BOOKS
Published
Read Time
8 min read
Reader ratingreader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
4.8
· 36,134 Amazon ratingsShare This Review
Magnolia Table by Joanna Gaines & Marah Stets Review: A #1 Bestselling Comfort Food Cookbook
Magnolia Table is a #1 New York Times bestselling cookbook by Joanna Gaines and Marah Stets, published by William Morrow Cookbooks in April 2018, collecting 125 recipes drawn from Gaines family favorites, American comfort food classics, and dishes inspired by the Gaineses' Waco restaurant — framed throughout with personal stories and photographs.
Tap to enlargeLuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Fans of Joanna Gaines and Fixer Upper who want an accessible, story-driven American comfort-food cookbook that doubles as a warm lifestyle read covering every meal of the day.
Worth it if
Worth it if you're looking for a broad, family-style everyday cooking reference — 125 recipes from breakfast to dessert — wrapped in personal narrative and the domestic warmth Gaines built her following on.
Skip if
Skip it if you're primarily seeking challenging culinary technique, international flavor profiles, or a recipe-dense reference free of lifestyle branding and personal memoir content.
What readers & critics say
Barnes & Noble's editorial materials highlight the book's #1 New York Times bestseller status and note that the Huffington Post specifically singled out Gaines's White Cheddar Biscuit — a recipe she spent a year developing — as a standout. Goodley Living's review characterises the recipes as "approachable and unfussy," praising the book's comforting flavours, family stories, and Southern hospitality.
Sources: Barnes & Noble, Goodley Living4.8from 36,134 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
In This Review
- What Works & What Doesn't
- What the Book Actually Is
- The Garden-to-Table Angle
- Cultural Moment and Commercial Reach
- Genuine Strengths
- Limitations and Who It May Frustrate
What Works & What Doesn't
What Works
- #1 New York Times bestseller with broad, documented popular appeal across a large readership
- Covers all meal categories — breakfast, lunch, dinner, small plates, snacks, and desserts — in a single 125-recipe volume
- Rooted in both family tradition and the Gaineses' Waco restaurant, giving the recipes a dual tested-in-real-life framing per the publisher
- Personal stories and photographs are woven throughout, making the book function as both cookbook and memoir-adjacent lifestyle read
- Launched a three-volume series, indicating sustained audience investment beyond a single publication
What Doesn't
- Focused narrowly on American comfort food classics; readers seeking international cuisines or advanced technique will find the scope limited
- Personal narrative and photography share significant space with recipes, which may disappoint readers prioritizing density of culinary instruction over lifestyle content
- As some reader reviews on retail platforms reflect, the book's strong branding connection to the Fixer Upper television audience can make it feel more like a companion product than a standalone culinary reference
A #1 New York Times bestseller, Magnolia Table is a comfort-food cookbook that doubles as a family memoir in recipe form — and it achieved both with enough popular force to launch a three-book series.
What the Book Actually Is
Interior page showing "What's inside?" description with hands preparing ingredients, introducing the cookbook's 125 classic American recipes.
Magnolia Table is a full-range cookbook spanning breakfast, lunch, dinner, small plates, snacks, and desserts — 125 recipes in total, according to the publisher. The recipes draw from two overlapping sources: longtime Gaines family favorites and classic comfort food selections developed for the couple's Waco, Texas restaurant of the same name, which opened in early 2018. Co-written with Marah Stets and published by William Morrow Cookbooks, the book is framed as an invitation into Joanna Gaines's home kitchen, woven through with personal stories and photographs. Representative dishes named in the publisher's description include Chicken Pot Pie, Fried Chicken with Sticky Poppy Seed Jam, Asparagus and Fontina Quiche, Brussels Sprouts with Crispy Bacon, Toasted Pecans, and Balsamic Reduction, Overnight French Toast, Peach Caprese, White Cheddar Biscuits, Lemon Pie, and Mac and Cheese — a roster that maps clearly onto American comfort cooking with occasional fresh, seasonal turns.
“invitation to share a seat at the table”
The Garden-to-Table Angle
One distinguishing thread running through the collection is Gaines's stated commitment to homegrown and seasonal produce used at the peak of its flavor. The publisher's description positions this not as a strict farm-to-table manifesto but as a natural outgrowth of her garden — an ingredient philosophy woven into recipes rather than a separate chapter or agenda. Dishes like Peach Caprese and the vegetable-forward Brussels Sprouts preparation reflect that sensibility concretely, offering what the publisher describes as a modern take on American classics inflected by whatever is freshest.
Chapter 8 dinner spread featuring pasta, fresh vegetables, and cooking ingredients arranged on a cream background.
Cultural Moment and Commercial Reach
The book arrived at a culturally specific juncture: Joanna and Chip Gaines had just announced the conclusion of their long-running HGTV series Fixer Upper, and as noted in a Barnes & Noble editorial excerpt, the cookbook's announcement coincided directly with that news — making it, for a large existing audience, a natural continuation of a relationship already built through television. That context helps explain the book's commercial trajectory. It debuted as a #1 New York Times bestseller and became the first entry in what is now a three-volume Magnolia Table series. The Huffington Post, quoted in the Barnes & Noble editorial materials, specifically singled out a White Cheddar Biscuit recipe that Gaines spent a year developing, calling it a standout.
