Skip to content
Reviewed

Read Time

9 min read

Our age bandAdult
Reader rating
4.1 · 22,862 Amazon ratings, as of Nov 2026
reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review
The Housewife by Natalie Barelli front cover

Our review

The Housewife

The Housewife by Natalie Barelli Review: A Taut Domestic Thriller

Natalie Barelli’s The Housewife follows Jodie Davies, who marries renowned psychologist Dr. Roy Davies and moves into his Beverly Hills home, only to suspect he murdered his first wife. Reviewers praise its darkly comedic tone and fast pace, though some find its characterizations thin.

Our age band: Adultcoercion · captivity

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Fans of darkly comedic domestic thrillers will appreciate the fast-paced narrative centered on an unhinged, morally gray anti-heroine.

Worth it if

Worth reading if you prefer plot twists and chaotic energy over nuanced character development and airtight plotting.

Skip if

Skip it if you require logical consistency in the timeline and well-developed supporting characters to stay engaged.

Where reviewers agree and split

Readers rate it 4.1 on Amazon. The reviews we read that discuss it in depth split on some points:

  • Positive

    Bookish Elf · Book blog: praises the memorable voice and darkly comedic tone despite flawed plotting

  • Positive · 4/5

    Novelgossip · Book blog: delivers a fast-paced, darkly comedic thriller with a magnetic anti-heroine

  • Mixed · 6.5/10

    The Review Geek · Book blog: praises pacing and food details but criticizes flat characters and timeline errors

  • Negative

    Cannonball Read · Book blog: criticizes the nonsensical premise, flat characters, and unbelievable ending

Of the 4 reviews we read that discuss its characters, 2 call the lead narrator compelling, but 2 find supporting cast underdeveloped.

  • Characters

    2 call the lead narrator compelling · 2 find supporting cast underdeveloped

  • Pacing

    2 praise the relentless forward momentum

Characters

Praise

“One of the more memorable narrators in recent domestic suspense”

— Bookish Elf · Book blog
Praise

“Fiercely original, morally gray protagonist”

— judithdcollins.wixsite.com · Book blog
Criticism

“Writer hasn’t worked much on the characters of Jodie’s mother and Roy Davies”

— The Review Geek · Book blog
Criticism

“Other characters read as caricatures honestly”

— Cannonball Read · Book blog

Pacing

Praise

“Fast, voice-led thriller you can finish over a weekend”

— Bookish Elf · Book blog
Praise

“Fast-paced thriller that you just can’t put down”

— The Review Geek · Book blog
Overall verdicts are our summary of each review we read, from its headline, rating and conclusion. Topic counts use only words we can quote (4 reviews: 4 book blogs).

Novelgossip and Judith Collins praise the novel's relentless pacing and magnetic, morally gray protagonist, while The Review Geek and Cannonball Read note that the supporting cast remains flat and the premise relies on heavy-handed exposition.

Sources: Bookish Elf, Judith Collins blog, The Review Geek, Cannonball Read
4.1from 22,862 Amazon ratings, as of Nov 2026— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

Ask LuvemBooks

Was this helpful?

The Housewife by Natalie Barelli follows Jodie Davies as she navigates a gilded cage in Beverly Hills, suspecting her renowned psychologist husband of murdering his first wife. LuvemBooks finds it a breathless, darkly comedic thriller that prioritizes relentless pacing and an unreliable narrator over deep character exploration. It is best suited for readers who enjoy chaotic thrillers, though those seeking airtight plotting or nuanced secondary figures may find it lacking.
Is it worth reading?
It delivers a highly entertaining, single-sitting escape for fans of domestic thrillers and complex anti-heroines. Critics praise its sharp, sarcastic wit, though opinions split on the execution of its plot and characters. Readers who prioritize breathless momentum and chaotic energy will likely find it completely entertaining.
Similar books
Readers who enjoy this blend of thriller elements and sharp wit will likely appreciate Mad Honey by Jodi Picoult, Between Sisters by Kristin Hannah, and Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke. The Wedding People by Alison Espach also shares a focus on domestic life and sharp character dynamics, though it approaches the premise with a lighter touch. These titles offer comparable hooks for fans of unreliable narrators and isolated luxury settings.
Who should read this?
This novel is tailored for readers who enjoy suspenseful narratives with unhinged protagonists and sharp undertones. It appeals to fans of books like The Housemaid and Gone Girl who prioritize narrative momentum over realistic portrayal. It is less suitable for those who require airtight timelines, rigorous plotting, or fully realized supporting casts.
What age is it for?
Written for adults, this novel explores mature subject matter regarding captivity and complex marital dynamics that require a developed understanding of interpersonal conflict. While there are no explicit content warnings for graphic violence or sexual cruelty, the psychological intensity and thematic focus make it unsuitable for younger readers.
About Natalie Barelli
Natalie Barelli is a thriller author best known for her debut novel The Housewife, a psychological thriller that explores the dark dynamics within a marriage and has resonated with readers of domestic suspense fiction. Her writing style combines intimate character study with fast-paced suspense.
What are the main themes?
The novel centers on the facade of domestic perfection, marital coercion, and the dangers of isolation within a restrictive environment. Jodie’s investigation into her husband’s past forces her to confront her own hidden secrets and the blurring line between victim and perpetrator. The narrative also examines the performative nature of social standing and the psychological toll of maintaining a curated image.
How is the pacing and structure?
The narrative is driven by rapid pacing, creating a breathless reading experience. Critics note that the plot shifts rapidly to avoid predictability, maintaining tension through Jodie’s deeply unhinged perspective. While this relentless forward momentum works well for genre fans, it occasionally sacrifices rigorous plotting and leaves secondary figures underdeveloped.
Summarize this book

