BOOKS
Published
Read Time
8 min read
Reader ratingreader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
4.7
· 3,956 Amazon ratingsShare This Review
Cook Like a Pro by Ina Garten Review: A Confidence-Building Cookbook for Every Level
Cook Like a Pro is Ina Garten's eleventh cookbook and a #1 New York Times bestseller, published by Clarkson Potter in October 2018. It earns its strong reception by embedding practical technique guidance — written directly in the margins of each recipe — alongside dishes such as Red Wine–Braised Short Ribs, Cauliflower Toasts with prosciutto and Gruyère, and Truffled Scrambled Eggs. The result is a cookbook designed to carry home cooks from comfortable to genuinely skilled, without abandoning the warm, accessible register that has defined Garten's work. This review assesses the book's content, structure, and published reception — not a kitchen test.
LuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Home cooks who already enjoy Ina Garten's Barefoot Contessa style and want to stretch their skills toward more ambitious, dinner-party-worthy dishes — without abandoning the warm, approachable sensibility they love.
Worth it if
You want to genuinely level up your cooking confidence through recipes that embed technique guidance exactly where you need it, mid-recipe, rather than in chapters you'll never revisit.
Skip if
You're looking for bold culinary departures from Garten's signature comfort-food aesthetic, or primarily need efficient weeknight meals rather than elegant entertaining centerpieces.
What readers & critics say
The book debuted as a #1 New York Times bestseller and was named one of the best books of 2018 by a broad coalition of outlets — including the New York Times Book Review, Food & Wine, and Eater — as documented across penguinrandomhouse.com and barnesandnoble.com. Eater.com observed that Garten's willingness to embrace self-doubt and ease, rather than prescriptive perfection, is "her real secret sauce," while The Kitchn's own review praised the book as filled with trustworthy, approachable recipes and highlighted practical details like ingredient-swap guidance and pantry staple recipes near the book's end.
Sources: Penguin Random House, Barnes & Noble, Eater, The Kitchn4.7from 3,956 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Look inside the book
Preview the actual pages, via Google BooksIn This Review
- What Works & What Doesn't
- What the Book Is and What It Sets Out to Do
- Reception and Critical Standing
- The Margin-Note Format as a Structural Strength
- Ambition Calibrated to Accessibility
- Limitations and Who May Want More
What Works & What Doesn't
What Works
- #1 New York Times bestseller named a best book of 2018 by more than ten major outlets, including the New York Times Book Review, Food & Wine, and Eater
- Innovative margin-note format delivers technique tips exactly where they're needed, mid-recipe, rather than in easily skipped front matter
- Recipes span a range of ambition — from Truffled Scrambled Eggs to Red Wine–Braised Short Ribs — designed to build genuine confidence alongside new dishes
- Explicitly accessible to both beginners and more experienced home cooks, with the Chicago Tribune noting it raises the bar while remaining 'warm, comforting, homey'
- Covers skills beyond the stove, including guidance on setting up an elegant home bar
What Doesn't
- Firmly rooted in Garten's established Barefoot Contessa aesthetic — readers seeking bold culinary departures from her signature style will not find them here
- The book's emphasis on elegant entertaining and dinner-party centerpieces makes it less focused on everyday weeknight cooking
Cook Like a Pro represents a deliberate step forward for Ina Garten, pitching itself at a slightly more ambitious level than her earlier Barefoot Contessa titles without leaving her loyal audience behind.
What the Book Is and What It Sets Out to Do
Cook Like a Pro: Recipes and Tips for Home Cooks: A Barefoot Contessa Cookbook by Ina Garten front cover
Cook Like a Pro is a recipe collection structured around one central idea: that professional-level confidence is teachable, and that the right moment to teach it is mid-recipe, not in a separate chapter a reader may skip. Garten embeds technique notes, tips, and process explanations directly in the margins of each recipe — the publisher describes the format as having Garten "in the kitchen by your side guiding you through the recipe." Specific dishes anchor that ambition to real cooking: Red Wine–Braised Short Ribs, Cauliflower Toasts with prosciutto and Gruyère, Truffled Scrambled Eggs, and Chocolate Chevron Cake are among the recipes highlighted, each serving as a vehicle for a concrete lesson. The book also covers skills outside the stove, including guidance on setting up an elegant home bar. Published by Clarkson Potter in October 2018, it is Garten's eleventh book and the latest entry in the long-running Barefoot Contessa series.
“filled with trustworthy recipes that taste delicious and don't require a culinary degree to make.”
Reception and Critical Standing
The book landed as a #1 New York Times bestseller and was named one of the best books of the year by an unusually wide coalition of outlets, including Food & Wine, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, and Delish, among others. The Chicago Tribune captured the book's tonal balance well: "Garten has kicked things up a level, this time encouraging readers to try more ambitious recipes that are still signature Ina: warm, comforting, homey." Published reviews described it as "filled with trustworthy recipes that taste delicious and don't require a culinary degree to make." That breadth of critical enthusiasm — spanning food-specialist outlets, general-interest publications, and regional papers — is well documented and reflects a genuine consensus around the book's quality.
The Margin-Note Format as a Structural Strength
The book's most distinctive design decision is its use of in-margin annotations. Rather than front-loading technique in introductory chapters, Garten's tips appear exactly where a cook needs them: beside the step in question. The tip for keeping a stovetop clean while making short ribs (roasting them in the oven rather than browning on the stove), the method for cutting cauliflower florets from the stem end with the head turned upside-down, and the counterintuitive instruction to add eggs to the skillet before the butter melts for Truffled Scrambled Eggs are all presented this way. This structure is designed so that a cook does not need to have internalized the technique in advance — the guidance arrives at the point of need, integrated into the recipe's own flow.
