- Endorsed by Bill Gates as illuminating how beliefs about capability shape learning and life paths, reflecting its strong reception among both general readers and public intellectuals
- Has sold over a million copies, demonstrating lasting relevance well beyond its initial publication
- Structured to move from foundational theory to practical application, including a dedicated section on how readers can work to shift their own mindset
What Doesn't
- The popular-audience format necessarily simplifies a research base that has accumulated significant nuance and debate since the book's original publication
- Readers seeking detailed, step-by-step protocols for implementing growth-mindset practices in classrooms or organizations will need to look beyond this general-audience overview
- Case studies drawn from high-profile athletes and executives, while illustrative, are selective examples rather than systematic evidence
A landmark popular-psychology book, Mindset: The New Psychology of Success remains one of the most widely read and discussed works in its field, built on decades of original research by one of Stanford University's leading psychologists.
What the Book Actually Argues
At the heart of Mindset is a deceptively simple distinction that Carol S. Dweck, Ph.D., developed over decades of research in personality, social, and developmental psychology. The book posits two fundamental orientations: a fixed mindset, in which people believe their talents and intelligence are static traits to be proven, and a growth mindset, in which people believe their abilities can be developed through effort and learning. As one passage in the book reads, "When you enter a mindset, you enter a new world. In one world — the world of fixed traits — success is about proving you're smart or talented." Dweck's central argument is that this psychological orientation — not raw talent — dramatically shapes outcomes across school, work, sports, the arts, and personal relationships. The book's guiding provocation is stated plainly early on: it's not always the people who start out the smartest who end up the smartest.
“When you enter a mindset, you enter a new world. In one world — the world of fixed traits — success is about proving you're smart or talented.”
Scope and Structure
The book is organized to move from the psychological foundations outward into virtually every major life context. After establishing the core framework in its opening chapters, it proceeds through chapters examining the mindset of champions in competitive sports, the role of mindset in leadership and organizational culture, how mindsets shape intimate relationships, and how parents, teachers, and coaches transmit mindset to children. A concluding section addresses how readers can actively work to change their own mindset. This arc — from theory to application across multiple domains — gives the book unusual breadth for a work rooted in academic research. The chapter on relationships, for instance, examines how people with fixed versus growth mindsets seek out and respond to partners, exploring whether they look for someone to shore up their self-esteem or someone who will challenge them and foster their development.
Reception and Significance
Mindset has achieved a rare crossover status: it is a million-copy bestseller that has also remained a staple reference in education, executive coaching, and sports psychology. Bill Gates, writing on GatesNotes, offered a frequently cited endorsement: "Through clever research studies and engaging writing, Dweck illuminates how our beliefs about our capabilities exert tremendous influence on how we learn and which paths we take in life." The book draws on real-world figures — including athletes such as Jackie Joyner-Kersee and John McEnroe, and business leaders including Jack Welch and Lee Iacocca — to illustrate how fixed- and growth-mindset patterns play out at the highest levels of achievement. That combination of rigorous sourcing and accessible case studies has made it a durable reference point across fields well beyond academic psychology.
Genuine Strengths
Dweck is a research psychologist first, and the book's credibility rests on that foundation. Rather than offering anecdote-driven self-help, it draws on structured studies — including a well-documented strand of research involving elementary-school children and puzzle difficulty — to demonstrate how mindset shapes behavior in measurable ways. The framework is also genuinely transferable: the same two-mindset lens is applied to parenting, coaching, organizational leadership, and romantic partnership without feeling strained, because Dweck grounds each application in relevant research rather than simply asserting that the concept applies. Readers across very different life stages and professional contexts have found the framework actionable, which helps account for the book's sustained presence on bestseller lists long after its initial publication.
Who May Find Limitations Here
Readers already deeply familiar with the academic literature on self-theories and implicit beliefs may find that the popular format necessarily simplifies the nuance of that research base. Some readers — particularly those in social science or education who have followed subsequent debates about replication and implementation of growth-mindset interventions — have noted that translating the concept from the lab to classroom or workplace practice is more complex than a general-audience book can fully capture. The book is written for a broad popular audience, not as a practitioner's manual, and readers seeking detailed protocols for applying growth-mindset principles in institutional settings will need to supplement it with more technical resources. Additionally, the case studies drawn from celebrity athletes and famous executives, while vivid, are necessarily selective illustrations rather than systematic evidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
is Mindset: The New Psychology of Success by Carol S. Dweck worth reading
It's worth reading if you want a research-backed framework for understanding how beliefs about ability shape outcomes across school, work, sports, and relationships — the review notes it has achieved rare crossover status as both a million-copy bestseller and a staple reference in education, executive coaching, and sports psychology. That said, if you're already deep in the academic literature on self-theories, the popular format does simplify the nuance of the underlying research, so it's best approached as a highly accessible introduction rather than a comprehensive scholarly text.
What is this book actually about
At its core, it's about the difference between a fixed mindset — believing your talents and intelligence are static traits to be proven — and a growth mindset — believing abilities can be developed through effort and learning. Dweck argues, drawing on decades of Stanford research, that this psychological orientation, not raw talent, dramatically shapes outcomes across virtually every major life domain, and the book famously opens with the provocation that it's not always the people who start out the smartest who end up the smartest.
Does this book actually help you change your mindset
The book dedicates a concluding section to how readers can actively work to change their own mindset, and the review notes that readers across very different life stages and professional contexts have found the framework actionable. However, the review is honest that the book is written for a broad popular audience, not as a practitioner's manual, so readers wanting detailed protocols for applying growth-mindset principles in institutional settings will need to supplement it with more technical resources.
Is this book good for teachers and parents or just business people
It's genuinely broad — the book applies its two-mindset lens to parenting, coaching, organizational leadership, and romantic partnership, with Dweck grounding each application in relevant research rather than just asserting the concept applies. There's even a dedicated chapter on how parents, teachers, and coaches transmit mindset to children, so educators and parents are very much a core intended audience alongside business readers.
Who are the real-life examples in this book
Dweck draws on a mix of athletes and executives to illustrate fixed and growth mindset patterns at the highest levels of achievement — figures including Jackie Joyner-Kersee and John McEnroe on the sports side, and business leaders including Jack Welch and Lee Iacocca on the corporate side. The review notes these are vivid illustrations rather than systematic evidence, so they work best as memorable examples anchoring the research rather than proof points on their own.
Is this book too basic if i already know about growth mindset
If you've already encountered the concept through education or workplace training, the core fixed vs. growth mindset distinction will feel familiar, and the review acknowledges that readers already deeply familiar with the academic literature on self-theories and implicit beliefs may find the popular format necessarily simplifies the research base. For those who've also followed subsequent debates about replication and implementation of growth-mindset interventions, some of the book's confidence in translating lab findings to classroom or workplace practice may feel underdeveloped.
Is this book more self-help or actual science
It sits firmly between the two — Dweck is a research psychologist first, and the book draws on structured studies, including a well-documented strand of research involving elementary-school children and puzzle difficulty, rather than relying on anecdote-driven self-help. Bill Gates described it on GatesNotes as using "clever research studies and engaging writing," which captures the balance well: it's credible science made genuinely accessible, not pop psychology dressed up in academic language.
Sources & Further Reading
The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.
- Cited in this review
- 1
- 2
- 3
static1.squarespace.com
- Further reading
- 4
proemergency.com
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
newbookrecommendation.com
- 9
Related Reviews
Reviews of books we picked for readers who enjoyed Mindset.
Reader Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!