Summarize this book

Jodie Davies marries renowned psychologist Dr. Roy Davies and moves into his pristine Beverly Hills home, only to find her domestic fairy tale unraveling as he grows distant. Haunted by the memory of Roy’s late wife, Deborah, Jodie launches a desperate investigation that uncovers a darker, more controlling past. Caught between exposing the truth and protecting her own devastating secret, she navigates a treacherous social landscape in this psychological thriller.

Follow up

Is it based on a true story?
Does it have a sequel?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

Ask LuvemBooks

What would you like to know about The Housewife?

Answers come from our editorial notes on this book. If we haven't covered something, we'll say so.

Readers often ask

Our Review

We review the evidence: book bloggers and reader verdicts, gathered and weighed with AI assistance and edited by LuvemBooks, rather than one reader's first-hand take.

The Housewife delivers a breathless, darkly comedic ride that prioritizes pacing and an unreliable narrator over deep character exploration though.
The Housewife by Natalie Barelli front cover
The Housewife by Natalie Barelli front cover

Plot Summary and Characters

Jodie Davies has always dreamed of becoming a housewife. She marries renowned psychologist Dr. Roy Davies following a whirlwind romance.
The couple moves into a pristine Beverly Hills home. The domestic fairy tale quickly unravels.
Roy becomes distant and emotionally unavailable. His social circle openly views Jodie as a gold-digger.
The house remains haunted by the memory of Roy’s late first wife, Deborah. Jodie discovers that Deborah became a recluse before her death.
She begins to suspect Roy orchestrated her downfall. The deeper Jodie investigates, the darker Roy’s past emerges.
He appears obsessive, controlling, and unfaithful. Jodie realizes she must expose the truth.
Going to the police would require revealing her own devastating secret. She remains trapped in a house built on lies.
The narrative follows her desperate attempts to uncover the reality behind Roy’s polished facade. Jodie’s investigation forces her to navigate a treacherous social landscape.
Her own hidden past threatens to destroy her if she proceeds. The story hinges on her ability to survive within a gilded cage.
Jodie’s relentless pursuit of the truth drives the central conflict. Her actions blur the line between victim and perpetrator.
The premise establishes a high-stakes game of domestic cat-and-mouse. Jodie’s internal struggles mirror the external dangers she faces daily.