Genuine Strengths
The book's design intent is to make family-style American cooking accessible and personally resonant. With 125 recipes spread across every meal category, it functions as a broad-coverage everyday cookbook rather than a niche or technique-driven one. The personal stories interspersed throughout are a deliberate structural choice — the publisher frames the entire collection as an "invitation to share a seat at the table" — which positions it as much as a lifestyle and memoir-adjacent reading experience as a purely instructional cooking reference. For readers who came to Gaines through Fixer Upper and responded to her domestic warmth on screen, the book is designed to translate that same register onto the page.
Limitations and Who It May Frustrate
The cookbook's strengths are also the source of its limitations for certain readers. Its deliberate emphasis on American comfort food classics — pot pie, mac and cheese, fried chicken, biscuits — means the range of global cuisines or ambitious technical cooking is narrow by design. Readers seeking challenging technique, international flavor profiles, or dietary-specific frameworks (vegan, gluten-free, and the like) will find the book's scope a poor match for those needs. Some readers, as reflected in aggregate ratings across retail platforms, have noted the book reads more as a branded lifestyle product than a cook's reference — a fair observation given that personal narrative and photography share substantial space with the recipes themselves. Whether that balance is an asset or a drawback is genuinely a matter of what a reader comes to a cookbook looking for.
Frequently Asked Questions
is Magnolia Table by Joanna Gaines, Marah Stets worth buying
It depends heavily on what you want from a cookbook. If you're a fan of Joanna Gaines from Fixer Upper and love American comfort food classics like Chicken Pot Pie, Mac and Cheese, and White Cheddar Biscuits, the book delivers both accessible recipes and a warm, memoir-adjacent reading experience full of personal stories and photographs. However, if you're after challenging techniques, international flavors, or dietary-specific frameworks like vegan or gluten-free cooking, the review is upfront that the book's scope is a poor match for those needs.
What is this book actually about
It's a 125-recipe comfort food cookbook that also functions as a kind of family memoir in recipe form — the publisher frames it as an invitation into Joanna Gaines's home kitchen, woven through with personal stories and photographs. The recipes draw from longtime Gaines family favorites and dishes developed for the Gaineses' Waco, Texas restaurant of the same name, covering everything from breakfast to desserts, with representative dishes like Fried Chicken with Sticky Poppy Seed Jam, Overnight French Toast, and Lemon Pie. A running thread throughout is Gaines's emphasis on homegrown and seasonal produce used at the peak of its flavor.
Is this book good if you don't watch Fixer Upper
The review notes the book arrived at a culturally specific moment — Joanna and Chip Gaines had just announced the end of their HGTV series Fixer Upper, and for that existing audience it was a natural continuation of an already-built relationship. That said, the book stands as a broad-coverage everyday cookbook with 125 recipes spanning every meal category, so readers unfamiliar with Fixer Upper can still find value in the comfort food recipes themselves — though the heavy emphasis on personal narrative and lifestyle photography may feel less meaningful without that prior connection.
Does this book have good recipes or is it just a coffee table book
It's genuinely both, which is either a strength or a drawback depending on your expectations. The review acknowledges that personal narrative and photography share substantial space with the recipes, and some readers have noted it reads more as a branded lifestyle product than a cook's reference. That said, the Huffington Post specifically singled out the White Cheddar Biscuit recipe — which Gaines spent a year developing — as a standout, suggesting there are real, carefully crafted recipes in the mix.
Is this book good for beginner cooks
Yes, it's well-suited for everyday home cooks rather than those chasing advanced technique. The review describes it as a broad-coverage everyday cookbook rather than a niche or technique-driven one, with the design intent squarely on making family-style American cooking accessible and personally resonant. Dishes like Asparagus and Fontina Quiche, Brussels Sprouts with Crispy Bacon and Balsamic Reduction, and Peach Caprese reflect a modern but approachable style that beginner cooks should find manageable.
What should i read after this book
The most direct next step is the rest of the Magnolia Table series — the review notes that this book's commercial success made it the first entry in what is now a three-volume series, so volumes two and three are the natural continuation. If you're drawn to the seasonal and homegrown ingredient philosophy woven through the book, you might also explore other American comfort food cookbooks that share that farm-fresh sensibility.
Is this book too focused on meat and comfort food for healthy eaters
Honestly, yes — the review is clear that the book's deliberate emphasis on American comfort food classics like pot pie, mac and cheese, fried chicken, and biscuits means it's narrow by design when it comes to dietary-specific frameworks. Readers looking for vegan, gluten-free, or health-focused recipes are specifically called out in the review as a poor fit for the book's scope. There are some vegetable-forward dishes like Peach Caprese and Brussels Sprouts with Crispy Bacon, Toasted Pecans, and Balsamic Reduction, but these are accents rather than the book's main focus.
Sources & Further Reading
The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.
- Cited in this review
- 1
goodleyliving.com
- 2
harpercollins.ca
- Further reading
- 3
Joanna Gaines, Marah Stets, Wikipedia
- 4
- 5
whitepinebooks.com
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
waterstones.com
Related Reviews
Reviews of books we picked for readers who enjoyed Magnolia Table.
Reader Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!