Skip to content
LuvemBooks
LuvemBooks

Who it's for. Who should skip it. What to read next.

Jonathan Rosen

About This Author
Reviewed

Updated

Read Time

8 min read

Age & reading levelAdult
Reader rating
4.4 · 3,914 Amazon ratings
reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
$16.40 on AmazonAudiobook
Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review
Front cover of The Best Minds: A Story of Friendship, Madness, and the Tragedy of Good Intentions

Our review

The Best Minds

The Best Minds by Jonathan Rosen Review: A Pulitzer-Finalist Memoir of Friendship and Tragedy

by Jonathan Rosen

Jonathan Rosen's memoir The Best Minds is a Pulitzer Prize finalist and a New York Times Top 10 Best Book of 2023 that reconstructs the author's lifelong friendship with Michael Laudor — a Yale-educated legal prodigy diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia who ultimately killed his pregnant girlfriend, Caroline Costello. Drawing on court and police records, medical studies, interviews, and diaries, Rosen widens the lens beyond one devastating story to examine deinstitutionalization, the nature of mental illness, and the self-deceptions of an entire era.

$16.40 on Amazon
Adulthomicide of a pregnant woman · paranoid schizophrenia and psychotic episodes

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Readers drawn to literary memoir that works simultaneously as cultural history — particularly those interested in mental illness, American meritocracy, the limits of friendship, and the policy failures of late twentieth-century deinstitutionalization.

Worth it if

Worth the considerable investment if you want a rigorously researched, multi-layered account that moves fluidly between intimate personal history and broad sociological critique — and can sustain engagement across 576 demanding, unrelenting pages.

Skip if

Skip it if you're looking for a tightly focused true-crime narrative or a biography of Michael Laudor alone, or if you need an emotionally uplifting resolution — the subject matter remains harrowing throughout with little consolation offered.

Kirkus Reviews, which named the book among its Best Books of 2023, praised it as "an affecting, thoughtfully written portrait of a friendship broken by mental illness and its terrible sequelae," while the Pulitzer Prize finalist listing at pulitzer.org echoes the New York Times' characterisation of the memoir as "an act of tremendous compassion and a literary triumph." Bookmarks.reviews describes it as "immensely emotional and unforgettably haunting," reflecting a broad critical consensus that Rosen has written a work that transcends its immediate subject.

“Rosen gives us the exquisitely fine print, drawing from clips, court and police records, legal and medical studies, interviews, and diaries.”

— New York Times
Sources: Kirkus Reviews, Pulitzer.org, Bookmarks.reviews, New York Times
4.4from 3,914 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

Ask LuvemBooks

Was this helpful?

The Best Minds: A Story of Friendship, Madness, and the Tragedy of Good Intentions is Jonathan Rosen's Pulitzer Prize\u2013finalist memoir reconstructing his lifelong friendship with Michael Laudor \u2014 a Yale-educated legal prodigy with paranoid schizophrenia \u2014 while simultaneously delivering a sweeping cultural history of deinstitutionalization and America's self-deceptions about mental illness. Rigorously researched and operating on multiple levels at once, it earned Top 10 Best Book of the Year recognition from The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and The Atlantic, and a place on Barack Obama's 2023 favorites list. Readers who prize literary memoir with serious sociological depth will find it essential, though its 576-page scope and unrelenting emotional weight make it a demanding rather than consoling experience.
Is it worth reading?
For readers drawn to literary memoir that also functions as cultural history and sociological study, The Best Minds is an essential work. Critical consensus — reflected in a Pulitzer Prize finalist designation, Top 10 Best Book recognition from The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, The Atlantic, Slate, and People, and inclusion among Barack Obama's favorite books of 2023 — is unusually broad and strong. Critics called it "a magisterial work, as much a sociological study of late 20th-century America as it is a book about madness" and "immensely emotional and unforgettably haunting." The key caveat is that at 576 pages, with wide sociological scope and unrelenting emotional weight, it rewards patience rather than offering consolation.
Similar books
Readers drawn to The Best Minds often reach for works that combine personal experience with serious inquiry into mental illness and the mind. Andrew Solomon's The Noonday Demon: An Atlas of Depression and Esmé Weijun Wang's The Collected Schizophrenias offer rigorous, first-person accounts of psychiatric illness that share Rosen's blend of memoir and cultural analysis. William Styron's Darkness Visible is a landmark short memoir of severe depression that rewards readers who appreciate literary precision applied to mental suffering. For the thread of intense, defining friendship that structures Rosen's narrative, Elena Ferrante's My Brilliant Friend provides a compelling fictional parallel. Johann Hari's Lost Connections approaches questions of mental health from a systemic, sociological angle reminiscent of Rosen's policy-history passages.
Who should read this?
The Best Minds is ideally suited to readers of serious literary memoir who want their personal narrative embedded in genuine cultural and historical analysis. It speaks directly to anyone interested in mental illness — particularly schizophrenia and the policy history of deinstitutionalization — as well as readers drawn to questions of American meritocracy, the limits of friendship, and late twentieth-century intellectual life. The book also rewards those interested in the post-Shoah Jewish intellectual world that shaped both the Rosen and Laudor families. It is not the right book for readers seeking true crime, a tightly focused biography of Michael Laudor, or any form of uplifting resolution.
About Jonathan Rosen
Jonathan Rosen is an American author and editor.
What are the main themes?
The Best Minds operates on several thematic levels simultaneously. At its most intimate, it is a study of friendship — specifically what one friend can and cannot understand about another's mind, and the limits of loyalty when that mind is overtaken by paranoid schizophrenia. More broadly, it examines deinstitutionalization and the systemic policy failures of late twentieth-century American psychiatry. Critics described its scope as "panoptic," extending to American meritocracy, the rise of predatory capitalism, the long shadow of the Second World War and its intellectual legacy, and what Rosen calls "the danger of stories" — the way narrative itself can become a vehicle for self-deception and destruction.
What awards and recognition has it received?
The Best Minds is a Pulitzer Prize finalist and received Top 10 Best Book of the Year designations from five major outlets: The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, The Atlantic, Slate, and People. Kirkus Reviews named it among its Best Books of 2023, calling it "an affecting, thoughtfully written portrait of a friendship broken by mental illness and its terrible sequelae." Barack Obama included it among his favorite books of 2023, reflecting what critics noted as the book's unusually broad reach across both literary and general audiences. Reviewers called it "brave and nuanced... An act of tremendous compassion and a literary triumph."
Summarize this book

