BOOKS
Published
Read Time
8 min read
Reader ratingreader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
3.6
· 165 Amazon ratingsShare This Review
Fast Boys and Pretty Girls by Lo Patrick Review: A Slow-Burn Southern Mystery of First Love
Lo Patrick's third novel is a gritty, coming-of-age Southern mystery that excavates the obsessive, devastating power of first love through the story of Danielle Greer — a North Georgia country girl whose past refuses to stay buried, even after a body surfaces in her own backyard.
Tap to enlargeLuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Readers of literary Southern fiction who want a mystery used as a scaffold for excavating character and memory — specifically those drawn to psychologically dense, dual-timeline narratives about first love, family wounds, and the weight of the past set in a vividly atmospheric North Georgia landscape.
Worth it if
The slow-burn pacing and deep immersion in Dani's adolescent obsession sound like features rather than bugs — this rewards patience and an appetite for character interiority over procedural plot mechanics.
Skip if
Plot-driven thriller readers who need propulsive momentum and a tightly resolved mystery will likely find the deliberate pacing and the psychologically weighted coming-of-age framework more taxing than satisfying — and fans who especially loved The Floating Girls may find this third novel a different, not universally preferred, experience.
What readers & critics say
Fictionophile.com, having read all three Patrick novels, found this one admirable in its descriptive writing but ranked it below The Floating Girls, reflecting a view that the book's specific texture won't land equally for all of Patrick's existing readership. Bookclb.com describes it as "a haunting, beautifully written novel" and a "masterfully crafted Southern Gothic mystery" that confirms Patrick as "a formidable voice in contemporary Southern fiction," while bookishelf.com identifies structural strain in the final act, noting the resolution feels "somewhat rushed after the careful buildup."
Sources: fictionophile.com, bookclb.com, bookishelf.com3.6from 165 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
In This Review
- What Works & What Doesn't
- What the Novel Is and What It Argues
- Place in Patrick's Body of Work and the Genre
- What the Novel Does Well
- Genuine Limitations and Who May Be Frustrated
- Who This Novel Is For
What Works & What Doesn't
What Works
- Psychologically precise portrayal of first love's obsessive, destabilizing power, praised by fellow authors as 'superbly depicted'
- Dual past-and-present timeline links a present-day mystery to the formative wounds of Dani's adolescence with deliberate structural purpose
- Strongly atmospheric North Georgia setting that functions as an active element of the novel's tone and pacing
- Comes from an author whose debut earned a starred Publishers Weekly review and a Townsend Prize for Fiction nomination, lending the series real literary credibility
What Doesn't
- The slow-burn pacing and emphasis on character interiority over procedural momentum will frustrate readers seeking a plot-driven thriller
- Readers who especially loved Patrick's debut, The Floating Girls, may find this third novel a different — and not universally preferred — experience
Patrick delivers a slow-burn Southern mystery that is as much a psychological portrait of first love as it is a thriller — and the combination gives the novel its distinctive, unsettling charge.
What the Novel Is and What It Argues
Back cover with synopsis, review quotes, and barcode for a coming-of-age mystery novel.
Fast Boys and Pretty Girls opens on a deceptively ordinary domestic scene: Danielle "Dani" Greer has returned to the mountains of North Georgia, settling back into her childhood home with her husband and four daughters after a semi-successful career as a teen model in New York City. That fragile peace cracks wide open one stifling afternoon when the girls discover a body in the ravine behind the house. From there, the narrative begins moving between Dani's present and her adolescence — specifically her consuming, destabilizing entanglement with local bad boy Benji Law, a relationship she was never quite certain how to read. The novel's central argument is that first love is not merely formative but potentially corrosive: it shapes how a young person sees the world, how she measures her own worth, and what she carries forward without ever intending to.
“the complex and emotional difficulties that often come with first love”
Place in Patrick's Body of Work and the Genre
This is Patrick's third novel, following The Floating Girls and The Night the River Wept. Her debut, The Floating Girls, earned a starred review from Publishers Weekly, was a finalist for the Townsend Prize for Fiction, and was a Reader's Digest Editor's Pick — a debut record that established her as a writer of literary Southern suspense with genuine critical backing. Fast Boys and Pretty Girls, published by Sourcebooks Landmark in July 2025, fits firmly within that tradition: atmospheric, character-driven, and rooted in a specific, vividly rendered Southern landscape. The novel's Georgia setting is not mere backdrop; blurbs from fellow authors describe it as carrying "turns as sharp as a Georgia back road," suggesting that place and narrative momentum are deliberately intertwined.
What the Novel Does Well
The book's strongest suit, by the account of multiple advance readers and fellow authors, is the psychological precision with which Patrick renders Dani's inner life. Donna Everhart, the bestselling author of When the Jessamine Grows, writes that "Dani's insecurities, willfulness, and obsession are superbly depicted by Patrick, who turns a shrewd eye on the psychology of first love and family dynamics," calling it "an absolutely riveting read." Suzanne Redfearn, describing the past-and-present structure, notes that Patrick "does a masterful job setting the stage for the gripping suspense." The dual-timeline construction allows the novel to do something more ambitious than a straightforward mystery: it uses the discovery of the body as a lens through which to re-examine the formative wounds that shaped the woman standing in that ravine. The themes — innocence lost, the parent-child relationship, forgiveness, and the hunt for belonging — are woven through both timelines rather than confined to one.
