At a glance
LuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Devoted John Prine fans and readers of hybrid nonfiction who want an intimate, genre-blending account of the human grain behind Prine's music — his working-class humor, low-key grace, and artistic independence — assembled from firsthand access by a personally invested author.
Worth it if
You already love Prine's catalog and want to get as close as possible to the man behind it, and you can appreciate a mosaic of oral history, travelogue, and elegy assembled frankly from incomplete materials rather than a comprehensive cradle-to-grave biography.
Skip if
You're expecting a deeply sustained portrait of a long creative friendship or a thorough biographical treatment — the encounters between Piazza and Prine were, by one reviewer's account, too scattered and brief to fully carry that weight.
What readers & critics say
Kirkus Reviews calls it "a heartfelt blend of first-person journalism, oral history, travelogue, and elegy," recognizing its formal ambition and emotional weight. A review at calirb.com (drawing on the Norton Review by David Starkey) acknowledges the book "seems like it shouldn't work" given how scattered Piazza's encounters with Prine were, yet concludes that Piazza somehow pulls it off — crediting him for keeping the focus on Prine rather than himself.
“A heartfelt blend of first-person journalism, oral history, travelogue, and elegy.”
— Kirkus Reviews“Living in the Present With John Prine is the next best thing to the memoir Prine never got to write.”
— BookPageAsk LuvemBooks
Was this helpful?
- Is it worth reading?
- For readers who already love John Prine's music, this book delivers exactly what fan tribute usually fails to: granular insider detail, firsthand road-trip reportage, and the kind of prose — often written in present tense — that places the reader alongside Piazza rather than at a retrospective distance. Even the publisher's own review acknowledges the book 'seems like it shouldn't work' given how scattered the encounters between Piazza and Prine were, yet credits Piazza with pulling it off by keeping Prine, not himself, at the center. The key caveat is scope: this is a mosaic assembled from incomplete materials, not a comprehensive biography, and readers expecting a sustained portrait of a long creative collaboration may find the connective tissue thinner than the 'friendship and loss' framing implies.
- Similar books
- Readers drawn to Living in the Present with John Prine will find natural companions in other music-world memoirs and biographies. Bob Spitz's The Beatles: The Biography offers a similarly deep dive into the lives and working-class origins of iconic musicians. Lionel Richie's Truly and Lisa-Marie Presley and Riley Keough's From Here to the Great Unknown both blend personal testimony with the pressures of music-industry fame. Michael Neiman's Hello My Name is Sharkbait rounds out the music-adjacent shelf, while Matthew Perry's Friends, Lovers and the Big Terrible Thing shares the elegiac tone of a life recounted in the shadow of loss.
- Who should read this?
- The book is designed first and foremost for John Prine fans who want to understand the human grain behind his music — the working-class humor, the cancer survivorships, and what Piazza distills as the low-key, unpretentious grace that made Prine's persona as compelling as his catalog. It will also reward readers drawn to hybrid nonfiction that refuses to settle into a single genre, and to music journalism at its most personally invested. Those unfamiliar with Prine's work are not excluded, but the emotional register is calibrated for an audience that already knows why his music matters.
- About Tom Piazza
- Tom Piazza is celebrated as a novelist and a writer on American music. His twelve books include the novels The Auburn Conference, A Free State, and City of Refuge, the short-story collection Blues and Trouble, the post-Katrina manifesto Why New Orleans Matters, and the essay collection Devil Sent the Rain. In 2018, he rode with singer-songwriter John Prine to write a piece for the Oxford American — the assignment that ultimately grew into Living in the Present with John Prine.
- What are the main themes?
- The book orbits several interlocking themes: working-class American identity (rooted in Prine's suburban Chicago upbringing and his deep ties to rural Kentucky), artistic autonomy (embodied in Prine's decision to co-found Oh Boy Records rather than remain within the major-label system), and the relationship between friendship, access, and the limits of biography. Running beneath all of it is elegy — the attempt to reconstruct and honor a life from materials gathered before and after an unexpected death. Piazza's comparison of Prine to Bob Dylan — 'You don't want to be him, you just want to hang out with him' — crystallizes the accessible, unpretentious quality the book works hardest to preserve.
- What does the foreword add?
- The foreword is written by Fiona Whelan Prine, John's widow, and its significance is structural as well as emotional: it signals that this book carries a degree of family endorsement and access that distinguishes it from posthumous tributes assembled without the subject's participation or family's blessing. The review notes that the book originated as a project Prine himself wanted to exist — a planned memoir Piazza was helping him produce — which means Fiona Whelan Prine's foreword functions as an authorized continuation of that intention.
Summarize this book
Follow up
Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review
Press Enter to ask. Answers come from our editorial Q&A — start typing to see related questions.
Age & Reading Level
Recommended age
Adult
Reading level
Adult
Content to know about
Skip if you want a comprehensive, cradle-to-grave biography of John Prine rather than a hybrid memoir-elegy built from limited direct encounters.
Editorial Review
Tom Piazza's Living in the Present with John Prine is a National Bestseller and one of Billboard's "Ten Essential Music Books That Make Great Gifts" — a hybrid work of first-person journalism, oral history, travelogue, and elegy published by W. W. Norton & Company on September 9, 2025, with a foreword by Fiona Whelan Prine. Born from a 2016 Oxford American profile and a friendship that deepened until John Prine's death from COVID-19 complications in 2020, the book traces Prine's working-class Chicago roots, his Kentucky ties, his critical coverage Records breakthrough, and his decision to co-found Oh Boy Records, while weaving in road-trip reportage and testimony from Prine's peers and family. Kirkus Reviews calls it "a heartfelt blend of first-person journalism, oral history, travelogue, and elegy."
Read the Full ReviewBooks like Living in the Present with John Prine
Curated picks for readers who enjoyed Living in the Present with John Prine, with our reasoning for each match.
If you liked Living in the Present with John Prine