Summarize this book

The Best Minds is Jonathan Rosen's memoir of his closest childhood friendship with Michael Laudor, which began when the Rosen family moved to New Rochelle in 1973. Both boys were sons of college professors, both were admitted to Yale, and Laudor blazed through college in three years, graduating summa cum laude — before a serious psychotic break led to a diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia. Even so, Laudor enrolled at Yale Law School while battling delusions, was celebrated in The New York Times as a genius destigmatizing mental illness, and sold a memoir with film rights to Ron Howard. Drawing on court and police records, medical studies, interviews, and diaries, Rosen widens the lens to examine deinstitutionalization, American meritocracy, and the policy failures that shaped Laudor's trajectory.

Follow up

Is it more memoir or true crime?
Where does the title come from?
How thoroughly researched is it?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

Ask LuvemBooks

What would you like to know about The Best Minds?

Answers come from our editorial notes on this book. If we haven't covered something, we'll say so.

Readers often ask

Our Review

We review the evidence: published critics, reader verdicts and BookTube reviews, gathered and weighed with AI assistance and edited by LuvemBooks, rather than one reader's first-hand take.

A Pulitzer Prize finalist and one of Barack Obama's favorite books of 2023, The Best Minds is a memoir that reviewers called "brave and nuanced... An act of tremendous compassion and a literary triumph."

What the Book Is and What It Covers

The Best Minds: A Story of Friendship, Madness, and the Tragedy of Good Intentions is Jonathan Rosen's memoir of his closest childhood friendship. When the Rosen family moved to New Rochelle in 1973, Jonathan and Michael Laudor became inseparable: both sons of college professors, both eventually admitted to Yale University.
Michael blazed through college in three years, graduated summa cum laude, and landed a top-flight consulting job. Then came the call: Michael had suffered a serious psychotic break and was in the locked ward of a psychiatric hospital, diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia.
Even so, he enrolled at Yale Law School while still battling delusions, was celebrated in The New York Times as a role-model genius destigmatizing mental illness, and sold a memoir with film rights to Ron Howard. The book's title is drawn from Allen Ginsberg's poem "Howl" — "I saw the best minds of my generation destroyed by madness" — a frame the memoir earns in full.

Research Depth and Structural Ambition

Rosen does not rely on memory alone. According to the New York Times, the book draws on newspaper clips, court and police records, legal and medical studies, interviews, diaries, and some of Laudor's own compositions to reconstruct events with what the Times described as "exquisitely fine print."
That documentary foundation allows Rosen to move between the intimate and the systemic: the boyhood friendship in New Rochelle, the post-Shoah Jewish intellectual world both families inhabited, and the broader policy history of deinstitutionalization that shaped Laudor's trajectory. Critics described the result as "a magisterial work, as much a sociological study of late 20th-century America as it is a book about madness" — one whose "panoptic" view extends to ambition, delusion, "the long shadow of the second world war and its unexpected intellectual legacy, and the danger of stories."