Genuine Limitations and Who May Be Frustrated
Readers who come to the novel primarily for plot-driven thriller mechanics may find the pacing a deliberate challenge. The "slow-burn" label in the publisher's own framing is accurate, and the novel's investment in character interiority over procedural momentum is a conscious choice that will not suit every mystery reader. One blogger who had previously read Patrick's work noted a preference for The Floating Girls over this title, suggesting that fans of the debut's specific texture may experience Fast Boys and Pretty Girls differently. The coming-of-age framework also means that a significant portion of the narrative is filtered through an adolescent consciousness — Dani's obsession with Benji Law, her uncertainty, her willfulness — which can be uncomfortable by design. Readers who want a more emotionally distanced or plot-forward mystery may find the immersion in Dani's psychology more taxing than rewarding.
Who This Novel Is For
Fast Boys and Pretty Girls is squarely for readers who gravitate toward literary Southern fiction with a suspense spine — the kind of novel that uses a mystery as a scaffold for excavating character and memory rather than as an end in itself. The combination of a body-in-the-backyard premise, a dual timeline, a model-turned-mother protagonist, and a North Georgia setting gives the book a specific, atmospheric identity. As Jennifer Moorhead, author of Broken Bayou, frames it, the novel tackles "the complex and emotional difficulties that often come with first love" — which is ultimately the real subject. For readers willing to sit with Dani's obsession and let the suspense build slowly, Patrick offers what Redfearn calls a story that proves "you can't ever really leave your past behind."
Frequently Asked Questions
is Fast Boys and Pretty Girls: A Novel by Lo Patrick worth reading
It depends on what you're looking for in a mystery. If you enjoy literary Southern fiction where the suspense serves as a scaffold for excavating character and memory — rather than a plot-driven thriller — then the novel's psychological precision and atmospheric North Georgia setting make it a rewarding read. Readers who want procedural momentum over character interiority, however, may find the slow-burn pacing a deliberate challenge.
What is this book actually about
On the surface it's a mystery: Dani Greer, a former teen model turned mother, returns to her North Georgia childhood home, and her daughters discover a body in the ravine behind the house. But the real subject is the psychology of first love — specifically Dani's consuming, destabilizing entanglement with local bad boy Benji Law during her adolescence, and how that relationship shaped her sense of worth and what she carries forward. The novel moves between Dani's present and her teenage years, using the body as a lens to re-examine the formative wounds that made her who she is.
Is this book too slow
The publisher's own framing uses the term "slow-burn," so yes, the pacing is deliberate and the novel prioritizes Dani's inner life over thriller mechanics. One blogger who had previously read Lo Patrick's work noted a preference for her debut The Floating Girls over this title, suggesting even existing fans may experience the pacing differently. Readers who enjoy sitting with a character's psychology — Dani's obsession with Benji Law, her willfulness, her uncertainty — will find the build rewarding rather than frustrating.
How does this book compare to Lo Patrick's other books
This is Lo Patrick's third novel, following The Floating Girls and The Night the River Wept, and it fits firmly within her tradition of atmospheric, character-driven Southern suspense. That said, at least one reader who had previously read her work noted a preference for The Floating Girls — her starred-reviewed, Townsend Prize finalist debut — over this title. Fans of the debut's specific texture may find Fast Boys and Pretty Girls a slightly different experience, though the literary DNA is consistent.
What kind of reader is this book good for
It's squarely aimed at readers who gravitate toward literary Southern fiction with a suspense spine — think atmosphere, dual timelines, and deep character psychology over whodunit mechanics. Bestselling author Donna Everhart calls Dani's insecurities, willfulness, and obsession "superbly depicted," and author Jennifer Moorhead highlights the novel's treatment of "the complex and emotional difficulties that often come with first love." If those themes resonate with you more than procedural mystery plotting, this book is a strong fit.
Does this book deal with dark or uncomfortable themes
Yes, intentionally so. A significant portion of the narrative is filtered through Dani's adolescent consciousness as she navigates her obsessive, destabilizing relationship with Benji Law — and the review notes the discomfort is by design. Themes of innocence lost, the parent-child relationship, forgiveness, and the hunt for belonging run through both timelines, and the novel's central argument is that first love can be not just formative but potentially corrosive.
Is this book similar to other Southern gothic mysteries
It shares DNA with literary Southern suspense in the tradition of character-driven, place-rooted fiction — blurbs describe the Georgia setting as carrying "turns as sharp as a Georgia back road," with place and narrative momentum deliberately intertwined. Author Jennifer Moorhead of Broken Bayou and Donna Everhart of When the Jessamine Grows both blurbed the book, which gives a sense of its literary neighborhood. If you've enjoyed that corner of Southern fiction, Lo Patrick's dual-timeline structure and psychological focus should feel familiar and appealing.
Sources & Further Reading
The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.
- Cited in this review
- 1
lopatrickbooks.com
- 2
- 3
- Further reading
- 4
- 5
Related Reviews
Reviews of books we picked for readers who enjoyed Fast Boys and Pretty Girls.
Reader Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!