Ambition Calibrated to Accessibility
One of the more notable editorial choices in Cook Like a Pro is its refusal to treat ambition and accessibility as opposites. The recipes are described by the publisher as "foolproof" while simultaneously reaching for dishes — braised short ribs, a decorated chevron-patterned cake — that carry genuine visual and culinary impact. The Chicago Tribune's observation that the book "kicks things up a level" while remaining "warm, comforting, homey" identifies exactly this calibration. Readers who have worked through earlier Barefoot Contessa titles will find the difficulty register nudged upward in a way that feels earned rather than abrupt, while readers coming to Garten for the first time are not assumed to have prior expertise. The publisher explicitly positions it as suitable for both beginners and advanced home cooks.
Limitations and Who May Want More
Readers seeking radical experimentation or recipes that push well outside the comfort-food tradition Garten has built her career on will find Cook Like a Pro consistent with — rather than a departure from — her established aesthetic. The book is explicitly designed to refine and deepen the Barefoot Contessa approach, not to reinvent it. For cooks already deeply familiar with Garten's previous ten books, some of the broader sensibility will feel familiar terrain, even as the individual recipes and margin-tip format are new. Additionally, the book's focus on elevated home entertaining — including the home bar section and dinner-party-worthy centerpieces — means it is most fully useful to cooks for whom hosting is a regular goal, rather than those focused primarily on weeknight efficiency.
Frequently Asked Questions
is Cook Like a Pro: Recipes by Ina Garten worth buying
It landed as a #1 New York Times bestseller and was named one of the best books of the year by an unusually wide coalition of outlets including the New York Times Book Review, Food & Wine, Eater, The Kitchn, and the Chicago Tribune — a genuine critical consensus that's hard to ignore. The Kitchn described it as "filled with trustworthy recipes that taste delicious and don't require a culinary degree to make," which gives a good sense of what you're actually getting. It's a strong pick if you want to build real kitchen confidence without abandoning accessible, comforting food.
What is this book actually about
The core idea is that professional-level confidence is teachable — and Garten teaches it mid-recipe, not in a separate chapter you might skip, by embedding technique notes and tips directly in the margins beside each step. Specific recipes like Red Wine–Braised Short Ribs, Cauliflower Toasts with prosciutto and Gruyère, Truffled Scrambled Eggs, and Chocolate Chevron Cake each serve as vehicles for a concrete lesson. There's also guidance on setting up an elegant home bar, making it as much about the full entertaining experience as it is about cooking.
Is this book good for beginners or is it too advanced
The publisher explicitly positions it as suitable for both beginners and advanced home cooks, and the review backs that up — readers new to Garten are not assumed to have prior expertise, while longtime fans will find the difficulty nudged upward in a way that feels earned rather than abrupt. The in-margin tip format means guidance arrives exactly when you need it, like when to add eggs before the butter melts for Truffled Scrambled Eggs, so you don't need to have internalized technique in advance. That said, it's most fully useful to cooks for whom hosting and entertaining are regular goals, not those focused primarily on weeknight efficiency.
How is this book different from ina garten's other barefoot contessa books
It's Garten's eleventh book and represents a deliberate step forward — the Chicago Tribune noted that "Garten has kicked things up a level, this time encouraging readers to try more ambitious recipes that are still signature Ina: warm, comforting, homey." The biggest structural difference is the in-margin annotation format, where technique tips appear right beside the relevant step rather than front-loaded in introductory chapters. So while the warm, accessible Barefoot Contessa sensibility is intact, the difficulty register is nudged upward and the teaching method is genuinely new.
Does this book actually teach you techniques or is it just recipes
Teaching technique is the whole point of the format — rather than separating instruction from cooking, Garten's tips are embedded in the margins exactly where a cook needs them. The review highlights specific examples: the tip for keeping a stovetop clean while making short ribs (roasting in the oven instead of browning on the stove), how to cut cauliflower florets by turning the head upside-down, and the counterintuitive move of adding eggs to the skillet before the butter melts for Truffled Scrambled Eggs. The publisher describes the effect as having Garten "in the kitchen by your side guiding you through the recipe."
Is this book good for someone who wants to try new or experimental cooking
Honestly, probably not — the review is clear that readers seeking radical experimentation or recipes that push well outside the comfort-food tradition will find this book consistent with Garten's established aesthetic rather than a departure from it. It's explicitly designed to refine and deepen the Barefoot Contessa approach, not reinvent it. If you're already deeply familiar with her previous ten books, the broader sensibility will feel like familiar terrain, even though the individual recipes and margin-tip format are new.
Is this book good for dinner parties and entertaining
It's arguably most in its element for exactly that — the review notes the book is most fully useful to cooks for whom hosting is a regular goal, and the recipes reflect that, including dinner-party-worthy centerpieces like Red Wine–Braised Short Ribs and Chocolate Chevron Cake alongside a dedicated home bar section. If weeknight efficiency is your main priority, it may feel like overkill. But if you want to cook with genuine confidence and visual impact for guests, this is built for you.
Sources & Further Reading
The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.
- Cited in this review
- 1
- 2
penguinrandomhouse.com
- 3
- Further reading
- 4
Ina Garten, Wikipedia
- 5
barefootcontessa.com
- 6
- 7
thesimplyluxuriouslife.com
- 8
- 9
modernfarmer.com
Related Reviews
Reviews of books we picked for readers who enjoyed Cook Like a Pro.
Reader Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!