Critical Reception and Strengths

Reception to Natalie Barelli’s The Housewife varies across critics. Bookish Elf offers a positive verdict, praising the memorable voice and darkly comedic tone despite flawed plotting, calling it a "wickedly fun read" and noting its fast, voice-led pacing.
Similarly, Novelgossip delivers a positive assessment, highlighting the magnetic anti-heroine and darkly comedic thriller elements, deeming it "completely entertaining from start to finish." The Review Geek provides a mixed conclusion, calling it a "Fast-paced thriller that you just can’t put down" while commending the pacing and food details, but criticizing flat characters and timeline errors, ultimately rating it 6.5/10.
Conversely, Cannonball Read issues a negative verdict, condemning the nonsensical premise, flat characters, and an "unbelievably bad" ending. judithdcollins.wixsite.com also weighs in, praising the fiercely original, morally gray protagonist. The overall critical response remains divided on the novel's execution.
Critics note that the story shifts rapidly whenever the plot seems predictable. The narrative maintains its grip through Jodie’s deeply unhinged perspective.
Novelgossip describes the tone as "darkly funny" and "twisty." Novelgossip notes that a sharp edge of humor keeps the story from feeling too heavy.
Judith Collins of the Judith Collins blog praises the "taut, twisty triumph" that pairs an original protagonist with a "breathless, venomous game of domestic cat-and-mouse."
Reviewers appreciate the detailed descriptions of Jodie’s cooking and homemaking routines. These details serve as a window into her fractured psyche.
The Review Geek notes that the food descriptions will appeal to food lovers. The narrative structure relies on short, crisp chapters with constant cliffhangers.
This format creates a "read in one sitting" experience that suits beach reads and reading slumps. Critics also commend Jodie’s voice as magnetic and morally gray.
Readers find themselves rooting for her even when her actions are questionable. The novel balances suspense with sharp, sarcastic wit throughout its pages.
The protagonist’s quirks and her love for luxurious items ground her unraveling mental state. The Review Geek specifically highlights how the narrative uncovers discoveries in an engaging way.
Readers anticipate plot points that the protagonist herself fails to see. The pacing ensures that precarious situations remain tiring or predictable.
The story delivers a refreshing take on familiar thriller tropes. Bookish Elf and Novelgossip find the twists engaging, while Cannonball Read argues the plot reveals its major twists too quickly.
The book functions as a highly entertaining escape for genre fans. The constant tension prevents the plot from ever stalling.

Limitations and Reader Considerations

Some readers find the character work to be a significant drawback. Cannonball Read criticizes the novel for feeling like a "bad Freida McFadden book."
Cannonball Read argues that the premise makes little sense and relies on heavy-handed exposition. Cannonball Read feels the plot reveals its twists too quickly.
The narrative stays locked inside Jodie’s head for the entire duration. This constant first-person perspective can become exhausting.
The Review Geek points out minor timeline discrepancies that might confuse detail-oriented readers. The Review Geek notes that supporting characters lack depth.
Jodie’s mother is described as pure evil and functions merely as a plot device. Roy Davies is criticized as a cardboard cutout of the husband archetype."
Cannonball Read argues that the ending feels unbelievable and includes a random reveal that does not matter.
No source explicitly discusses how the book navigates these specific dynamics. Readers seeking emotional resonance may find the characters too one-dimensional.
The supporting cast feels underdeveloped compared to the central mystery. The narrative prioritizes shock value over psychological realism.
The protagonist's naivety and anger drive the plot forward. Her sister remains throughout the story.
The heavy reliance on exposition slows the initial momentum. The pacing occasionally sacrifices logical consistency for speed.
The novel demands a suspension of disbelief from its audience.

Is It Worth Reading?

The collected reviews reveal a clear tension between momentum and depth. The Housewife prioritizes a breathless, unpredictable ride over nuanced character development.
It succeeds as a darkly comedic, fast-paced thriller for readers who enjoy unreliable narrators. The story appeals to fans of domestic suspense who prefer plot twists over psychological realism.
It draws comparisons to The Housemaid and Gone Girl for its domestic suspense framework. However, the thin characterization and rapid-fire reveals may frustrate readers seeking intricate plotting.
The novel works best as a single-sitting escape rather than a literary suspense novel. Readers who enjoy unhinged anti-heroines and dark domestic humor will find it entertaining.
Those who prefer slow-burn mysteries or fully realized supporting casts may find it lacking. The book delivers a sharp, stylish ride that trades emotional weight for pure velocity.
The narrative promises a breathless escape that delivers on its chaotic premise. The story demands readers surrender to its unhinged energy.
The novel ultimately serves as a fast-paced diversion for the right audience. The narrative thrives on its chaotic momentum.

Sources & Further Reading

The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

  1. Cited in this review
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. Further reading
  5. 3
  6. 4

    judithdcollins.wixsite.com

  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8

    bookishelf.com

Age & Reading Level

Our age band

Adult

Our age band groups books for browsing; it isn't an age a review gave.

Content to know about

coercion
captivity
domestic manipulation

Best for: Adults 18+ — themes of coercion and captivity

Skip if you require logical consistency in the timeline and well-developed supporting characters to stay engaged.

From our readers

Reader reviews

No LuvemBooks readers have answered yet.

Read it? Was it right for you?

Discussion

Reader comments