Skip to content
Reviewed

Updated

Read Time

8 min read

Reader rating
4.3 · 96,033 Amazon ratings
reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review
Front cover

Our review

That's Not My Name

That's Not My Name Review: Amnesia Thriller (Megan Lally)

Megan Lally's debut YA thriller, That's Not My Name, follows an amnesiac girl taken in by a man claiming to be her father and a boyfriend suspected of murdering his girlfriend. Bloggers rave about its pace and twists; one found the first half slow.

Promotional graphic with white and red text on dark background warning of deception and false security.Front cover featuring the title in red and yellow text with a car's headlights, against a dark textured background.Front cover featuring the title in red text over a dark forest image with glowing headlights.Tap to enlarge
Our age band: Ages 14+coercive control · a girl who may be living with danger

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Readers who want a fast, emotionally heavy YA thriller with two alternating narrators and a mystery that rewards patience, and who can accept a bittersweet rather than tidy ending.

Worth it if

Worth reading if you want a twisty, quick-to-finish thriller where the ending's payoff outweighs the slower, more predictable opening.

Skip if

Skip it if you need both narrators gripping from page one: Heidi Dischler found Drew's story slow, angsty and boring, and another reviewer was less invested in his chapters.

Where reviewers agree and split

Readers rate it 4.3 on Amazon. The reviews we read that discuss it in depth split on some points:

  • Positive

    Kirkus Reviews · Press review: A gripping, thrilling debut with immersive storylines and resilience

  • Positive

    Teatime Lit · Book blog: an expertly crafted debut thriller with compelling characters and plot twists

  • Positive

    Moms That Read · Book blog: A gripping quick-paced thriller that delivers exactly what it promises

  • Positive

    The Book Dutchesses · Book blog: A captivating emotional thriller with an excellent twist ending

  • Mixed

    Heidi Dischler · Book blog: captivating but slow-starting; strong ending redeems dragging first half

  • Positive

    Megs Book Rack · Book blog: A compelling debut that kept the reader hooked throughout from start to finish

  • Positive

    How Did That Book End · Book blog: A gripping, tense debut thriller with an emotional epilogue

Of the 2 reviews we read that discuss its pacing, 1 finds it gripping and fast, but 1 says the first half is slow.

  • Pacing

    1 finds it gripping and fast · 1 says the first half is slow

  • Ending

    2 loved the ending

Pacing

Praise

“If you’re looking for a quick-paced thriller that will keep you on your toes, this is a great option.”

— Moms That Read · Book blog
Criticism

“This book was very slow to start off.”

— Heidi Dischler · Book blog

Ending

Praise

“I loved the twist and the ending itself merits a read for this novel.”

— Heidi Dischler · Book blog
Praise

“I loved the conclusion and am just so very pleased by the overall experience.”

— Meg's Book Rack · Book blog
Overall verdicts are our summary of each review we read, from its headline, rating and conclusion. Topic counts use only words we can quote (3 reviews: 3 book blogs).

Reception leans clearly positive. Kirkus Reviews calls the debut "a thrilling delight right up to the unexpected and bittersweet conclusion," and several book bloggers rate it highly, including one at teatimelit.com who ranks it among the best YA thrillers she has read. The main reservation comes from the blogger at heididischler.com, who found the opening slow before the ending won her over.

“A gripping tribute to resilience.”

— Kirkus Reviews
Sources: Kirkus Reviews, Heidi Dischler, teatimelit.com
4.3from 96,033 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

An Autistic Reader reviews That's Not My Name

A spoiler-free overview, content and profanity breakdown, and review of Megan Lally's debut thriller 'That's Not My Name.'

A BookTube review by An Autistic Reader, 2024 · 1.8K views · 1.1K subscribers · Watch on YouTube ·

Their views, not ours. The points are our AI summary of what they say, each playing from where they say it.

Dual POV plot structure

The story alternates between Mary, a traumatized girl with amnesia, and Drew, a boy suspected of causing his girlfriend's disappearance.

An unpredictable ending twist

The book concludes with a surprise twist that the reviewer personally did not see coming at all.

Heavy profanity for YA

The novel features a significant amount of swearing for a young adult book, though the reviewer found it realistic for the stressful scenario.

Preview the book

Front cover
Promotional graphic with white and red text on dark background warning of deception and false security.
Front cover featuring the title in red and yellow text with a car's headlights, against a dark textured background.
Front cover featuring the title in red text over a dark forest image with glowing headlights.

Ask LuvemBooks

Was this helpful?

