Skip to content
Reviewed

Read Time

8 min read

Our age bandAdult
Reader rating
4.4 · 118,390 Amazon ratings, as of Nov 2026
reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review
Front cover

Our review

Hidden Pictures

Hidden Pictures by Jason Rekulak Review: A Mixed-Media Supernatural Thriller

Hidden Pictures delivers a highly inventive supernatural thriller with an innovative mixed-media format. Readers prioritizing strict realism may find its escalating absurdity frustrating.

Our age band: Adultsupernatural horror · psychological trauma

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

This book appeals to readers who enjoy psychological thrillers that blend supernatural suspense with an unreliable narrator and visually integrated illustrations.

Worth it if

Worth reading if you are open to a genre-bending horror-thriller that prioritizes atmospheric terror and surreal twists over strict logical consistency.

Skip if

Skip it if you prefer tightly grounded mysteries and find escalating absurdity or contrived plot mechanics frustrating.

Where reviewers agree and split

Readers rate it 4.4 on Amazon. The reviews we read that discuss it in depth split on some points:

  • Positive

    Kirkus Reviews · Press review: praises character development and engaging supernatural narrative

  • Positive

    Lair of Reviews · Book blog: highly recommends the thriller and its unique mixed media illustrations

  • Mixed

    brettmilam.com · Book blog: praises illustrations and setup but critiques the unresolved genre explanation

  • Mixed

    What Is Quinn Reading? · Book blog: praises plot and twists while noting some silly author choices

  • Positive

    A Well-Read Tart · Book blog: highly recommends the riveting and unique haunted house story

Only Kirkus Reviews and The Crime Vault discuss its characters: both praise character development.

  • Characters

    2 praise character development

Characters

Praise

“Rekulak does a great job with character development”

— Kirkus Reviews · Press review
Praise

“Rekulak does a great job with character development”

— The Crime Vault · Book blog
Overall verdicts are our summary of each review we read, from its headline, rating and conclusion. Topic counts use only words we can quote (2 reviews: 1 press review, 1 book blog).

Critics highlight the book’s character work, while reviewers note the engaging story, though What Is Quinn Reading? flags some contrived decisions. Publishers Weekly observes the brisk pace but questions whether the narrative commits fully to its genre blend.

“Rekulak does a great job with character development”

— Kirkus Reviews
Sources: Kirkus Reviews, Lair of Reviews, The Crime Vault, What Is Quinn Reading?, A Well-Read Tart, Publishers Weekly
4.4from 118,390 Amazon ratings, as of Nov 2026— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

Ask LuvemBooks

Was this helpful?

Hidden Pictures follows Mallory, a recovering addict turned nanny, as she uncovers sinister supernatural forces through the drawings of a five-year-old boy in an affluent New Jersey suburb. LuvemBooks finds the novel a highly inventive genre-bender that successfully blends psychological thriller mechanics with escalating horror. Readers open to surreal twists and visually integrated storytelling will find it compelling, while those demanding strict realism may find the narrative structure frustrating.
Is it worth reading?
Yes, if you enjoy psychological thrillers that blend supernatural suspense with a complex protagonist and integrated illustrations. The novel successfully shifts into an increasingly eerie horror show, though readers seeking strictly grounded narratives may find its growing strangeness frustrating.
Similar books
Fans of twisty supernatural mysteries will appreciate this title alongside Home Before Dark and The Whisper Man for their shared focus on haunted environments and psychological dread. It also pairs well with The Silent Patient for readers who enjoy narratives that deliberately compromise narrator reliability to maintain suspense.
Who should read this?
Ideal for readers who enjoy suspenseful stories with integrated illustrations. It is particularly suited for those who appreciate stories exploring the intersection of trauma, memory, and the unknown, provided they are open to boundary-pushing experiments.
What age is it for?
Written for adults, the novel contains mature themes including psychological trauma, eerie dread, and references to addiction that require a developed understanding of complex storytelling. It is best suited for readers who can handle unsettling imagery and sudden changes in mood.
About Jason Rekulak
Jason Rekulak is the author of "Hidden Pictures," a psychological thriller that explores the unsettling boundary between imagination and reality through the story of a nanny who becomes entangled with a mysterious presence in a family's home.
What's this book about?
Mallory moves to New Jersey and discovers sinister phenomena linked to the drawings of Teddy. The narrative deliberately blurs the line between Mallory’s hidden history and present reality, forcing readers to question what is real alongside her.
Who is it for?
It is best for readers who enjoy suspenseful stories with integrated illustrations. It also suits those interested in stories exploring psychological depth and the unknown.
What are the main themes?
The novel explores psychological depth and the unknown, alongside the unsettling boundary between imagination and reality. It also examines how personal recovery can intertwine with external supernatural threats.
Who wrote it?
Jason Rekulak is the author of "Hidden Pictures," a suspenseful novel that explores the unsettling boundary between imagination and reality through the story of a nanny who becomes entangled with a mysterious presence in a family's home.
What format or source is it?
The book is a standalone novel that utilizes an innovative combined format, integrating illustrations by Will Staehle and Doogie Horner to document the protagonist's discoveries.
Summarize this book

