BOOKS
Published
Read Time
3 min read
Reader ratingreader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
4.0
· 46 Amazon ratingsShare This Review
The Secret World of Briar Rose by Cindy Pham Review: A Sapphic, Grief-Laden Fairy-Tale Reimagining
A #1 New York Times bestseller and debut novel from queer Vietnamese-American author and YouTuber Cindy Pham, The Secret World of Briar Rose is a Sapphic retelling of "Sleeping Beauty" published by Kokila that weaves together mental health, grief, identity, and the seductive danger of escapism through a layered dreamworld narrative aimed at readers aged 14 and up.
LuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Readers aged 14 and up who want a structurally ambitious, emotionally serious Sapphic fairy-tale retelling and are comfortable with shifting timelines, grief, mental health themes, and queer and nonbinary representation woven into the core cast.
Worth it if
The narrative's emotional demands and non-linear structure suit you — if dark, layered YA fantasy that treats escapism and grief as its primary subject matter is exactly what you're looking for, the starred trade reviews and #1 NYT bestseller status suggest it earns that weight.
Skip if
You're hoping for a breezy, lighthearted fairy-tale retelling — critics and readers alike flag confusing worldbuilding, time jumps, and sustained emotional confrontations with depression and suicidal ideation that make this a demanding rather than comforting read.
What readers & critics say
Kirkus Reviews called it "somberly beautiful," while Publishers Weekly praised its "intersectionally diverse, emotionally complex characters" navigating "an empathetic exploration of identity, grief, forgiveness, and mental health," as relayed via panmacmillan.com. School Library Journal awarded it a starred review, writing that "this ambitious, intelligent novel hits all its marks and provides a beautiful, challenging read," as cited on penguinrandomhouse.com — though some reader reviewers on Lesbrary and StoryGraph flagged confusing worldbuilding and a dreamworld setting that doesn't always give readers enough solid grounding.
Sources: Kirkus Reviews (via Pan Macmillan), Penguin Random House, Lesbrary, StoryGraph4.0from 46 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
In This Review
- What Works & What Doesn't
- What the Book Actually Is
- Narrative Structure and Ambition
- Critical Reception and Significance
- The Author's Voice and Context
- Who This Book Is For and Where It Challenges
What Works & What Doesn't
What Works
- Debuted as a #1 New York Times bestseller and earned a USA Today bestseller designation, reflecting broad readership alongside strong critical traction
- Received a starred review from School Library Journal for its emotional depth in exploring identity, grief, and belonging
- Offers meaningful queer and nonbinary representation woven into the core cast and central relationships, not as an afterthought
- Published by Kokila with a richly designed deluxe first edition featuring embossed jacket, colored edges, illustrated endpapers, and gold foil-stamped case
- Tackles mental health, escapism, and grief with thematic seriousness, earning Booklist's description of 'somberly beautiful'
What Doesn't
- Critical coverage notes the novel 'asks a lot of readers,' with time jumps, emotional confrontations, and memory-inhabiting sequences requiring sustained, intense engagement — a structural challenge that may not suit all tastes
- The dark and emotionally demanding subject matter — grief, mental health, the pull of escape — makes this a weighty read rather than a breezy fairy-tale retelling, which will not match every reader's expectations for the genre
This debut novel is not a light fairy-tale update — it is a structurally ambitious, emotionally demanding reimagining that earned a #1 New York Times bestseller ranking on the strength of its thematic weight.
The Secret World of Briar Rose by Cindy Pham front cover
What the Book Actually Is
The Secret World of Briar Rose centers on Corin, a girl searching for her missing sister, who discovers a hidden dreamworld — described in the text as "where your subconscious desires come to life." Inside that dreamworld, Corin encounters two figures: Briar Rose, the alter ego of a cursed princess named Amelia who experienced profound sadness and chose to fall asleep, and Malicine, a green-skinned, nonbinary demon who placed the curse of eternal slumber on Amelia yet proves to be, in the book's telling, largely a sympathetic presence. All three characters are, at their core, running from things they cannot face. The novel is structured as a Sapphic reimagining of "Sleeping Beauty," and its central concerns — escapism, grief, the search for belonging, and the longing for a better world — are woven into the mechanics of its dreamworld setting.
“where your subconscious desires come to life.”
Narrative Structure and Ambition
critical coverage notes that the novel "asks a lot of readers as it seesaws between emotional confrontations, time jumps, and scenes where one character inhabits the memories of another, all of which demand intense engagement." This is a fair characterization of the book's design intent: the narrative does not move in a straight line. Memory, identity, and dream bleed into one another, and the story is built around the idea that all three of its central figures are shaped — and haunted — by what they refuse to confront directly. Pham structures the book so that the dreamworld becomes not an escape hatch but a pressure cooker, forcing characters toward the emotional reckonings they have been deferring.
Critical Reception and Significance
The novel arrived with substantial critical recognition for a debut. School Library Journal awarded it a starred review, writing that "the emotional depth of the characters adds many layers to the search for identity, overcoming grief, and finding belonging; the book shows how hope, love, and redemption can exist in this darkness." Critics called it "somberly beautiful." The novel also landed on the 2026 critical coverage Summer Reads Best Books List and the July/August 2026 Kids' Indie Next List, alongside its #1 New York Times bestseller status and a USA Today bestseller designation. That breadth of recognition — trade journals, bookseller lists, and national sales charts — marks it as a notable debut within YA fantasy, not merely a viral one.