That's Not My Name is a dual-narrator YA thriller in which an amnesiac girl is claimed by a man who says he is her father while a boyfriend no one believes searches for his missing girlfriend. It is fast, twisty and emotionally heavy, best for readers who can accept a bittersweet ending. The main caveat is that reviewers split on pacing: Meg's Book Rack and The Book Dutchesses found it gripping from the start, while Heidi Dischler found it slow initially.
Is it worth reading?
Reviewers who liked it were enthusiastic: Kirkus Reviews called it a "gripping tribute to resilience," and Moms That Read called it a quick-paced thriller that keeps you on your toes. The payoff is what pulls people through, with Heidi Dischler writing that the twist and ending merit a read by themselves. The reservation is that she also found the book very slow to start, so it rewards patience more than it grabs you immediately.
Similar books
For another YA story built on a twisty secret, We Were Liars and A Good Girl's Guide to Murder are the closest fits, and The Inheritance Games adds a puzzle-driven mystery with more romance. Speak is a quieter pick that shares the emotional weight and a protagonist struggling to be believed. Meg's Book Rack separately points fans of Kit Frick, Laurie Faria Stolarz, Mindy McGinnis and Natalie D. Richards toward this book.
Who should read this?
It suits older teens and adults who read YA and want a character-driven suspense story over gore. It works best for readers who like a mystery that withholds its answers, since both Mary and Drew are working from incomplete information. Readers who prefer equal investment in both narrators may drift, because the How Did That Book End blogger was less invested in Drew's chapters than in Mary's.
What age is it for?
Best for ages 14 and up. Kirkus labels it for ages 14 to 18, and the Amazon listing gives the same reading age. Moms That Read noted it is not spicy and has some profanity, and the story deals with a girl who may be living with danger, framed around coercive control, identity and memory. Detailed content notes are not in the sources we reviewed, so parents wanting specifics should check the publisher's information.
About Megan Lally
Megan Lally is the New York Times and USA Today bestselling author of dark and twisty young adult novels, including That's Not My Name. In her own author bio she says that when she is not writing, she can be found barefoot at the ocean, drinking lavender lattes, or arguing.
Why is this book trending?
That fits what reviewers highlight: a hook that makes it easy to recommend without spoilers, and a twist worth discovering unspoiled.
What are the main themes?
A second thread is the cost of being disbelieved, since Drew is suspected by the sheriff and much of the town. Humor from Drew's cousin Max lightens the mood without undercutting the seriousness.
Are there content warnings?
The sources point to a girl in danger, plus some profanity and a serious, dark tone. Moms That Read noted it is not spicy. Detailed content notes are not available in the sources we reviewed, so readers who need specifics should check the publisher's information.
Summarize this book

Summarize this book

A 17-year-old wakes in a ditch outside Alton, Oregon, with no memory, and a man named Wayne Boone produces her school ID and birth certificate to take her home as his daughter Mary. Across the Willamette River in Washington City, Drew is suspected of harming his girlfriend Lola, who vanished after a fight, and he starts his own search with his cousin Max and Lola's best friend Autumn. The chapters alternate between the two, and the book was published by Sourcebooks Fire on December 26, 2023.

Follow up

Is this a standalone?
Does this summary spoil the twist?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

Ask LuvemBooks

What would you like to know about That's Not My Name?

Answers come from our editorial notes on this book. If we haven't covered something, we'll say so.

Readers often ask

Our Review

We review the evidence: book bloggers and reader verdicts, gathered and weighed with AI assistance and edited by LuvemBooks, rather than one reader's first-hand take.

Reviews of Megan Lally's debut are split on its pace, but the ones that loved it were enthusiastic: Kirkus Reviews called it a "gripping tribute to resilience," and one blogger at teatimelit.com ranked it among the best YA thrillers she has read. The one significant caveat comes from Heidi Dischler, who found the first half slow before the ending won her over.

What happens in That's Not My Name?

A 17-year-old girl wakes in a ditch outside Alton, Oregon, bruised and with no memory of who she is. Police take her to the station, where a frantic man named Wayne Boone arrives with her school ID, a birth certificate and family photos.
He says she is his daughter Mary and convinces the police to release her into his custody.
The second thread follows Drew in Washington City, across the Willamette River. His girlfriend Lola vanished after a fight and he was the last person to see her.
The sheriff and much of the town believe he is responsible, so he sets out to find her himself, helped by his cousin Max and, unexpectedly, Lola's best friend Autumn, the sheriff's daughter.
The novel alternates between "Mary" and Drew. It was published by Sourcebooks Fire on December 26, 2023, and Megan Lally is described on teatimelit.com as a New York Times and USA Today bestselling author.