Summarize this book

Mallory, a recovering addict, takes a nanny job in New Jersey and discovers sinister phenomena linked to the drawings of Teddy. The narrative deliberately blurs the line between Mallory’s past trauma and present reality, forcing readers to question what is real alongside her.

Follow up

How does the artwork change?
Is the narrator unreliable?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

Ask LuvemBooks

What would you like to know about Hidden Pictures?

Answers come from our editorial notes on this book. If we haven't covered something, we'll say so.

Readers often ask

Our Review

We review the evidence: published critics, book bloggers and reader verdicts, gathered and weighed with AI assistance and edited by LuvemBooks, rather than one reader's first-hand take.

Hidden Pictures delivers a highly inventive supernatural thriller with an innovative mixed-media format. Readers prioritizing strict realism may find its escalating absurdity frustrating.
Hidden Pictures_main_0

What Hidden Pictures Covers

Published in 2023, Jason Rekulak’s novel follows Mallory, a recovering drug addict who takes a nanny position for five-year-old Teddy in an affluent New Jersey suburb. The quiet job quickly turns unsettling when Teddy begins drawing pictures of an imaginary friend named Anya.
His sketches reveal that Anya is dead, and the drawings grow increasingly sinister as the story progresses. Mallory suspects supernatural forces are at work behind the Maxwell family’s property.
She investigates a long-ago murder on the grounds with the help of a landscaper and an eccentric neighbor.
Her reliability as a narrator is deliberately compromised by gaps in her memory caused by her past addiction. The narrative forces readers to question reality alongside Mallory as the lines between her trauma and the haunting blur.
The publisher pitches the novel to fans of Stranger Things and Riley Sager. The story operates as a standalone supernatural thriller that blends mystery with horror elements.
Teddy’s artwork serves as the primary clue for Mallory’s investigation.
The text explicitly details how Teddy’s drawings evolve from simple stick figures to complex, lifelike sketches. Mallory must decipher these images to save the child from a lingering supernatural threat.
Mallory’s journey forces her to confront a tragedy from her own past.
The story intertwines her personal recovery with the supernatural events unfolding around her. Teddy’s drawings become a crucial window into the victim’s final moments.

Critical Reception and the Mixed-Media Format

The novel’s most distinct feature is its integration of black-and-white illustrations by Will Staehle and Doogie Horner. These images are interspersed throughout the text to visually document Teddy’s disturbing artwork.
Regarding reception, Kirkus Reviews offered a positive verdict, praising the engaging supernatural narrative and noting that "Rekulak does a great job with character development." Lair of Reviews also delivered a positive assessment, highly recommending the thriller for its unique mixed media illustrations and calling it "definitely one of the best thrillers I’ve read."
A Well-Read Tart shared this positive stance, highly recommending the riveting and unique haunted house story with the declaration, "I seriously loved this book." Similarly, What Is Quinn Reading? gave a mixed verdict, praising the plot and twists while noting some silly author choices, yet determining that "the pros far, far outweighed the cons here."}
The book blogger behind Lair of Reviews noted, "These illustrations really elevate the novel." The reviewer emphasized that showing the drawings allows the audience to feel Mallory’s fear directly.
WellReadTart praised the illustrations for making the reading experience visceral. The blogger highlighted how the shifting art styles mirror the escalating terror.
The artwork transitions from childlike scribbles to realistic images created when Anya takes control.
WhatIsQuinnReading appreciated how the art shifts the tone from a traditional thriller into an increasingly eerie supernatural horror show. The book has established itself as a New York Times bestseller.
Praise from figures like Stephen King highlights its status as a wildly inventive spin on the classic ghost story.
The novel’s commercial success underscores its appeal to modern thriller readers. Critics and general audiences alike have responded strongly to its visual innovation.
The format distinguishes it from conventional prose-heavy horror novels.