The Author's Voice and Context
Cindy Pham is a queer Vietnamese-American author and full-time designer based in New York City, whose YouTube channel Read With Cindy has accumulated over half a million subscribers focused on books, film reactions, and commentary. The Secret World of Briar Rose is her debut novel, published by Kokila, an imprint known for centering diverse voices in children's and young adult literature. Pham's dual background as a designer and content creator shapes her public profile, but the novel's reception — anchored in starred trade reviews rather than social media metrics — suggests that critical standing rests on the work itself.
Who This Book Is For and Where It Challenges
The novel is designed for readers aged 14 and up, and that upper end of the target range matters. Critical coverage's observation that the book "asks a lot of readers" points to a real consideration: the narrative's shifting timelines, inhabiting of other characters' memories, and sustained emotional confrontations with grief and mental health are not background texture but the primary experience. Readers drawn to lush, immersive fairy-tale retellings with queer representation, and who are comfortable with structural complexity and dark emotional terrain, are the audience this book is built for. Those seeking a lighter, more linear retelling may find the demands considerable — but for the right reader, the starred reviews and critical coverage's verdict of "somberly beautiful" suggest it delivers exactly what it sets out to do.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is The Secret World of Briar Rose worth reading?
The review notes that for the right reader — one drawn to lush, immersive fairy-tale retellings with queer representation and comfortable with structural complexity and dark emotional terrain — the book delivers exactly what it sets out to do. Its starred review from School Library Journal and its #1 New York Times bestseller status suggest it has earned its critical standing on the strength of the work itself, not merely on social media buzz. That said, readers seeking a lighter or more linear retelling may find its demands considerable.
Who is the target audience for this book?
The novel is designed for readers aged 14 and up, and the review emphasizes that the upper end of that range matters. It is built for readers who are comfortable with shifting timelines, sustained emotional confrontations with grief and mental health, and structural complexity — not those looking for a straightforward fairy-tale update. Queer representation is also central to the book's design, making it particularly resonant for readers seeking Sapphic retellings.
What is the price of this book?
The Secret World of Briar Rose is priced at $16.48, which positions it as an accessible entry point for a debut novel that has earned both #1 New York Times bestseller status and a starred review from School Library Journal. Given the breadth of its critical recognition, the review implies strong value for readers who match the book's intended audience.
What are the main themes in this book?
The review identifies escapism, grief, the search for belonging, and the longing for a better world as the novel's central concerns, all woven into the mechanics of its dreamworld setting. School Library Journal's starred review, as quoted in the piece, also highlights the emotional depth around identity, overcoming grief, and finding belonging, noting that the book shows how hope, love, and redemption can exist in darkness.
How does the book handle the theme of escapism?
The review notes that while the dreamworld initially appears to be a place of escape — described in the text as where your subconscious desires come to life — author Cindy Pham structures it to function as a pressure cooker rather than an escape hatch. All three central characters are running from things they cannot face, and the dreamworld ultimately forces them toward the emotional reckonings they have been deferring.
What is the plot of this book?
The novel centers on Corin, a girl searching for her missing sister, who discovers a hidden dreamworld where she encounters two key figures: Briar Rose, the alter ego of a cursed princess named Amelia who experienced profound sadness and chose to fall asleep, and Malicine, a green-skinned, nonbinary demon who placed the curse of eternal slumber on Amelia. The review describes it as a Sapphic reimagining of Sleeping Beauty, with all three characters shaped and haunted by what they refuse to confront directly.
How is the book structured narratively?
The review describes the narrative as structurally ambitious, noting that it seesaws between emotional confrontations, time jumps, and scenes where one character inhabits the memories of another — all of which demand intense engagement from the reader. Memory, identity, and dream bleed into one another, and the story does not move in a straight line, making it a deliberate and demanding design rather than a conventional linear retelling.
Is the narrative structure easy to follow?
The review is candid that the book asks a lot of readers, citing its shifting timelines, inhabiting of other characters' memories, and sustained emotional confrontations as the primary experience rather than background texture. Readers who prefer straightforward storytelling may find the demands considerable, while those comfortable with structural complexity are the audience the book is built for.
Who are the main characters in this book?
The three central characters are Corin, the protagonist searching for her missing sister; Briar Rose, the alter ego of a cursed princess named Amelia who chose to fall asleep after experiencing profound sadness; and Malicine, a green-skinned, nonbinary demon who placed the curse of eternal slumber on Amelia. The review notes that all three are, at their core, running from things they cannot face.
What kind of character is Malicine?
Malicine is described in the review as a green-skinned, nonbinary demon who placed the curse of eternal slumber on the princess Amelia, yet proves to be largely a sympathetic presence in the book's telling. Rather than functioning as a straightforward villain, Malicine is portrayed as one of three characters shaped and haunted by what they refuse to confront directly.
Sources & Further Reading
The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.
- Cited in this review
- 1
- 2
commonsensemedia.org
- 3
panmacmillan.com
- 4
- Further reading
- 5
kirkusreviews.com
- 6
publishersweekly.com
- 7
- 8
readwithcindy.com
- 9
app.thestorygraph.com
- 10
- 11
beforewegoblog.com
- 12
Related Reviews
Reviews of books we picked for readers who enjoyed The Secret World of Briar Rose.
Reader Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!