BOOKS
Published

Read Time

4 min read

Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review

A Game of Thrones: 20th Anniversary Illustrated Edition by George R.R. Martin Review: A Landmark Fantasy Reimagined in Celebration

George R.R. Martin's A Game of Thrones — the 1996 epic fantasy novel that launched the A Song of Ice and Fire series and ultimately sold more than 100 million copies across the full series — returns in this 2016 HarperCollins hardcover edition featuring full-page illustrations by artist John Picacio in every chapter, issued in commemoration of the novel's twentieth anniversary.

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Dedicated fans of A Song of Ice and Fire — or viewers of the HBO series seeking a definitive physical edition — who want a commemorative collector's hardcover combining the complete, unabridged text with John Picacio's full-page chapter illustrations.

Worth it if

You value the novel's landmark place in modern fantasy history and want a shelf-worthy anniversary edition, particularly if a signed copy bearing both Martin's and Picacio's signatures appeals as a collector's item.

Skip if

You're looking for a lightweight read, a full-colour illustrated treatment, or simply a first affordable paperback introduction to the series — this 880-page hardcover is designed as a collector's and gift edition, not a casual entry point.

What readers & critics say

Kirkus Reviews, in its original 1996 appraisal, described Martin as returning after a long silence with the first of a fantasy series set in the Seven Kingdoms, following honourable Ned Stark into the treacherous politics of Robert Baratheon's court. Wikipedia notes that A Song of Ice and Fire depicts a violent world dominated by political realism, with moral ambiguity pervading the books and storylines repeatedly raising questions about loyalty, pride, human sexuality, piety, and the morality of violence.

The author of the cult novel The Armageddon Rag returns with the first of a fantasy series — honorable Ned Stark reluctantly heads south, mistrusting the treacherous Lannisters.

Kirkus Reviews
Sources: Kirkus Reviews, Wikipedia – A Song of Ice and Fire
4.7from 945 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
In This Review
  • What Works & What Doesn't
  • What the Novel Is and What It Contains
  • Significance and Place in the Genre
  • What This Edition Adds
  • Themes and Structural Depth
  • Who This Edition Is For

What Works & What Doesn't

What Works
  • Commemorates the full, unabridged text of a novel that won the 1997 Locus Award for Best Fantasy Novel and is part of a series that has sold more than 100 million copies in 47 languages
  • John Picacio contributes a full-page illustration to every chapter, adding a significant visual dimension to the original text
  • Issued by HarperCollins specifically as a twentieth-anniversary collector's edition, making it a meaningful gift or shelf piece for dedicated fans
  • Signed copies bearing both Martin's and Picacio's signatures are available, enhancing its value as a collector's item
What Doesn't
  • The illustrations are rendered in black and white rather than colour, which some readers have noted as a disappointment for a collector's edition of this scale
  • At 880 pages in hardcover, the format is substantial and not designed for lightweight or casual reading convenience
The 20th Anniversary Illustrated Edition is a collector-focused hardcover reissue of the novel that launched one of modern fantasy's most significant series — not a new novel, abridgment, or companion volume, but the complete original text of A Game of Thrones accompanied by full-page illustrations by artist John Picacio, one per chapter throughout its 880 pages.

What the Novel Is and What It Contains

Back cover featuring decorative border, gold emblem, opening passage, and barcode label.
Back cover featuring decorative border, gold emblem, opening passage, and barcode label.
First published in August 1996, A Game of Thrones is the opening volume of George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire series. The narrative is set on the fictional continents of Westeros and Essos and is structured around three interwoven threads: a dynastic conflict among noble houses — most centrally House Stark and House Lannister — for control of Westeros; the efforts of the exiled House Targaryen, the deposed royal dynasty, to reclaim the Iron Throne from across the sea; and an encroaching supernatural threat from the northernmost reaches of the continent, where an ancient force known as the Others stirs beyond a massive wall of ice. The story is told in third person through alternating chapters, each tied to one of eight point-of-view characters, a structure that renders every narrator's account potentially limited or unreliable and ensures that no character's survival is guaranteed.

Significance and Place in the Genre

According to Wikipedia, A Game of Thrones won the 1997 Locus Award for Best Fantasy Novel, and a novella drawn from its Targaryen chapters won the 1997 Hugo Award for Best Novella. Critics and scholars have widely characterised the novel as subverting established fantasy tropes and compared it with the work of J.R.R. Tolkien, while also describing it as historical or medieval fantasy — one with clear echoes of real history, including Hadrian's Wall as an inspiration for the novel's great ice barrier. Wikipedia notes that the series as a whole has received critical acclaim for its world-building, characters, and narrative, and that as of 2026 more than 100 million copies across the series have been sold in 47 languages. The 2011–2019 HBO television adaptation dramatically amplified readership of the novels, transforming the first book from a word-of-mouth success — its original printing sold only a few thousand copies — into a sustained bestseller.
Interior spread featuring text on left page and winter landscape illustration with figures on right page.
Interior spread featuring text on left page and winter landscape illustration with figures on right page.

What This Edition Adds

The edition was published by HarperCollins to mark the twentieth anniversary of Martin's landmark series. Its defining addition is the work of illustrator John Picacio, who contributes full-page illustrations in every chapter. The publisher describes the edition as "lavishly illustrated" and positions it as a revitalization of the fantasy novel for both longtime readers and new ones. Some reader responses noted that the illustrations are rendered in black and white rather than colour — a detail worth knowing for those hoping for a fully painted, full-colour treatment. The edition is also available in signed copies bearing both Martin's and Picacio's signatures on the title page, making it a notable collector's item for dedicated fans of the series.

Themes and Structural Depth

Wikipedia identifies moral ambiguity as pervasive throughout the A Song of Ice and Fire novels, with the storylines repeatedly raising questions about loyalty, pride, human sexuality, piety, and the morality of violence. What little supernatural power exists in the world is confined to the margins; the dominant register is political realism. Scholars have explored the novel's engagement with medieval literary conventions, including chivalry, as well as its treatment of gender, motherhood, and sexual violence — a body of academic attention that reflects the novel's literary standing beyond its commercial success. For readers coming to the text for the first time, that thematic density — woven through a cast that expands considerably across the series — is central to understanding why this novel occupies the position it does in contemporary fantasy.

Who This Edition Is For

The 20th Anniversary Illustrated Edition is designed primarily as a collector's and gift edition rather than a first point of entry for the entirely uninitiated. Readers who enjoyed the HBO television series and want a definitive physical edition of the source material, as well as long-standing fans of the novels seeking a commemorative volume, represent its most natural audience. Those purchasing purely for reading convenience should be aware this is a substantial hardcover at 880 pages. Readers who prefer fully coloured illustration work may wish to note that the Picacio illustrations are in black and white. For anyone who values the novel's place in the history of modern fantasy — and the record supports calling that place significant — this edition offers both the complete text and a layer of visual interpretation that marks the occasion of its twentieth year in print.

Sources & Further Reading

The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

  1. Cited in this review
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. Further reading
  5. 3

    George R.R. Martin, Wikipedia

  6. 4
  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8