BOOKS
Published
Read Time
4 min read
Reader ratingreader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
4.3
· 81,855 Amazon ratingsShare This Review
That's Not My Name by Megan Lally Review: A Gripping Debut YA Thriller
Megan Lally's debut YA thriller That's Not My Name, published by Sourcebooks Fire on December 26, 2023, delivers two interlocking storylines — a teenage girl with amnesia trying to determine whether the man claiming to be her father is telling the truth, and a boy racing to clear his name in his girlfriend's disappearance — that Kirkus Reviews calls "a thrilling delight right up to the unexpected and bittersweet conclusion."
LuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Readers aged 14–18 who crave psychological tension and questions of identity and memory, and who want a YA thriller that earns its emotional weight through two fully developed perspectives rather than a tidy resolution.
Worth it if
You're drawn to dual-narrative mysteries where the central question is not just what happened but who can be trusted — and you can ride with genre conventions around police procedure in exchange for genuine suspense and a bittersweet payoff.
Skip if
Readers who scrutinize procedural realism closely, or who tend to piece together dual-narrative connections early and find predictability a dealbreaker, may hit friction points that pull them out of an otherwise tightly wound story.
What readers & critics say
Kirkus Reviews called it "a gripping tribute to resilience" and "a thrilling delight right up to the unexpected and bittersweet conclusion," noting that the two immersive storylines bring both main characters' trials to life with equal emotional grounding. Reader review sites including teatimelit.com and megsbookrack.com placed it among the strongest YA thrillers in recent memory, with teatimelit.com describing it as "one of the best — if not the best — YA thrillers I have ever read."
“A gripping tribute to resilience… the two immersive storylines bring to life the trials and frustrations each main character faces.”
— Kirkus Reviews4.3from 81,855 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
In This Review
- What Works & What Doesn't
- What the Book Is and What It Sets in Motion
- Significance and Place in the YA Thriller Landscape
- Structural Strengths: The Dual-Narrative Design
- Genuine Limitations: Predictability and Plot Mechanics
- Who This Book Is For
What Works & What Doesn't
What Works
- Kirkus Reviews called it 'a gripping tribute to resilience' and 'a thrilling delight right up to the unexpected and bittersweet conclusion'
- Two fully realized, alternating storylines give both Mary's and Drew's perspectives equal emotional weight
- Strong pre-publication endorsements from established YA thriller authors, including April Henry and Jessie Weaver
- Went on to make Lally a New York Times and USA Today bestselling debut author
- The bittersweet, unexpected conclusion resists formula and delivers genuine emotional resonance
What Doesn't
- Some readers have noted the plot can feel predictable, particularly for those who piece together the dual-narrative connection early
- Reader feedback flags concerns about unrealistic police behavior and plot holes that may disrupt suspension of disbelief for procedurally minded readers
Lally's debut is a confidently constructed dual-narrative thriller that earns its pulse-pounding subtitle with two genuinely distinct mysteries converging toward a bittersweet payoff.
What the Book Is and What It Sets in Motion
Promotional graphic with white and red text on dark background warning of deception and false security.
That's Not My Name opens with a disorienting premise: a 17-year-old girl wakes up in a ditch in Alton, Oregon, with no memory of who she is or how she got there. When a man named Wayne Boone arrives at the police station with photos on his phone and a high school ID card bearing the name "Mary Boone," the authorities release her into his custody. The novel's central dread is methodical: as Mary's memories begin fragmenting back, they refuse to match Wayne's version of her life — he does not know about her food allergy, and his stories don't hold up under scrutiny. Across the Willamette River in Washington City, a boy named Drew is living a different kind of nightmare. His girlfriend, Lola, has vanished, and Drew was the last person to see her. With the sheriff treating him as a suspect, Drew turns to an unlikely partner in the search: Autumn, Lola's best friend and, notably, the sheriff's own daughter. The two storylines drive toward a single collision, with the question of Lola's whereabouts threading them together.
“a designation that speaks to the book's ambitions beyond pure genre mechanics. Author Jessie Weaver praised Lally's technique directly, writing that”
Significance and Place in the YA Thriller Landscape
This is Lally's debut novel, and it announced her arrival with notable force. The book went on to make Lally a New York Times and USA Today bestselling author. Kirkus Reviews, in a review published ahead of the December release, described the novel as "a gripping tribute to resilience," a designation that speaks to the book's ambitions beyond pure genre mechanics. Author Jessie Weaver praised Lally's technique directly, writing that "with her masterful use of carefully-placed details to build suspense, Lally asks: just because something is obvious, does that make it true?" — a question that captures the novel's core preoccupation with perception, evidence, and who gets believed. April Henry, a New York Times bestselling author, called it "tense, heart-wrenching, and addictive," adding that it is "an exciting first entry for an author we should all be watching." For a debut to collect this caliber of pre-publication endorsement signals real momentum in the competitive YA thriller space.
Front cover featuring the title in red and yellow text with a car's headlights, against a dark textured background.
Structural Strengths: The Dual-Narrative Design
The novel's most discussed structural choice is its commitment to two fully realized, alternating storylines. Rather than using a secondary perspective as a framing device, Lally builds Drew's thread — his isolation, the community's suspicion, his fragile alliance with Autumn — with the same investment she brings to Mary's claustrophobic situation with Wayne. Kirkus noted that "the two immersive storylines bring to life the trials and frustrations each main character faces," suggesting the dual structure succeeds in keeping both threads emotionally grounded rather than treating one as scaffolding for the other. The novel also incorporates some representation in its cast: one of Drew's adoptive dads is Guatemalan, a detail Kirkus flags in its character notes.