What did critics and bloggers find in the two narrators?

Kirkus Reviews judged the two storylines "immersive" and said they bring each lead's trials and frustrations to life. The review called the book a thrilling delight that holds up to its conclusion.
On the blog Meg's Book Rack, Meg praised how Lally paces the perspective shifts, calling it a "one more chapter" kind of read where the intensity builds steadily. The blogger at teatimelit.com wrote that Lally "does a brilliant job" of weaving the two points of view together, singled out Max's jokes as welcome relief that never undercut the seriousness, and said Autumn grew on her.
Not every voice is equal across the two strands. The How Did That Book End blogger said she was less invested in Drew's chapters but appreciated the contrast with Mary's tension.
Heidi Dischler found the first half of Drew's story boring and angsty before it got to "the good stuff."

Does the ending of That's Not My Name pay off?

Heidi Dischler gave it 4 out of 5 and said she did not see the twist coming. The reveal, she wrote, merits a read of the novel by itself.
The Book Dutchesses blogger said just when she thought she had it figured out, the author took a different turn. She also warned that it is not a wrapped-up happily-ever-after in every sense.
Kirkus described the conclusion as unexpected and bittersweet. According to the How Did That Book End blog, the epilogue packed an unexpected emotional touch that really brought the read home.
Meg's Book Rack said she loved the conclusion.

How fast and how emotional is it?

Moms That Read said she read it front to back in under a day and called it a quick-paced thriller. The blogger behind The Book Dutchesses said it had her hooked from the start, and Meg's Book Rack said she "knocked this out of the park" for a debut.
The teatimelit.com reviewer went further, calling it "one of the best — if not the best — YA thrillers I have ever read," and said it made her cry.
The tone is heavy. The teatimelit.com blogger described the book as very heavy, with humor as relief rather than a change of register, and some reviewers called it an emotional read.

Is That's Not My Name suitable for teens?

Kirkus labels it for ages 14 to 18, and the Amazon listing gives a reading age of 14 to 18; LuvemBooks suggests 14 and up as a starting point. The Moms That Read blogger noted it is not spicy and has some profanity, and that the dialogue is full of teenage slang and angst; she described it as written for older young adults.
The book centers on a girl who may be living with danger rather than escaping it, which sources frame in terms of coercive control, identity and memory. Detailed content notes are not available in the sources here, so parents wanting specifics should check the publisher's information.

Is That's Not My Name worth reading?

Weighing these reviews, the book's pull is its hook: an amnesiac girl handed to a man who says he is her father, set against a boyfriend no one believes. Two sources describe it as readable in a day, and Meg's Book Rack and teatimelit.com both put it near the top of the YA thrillers they have read.
The tension the reviews circle is between momentum and patience. Readers who want a tense, fast, emotional YA thriller are the natural audience, while Heidi Dischler's slow first half and some critics' lower investment in Drew suggest that readers who need both narrators equally gripping may drift in the middle.
Meg's Book Rack points fans of Kit Frick, Laurie Faria Stolarz, Mindy McGinnis and Natalie D. Richards toward it, which places it among character-driven YA suspense rather than gore-forward horror.

Sources & Further Reading

The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

  1. Cited in this review
  2. 1
  3. Further reading
  4. 2
  5. 3
  6. 4
  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8
  11. 9

Age & Reading Level

Our age band

Ages 14+

Reading level

Young adult

Amazon listing

Ages 14–18 · Grade 9–12

Our age band groups books for browsing; it isn't an age a review gave.

Content to know about

coercive control
a girl who may be living with danger
emotionally heavy tone
some profanity

Best for: Ages 14+ — heavy emotional themes around coercive control and a missing-person mystery

Skip if you want a tidy, happily-ever-after ending or need both narrators gripping from the first chapter

Megan Lally on That's Not My Name

Author Megan Lally discusses the premise, inspiration, and dual-perspective plotting of her YA thriller That's Not My Name.

Uploaded by Unofficial Book Club: Where Life & Stories Meet , 2025 · Watch on YouTube ·

More from this interview on Megan Lally's page →

Inspiration for That's Not My Name

Lally conceived the story while doing housework when the image of a girl waking in a ditch came to mind. She explored how terrifying trauma would be if amnesia prevented you from identifying who to trust.

Why Drew's POV was created

Lally realized that relying solely on Mary's memory-loss perspective would stall the narrative. She introduced the boyfriend's point of view to ground the investigation and provide dramatic counterpoint.

From our readers

Reader reviews

No LuvemBooks readers have answered yet.

Read it? Was it right for you?

Discussion

Reader comments