Genuine Limitations and Points of Contention

Despite the strong reception of its format, the novel faces criticism regarding its plot mechanics. WhatIsQuinnReading noted that certain decisions Mallory makes to keep the action moving are flat-out silly.
The reviewer observed that Rekulak swerves the story into absurdity to muddy the waters and raise stakes. Some readers initially worried that addiction would be used as a convenient plot device.
The text ultimately integrates Mallory’s recovery as a crucial element of her psychological journey rather than a mere trope. The narrative demands suspension of disbelief as the mystery deepens.
Readers expecting a strictly grounded mystery may find the supernatural elements overwhelming. The plot relies heavily on the unreliable narrator trope to maintain suspense.
The narrative occasionally prioritizes shock value over logical consistency.
This approach may alienate readers who prefer methodical, grounded mystery solving. The plot’s reliance on sudden tonal shifts requires an open mind.

Is Hidden Pictures Worth Reading?

Weighing these reviews reveals a clear divide between readers who embrace genre-bending experiments and those who demand traditional thriller logic. The book’s pacing and innovative visuals create a unique reading experience, though.
Fans of twisty supernatural mysteries will find the escalating mystery and unpredictable ending highly engaging. Readers who prefer tightly grounded narratives may find the story’s descent into the absurd frustrating.
While some praise its blend of haunted house and psychological thriller, others argue the plot never quite commits to one genre or the other. Its mixed-media approach ensures that the horror remains visually tangible.
The story rewards rereading due to the subtle clues hidden within Teddy’s evolving sketches. It remains a distinctive addition to the modern horror-thriller catalog.
The book maintains a tight focus on Mallory’s psychological state throughout its duration.
Her struggle to distinguish past trauma from present danger drives the central tension. The resolution ties together the supernatural elements with the protagonist’s emotional arc.

Who Should Read This Novel?

Hidden Pictures appeals to audiences interested in mixed-media storytelling and supernatural thrillers that play with narrative reliability. It is particularly suited for readers who enjoy stories exploring the intersection of trauma, memory, and the unknown.
The novel functions as a standalone experience, requiring no prior knowledge of Rekulak’s previous works. It serves as a compelling entry point for those seeking a fresh take on the haunted house genre.
Readers who appreciate visual storytelling alongside traditional prose will find the format highly immersive. The book is best consumed with minimal prior knowledge to preserve its twists.
Fans of authors like Riley Sager will likely appreciate the genre-blending structure. The novel also appeals to readers interested in the mechanics of unreliable narration.
It offers a fresh perspective on the classic nanny-and-child horror trope.

Sources & Further Reading

The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

  1. Cited in this review
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. Further reading
  5. 3
  6. 4
  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8

    kirkusreviews.com

  11. 9

    thecrimevault.com

  12. 10

    publishersweekly.com

Age & Reading Level

Our age band

Adult

Our age band groups books for browsing; it isn't an age a review gave.

Content to know about

supernatural horror
psychological trauma
references to addiction

Best for: Adults — themes of psychological trauma and supernatural horror require a mature understanding of complex narrative reliability.

Skip if you prefer tightly grounded mysteries and find escalating absurdity or contrived plot mechanics frustrating

From our readers

Reader reviews

No LuvemBooks readers have answered yet.

Read it? Was it right for you?

Books like Hidden Pictures

Curated picks for readers who enjoyed Hidden Pictures, with our reasoning for each match.

If you liked Hidden Pictures

Discussion

Reader comments