Literary Craft and Emotional Register

Kirkus Reviews, which named the book among its Best Books of 2023, praised it as "an affecting, thoughtfully written portrait of a friendship broken by mental illness and its terrible sequelae," commending Rosen for capturing "many worlds in this attentive, nuanced narrative" — boyhood discovery, the rise of predatory capitalism, and the essential limits of what one friend can understand about another's mind. The book's own passage on narrative and self-destruction surfaces that tension directly: as Kirkus quotes Rosen writing, "The flip side of the idea that writing heals you, perhaps, was the fear that failing to tell your story, and fulfill your dreams, cast you into outer darkness." critics called the memoir "immensely emotional and unforgettably haunting," and critics noted that Rosen thoughtfully interweaves the personal story with an account of changing attitudes toward mental illness — a dual track that keeps the book from functioning as either a simple tragedy or a policy argument alone.

Genuine Limitations

The memoir's considerable scope — personal history, cultural criticism, psychiatric policy, literary meditation — is also its most demanding quality for readers. At 576 pages, the book is long and deliberately expansive, and readers expecting a tightly focused true-crime narrative or a straightforward biography of Laudor may find Rosen's wide-angle sociological digressions require patience.
The book's emotional weight is sustained and unrelenting; those looking for resolution or consolation should know the subject matter remains harrowing throughout, as Rosen himself acknowledges in framing it as a story of "good intentions and tragic outcomes."

Who This Book Is For

The Best Minds rewards readers drawn to literary memoir that operates simultaneously as cultural history. Its recognition — a Pulitzer Prize finalist, a Top 10 Best Book of the Year designation from The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, The Atlantic, Slate, and People, and inclusion among Barack Obama's favorite books of 2023 — reflects a broad critical consensus that Rosen has written something that transcends its immediate subject.
Readers interested in mental illness, American meritocracy, the limits of friendship, or the policy failures of late twentieth-century psychiatry will find the book speaks directly to all of those concerns at once. It is not an easy read, but the record is clear that it is an important one.

Sources & Further Reading

The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

  1. Cited in this review
  2. 1
    Book Marks reviews of The Best Minds: A Story of Friendship, Madness, and the Tragedy of Good Intentions by Jonathan Rosen Book Marks

    bookmarks.reviews

  3. 2
    The Best Minds by Jonathan Rosen: 9780143132899 | PenguinRandomHouse.com: Books

    penguinrandomhouse.com

  4. Further reading
  5. 3
    Jonathan Rosen — author profile

    Jonathan Rosen, LuvemBooks

  6. 4
    Book Review: ‘The Best Minds,’ by Jonathan Rosen - The New York Times

    nytimes.com

  7. 5
    THE BEST MINDS | Kirkus Reviews

    kirkusreviews.com

  8. 6
    Jonathan Rosen - Finalist: The Best Minds

    pulitzer.org

  9. 7
    The Best Minds: A Story of Friendship, Madness, and the Tragedy of Good Intentions by Jonathan Rosen, Paperback | Barnes & Noble®

    barnesandnoble.com

Age & Reading Level

Recommended age

Adult

Browse all adult books

Content to know about

homicide of a pregnant woman
paranoid schizophrenia and psychotic episodes
psychiatric institutionalization

Best for: Adults — the book covers homicide, paranoid schizophrenia, and sustained harrowing subject matter with no consoling resolution

Skip if you want a focused true-crime narrative or a story that offers resolution and consolation

From our readers

Reader reviews

Be one of the first readers to answer.

Read it? Was it right for you?

Books like The Best Minds

Curated picks for readers who enjoyed The Best Minds, with our reasoning for each match.

If you liked The Best Minds

On Amazon

The Noonday Demon: An Atlas of Depression

Andrew Solomon

Shares Rosen's dual structure: intimate personal witness braided with a sweeping history of how society has failed to understand mental illness.

Solomon spent nearly a decade interviewing patients, doctors, and policymakers, producing a portrait of depression that moves from a single sufferer's bedroom to the halls of Congress — the same scale Rosen uses to examine schizophrenia. Both books refuse to separate the personal tragedy from the policy failure that enables it. Readers who found the cultural-history chapters in Rosen's book as compelling as the friendship narrative will feel immediately at home here.

On Amazon

Hidden Valley Road: Inside the Mind of an American Family

Robert Kolker

Follows one family shattered by schizophrenia across decades, exposing the same institutional failures and diagnostic blind spots Rosen traces.

On Amazon

Say Nothing: A True Story of Murder and Memory in Northern Ireland

Patrick Radden Keefe

Another literary nonfiction book that begins with a single violent act and expands into a decades-long reckoning with ideology, self-deception, and culpability.

On Amazon

My Own Country: A Doctor's Story

Abraham Verghese

A physician-memoirist watches a community undone by a misunderstood epidemic, blending medical history and personal loss in the same register Rosen uses.

Not your thing?

On Amazon

Lost Connections: Uncovering the Real Causes of Depression — and the Unexpected Solutions

Johann Hari

If the weight of homicide and psychosis made Rosen's book hard to finish, Hari covers mental-health system failures with more hope and less tragedy, at a brisker pace.