Genuine Limitations: Predictability and Plot Mechanics
No thriller debut is without rough edges, and some readers have noted that the plot's trajectory can feel predictable in places — a risk inherent to dual-narrative mysteries where attentive readers may piece together the connection between the two storylines before the characters do. Reader feedback has also cited concerns about unrealistic police behavior and occasional plot holes as friction points. These criticisms are worth naming plainly: the book's central tension depends on law enforcement making decisions that strain credibility, and readers who scrutinize procedural plausibility may find those moments pull them out of an otherwise tightly wound narrative. For readers who prioritize airtight plotting over emotional propulsion, these mechanics may register as flaws rather than genre conventions.
Who This Book Is For
That's Not My Name is aimed at readers aged 14 to 18 and is designed to work for those who want psychological tension, questions of identity and memory, and a thriller structure that does not resolve neatly into a tidy happy ending. The bittersweet conclusion Kirkus references suggests Lally resists the easy wrap-up, which will satisfy readers who want their genre fiction to carry some emotional weight. Readers who enjoy YA thrillers built around unreliable circumstances — where the question is not just what happened but who can be trusted — will find the novel's design well-suited to that appetite. For libraries and educators working with grades 9 through 12, the book's themes of resilience, identity without memory, and the insidious nature of control exercised through apparent care give it conversational depth beyond the plot mechanics alone.
Frequently Asked Questions
is That's Not My Name: A Pulse-Pounding YA Thriller of Secrets, Lies by Megan Lally worth reading
Yes, especially if you enjoy psychological tension and mysteries built around trust rather than just whodunit plotting. Kirkus Reviews called it "a thrilling delight right up to the unexpected and bittersweet conclusion," and authors April Henry and Jessie Weaver both praised Lally's skill at building suspense through carefully placed details. The main caveat: readers who need airtight procedural realism may find some of the police behavior hard to swallow.
what is That's Not My Name: A Pulse-Pounding YA Thriller of Secrets, Lies by Megan Lally actually about
It follows two interlocking storylines: a 17-year-old girl who wakes up in a ditch in Alton, Oregon, with no memory of who she is, and must figure out whether a man named Wayne Boone — who shows up at the police station with photos and an ID card bearing the name "Mary Boone" — is really her father. At the same time, a boy named Drew in Washington City is trying to clear his name after his girlfriend Lola vanishes and the sheriff treats him as the prime suspect. The question threading both stories together is not just what happened, but who can actually be trusted.
does That's Not My Name: A Pulse-Pounding YA Thriller of Secrets, Lies by Megan Lally have a happy ending
Not exactly — Kirkus Reviews specifically describes the conclusion as "unexpected and bittersweet," which signals Lally resists tying things up neatly. The review notes this will satisfy readers who want their genre fiction to carry genuine emotional weight rather than a tidy resolution. If you need a fully happy wrap-up, this one may leave you unsettled in an intentional way.
is That's Not My Name: A Pulse-Pounding YA Thriller of Secrets, Lies by Megan Lally good for fans of dual-narrative YA thrillers
It's a strong pick for that audience — Lally commits fully to both perspectives rather than using one as a framing device for the other. Kirkus noted that "the two immersive storylines bring to life the trials and frustrations each main character faces," meaning Drew's isolation and fragile alliance with Autumn get the same emotional investment as Mary's claustrophobic situation with Wayne. The trade-off is that attentive readers may piece together the connection between the two storylines before the characters do.
can you figure out the twist early in That's Not My Name: A Pulse-Pounding YA Thriller of Secrets, Lies by Megan Lally
Possibly — the review acknowledges that "the plot's trajectory can feel predictable in places," which is a known risk with dual-narrative mysteries where the link between storylines can become visible to sharp readers ahead of schedule. That said, author Jessie Weaver praised Lally's "masterful use of carefully-placed details to build suspense," suggesting the ride itself is engaging even if you sense where things are heading. It's more about atmosphere and emotional tension than a pure puzzle-box surprise.
what age is That's Not My Name: A Pulse-Pounding YA Thriller of Secrets, Lies by Megan Lally appropriate for
Best for ages 14 and up. The book's themes of coercive control, psychological manipulation, and identity under duress — particularly in the storyline where Mary must assess whether Wayne Boone is really her father — suit high school-level readers rather than middle schoolers. The dual-narrative complexity also calls for a reader comfortable holding two emotionally heavy storylines in tension at the same time.
is That's Not My Name: A Pulse-Pounding YA Thriller of Secrets, Lies by Megan Lally good for a high school class or library
The review specifically flags it as a strong fit for grades 9 through 12, noting that its themes of resilience, identity without memory, and "the insidious nature of control exercised through apparent care" give it conversational depth well beyond the plot mechanics. Kirkus also called it "a gripping tribute to resilience," suggesting it has enough thematic substance to support classroom discussion. The unrealistic police behavior some readers flag is worth noting as a talking point rather than a dealbreaker in an educational context.
Sources & Further Reading
The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.
- Cited in this review
- 1
- 2
howdidthatbookend.com
- 3
megsbookrack.com
- Further reading
- 4
kirkusreviews.com
- 5
teatimelit.com
- 6
Related Reviews
Reviews of books we picked for readers who enjoyed That's Not My Name.
Reader Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!