Reviewed
Read Time
8 min read
Age & reading levelAdult
Reader ratingreader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
4.6
· 9,337 Amazon ratingsShare This Review
Our review
Snuff
Snuff: A Discworld Novel by Terry Pratchett Review: Sharp Satire Wrapped in Rural Mystery
Snuff is the 39th Discworld novel and the eighth City Watch story by Terry Pratchett, following Commander Sir Sam Vimes as a forced countryside holiday at the Ramkin estate quickly becomes a murder investigation tangled up in class prejudice and the persecution of goblins. A New York Times bestseller, it sold over 55,000 copies in its first three days — a figure that reflects the series' enduring pull on readers worldwide.
LuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Fans of satirical fantasy and police-procedural fiction who enjoy social commentary woven into comic plotting — particularly readers already invested in the City Watch arc of the Discworld series.
Worth it if
Worth reading if you enjoy the intersection of comic fantasy and moral seriousness, especially when class prejudice and justice are skewered through the eyes of a stubbornly principled copper transplanted into English country-house territory.
Skip if
Skip it if you are entirely new to Discworld and unwilling to accept that some plot payoffs — particularly around Vimes's supernatural abilities introduced in Thud! — will carry less weight without the accumulated series context behind them.
What readers & critics say
Publishers Weekly awarded the novel a starred review, calling it "a lively outing, complete with sly shout-outs to Jane Austen and gritty police procedurals," as quoted on ampersandbooks.org. Kirkus Reviews, whose own retrieved page describes the book as a treat no Discworld fan will want to miss, and The Guardian, whose retrieved review notes Pratchett's dual use of "snuff" to connect refined social privilege with arbitrary death, both contributed to a broadly positive critical picture.
“A treat no fan of Discworld — and there are boatloads of them — will want to miss.”
— Kirkus Reviews“Pratchett's novel turns on the connection between snuff as an old-fashioned social stimulant and snuff meaning arbitrary, unpleasant deaths.”
— The Guardian4.6from 9,337 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Ask LuvemBooks
Was this helpful?
Snuff is the 39th Discworld novel and eighth City Watch outing, following Commander Sir Sam Vimes as a forced family holiday at the Ramkin estate turns into a murder investigation exposing the brutal exploitation of goblins — and the class prejudices that enable it. A New York Times bestseller with a starred Publishers Weekly review, it delivers one of the City Watch series' sharpest articulations of its justice-and-inequality themes, wrapped in a country-house-mystery frame that blends Jane Austen with gritty police procedural. The ideal reader is already invested in the City Watch arc; first-timers will find the rural mystery navigable but will lose some force from backstory rooted in earlier entries like Thud!
- Is it worth reading?
- For readers already engaged with the City Watch arc, Snuff is, as Kirkus Reviews put it, unmissable — a richly contextualised entry packed with payoffs that reward series familiarity. Publishers Weekly awarded it a starred review, calling it 'a lively outing, complete with sly shout-outs to Jane Austen and gritty police procedurals,' and the novel was a finalist for both the 2012 Locus Award and the Prometheus Award. The rural setting gives a long-running series a fresh structural frame, and the goblin-prejudice plot produces one of the City Watch series' sharpest statements on class and justice. First-time Discworld readers will find the self-contained mystery navigable, but some backstory — particularly around the Summoning Dark ability Vimes acquired in Thud! — lands with less force without prior acquaintance.
- Who should read this?
- Snuff is best suited to readers who have followed the City Watch series — ideally from Guards! Guards! onward — and who enjoy satirical fantasy that takes its social themes as seriously as its comedy. Fans of the intersection between police procedural and comic fiction, or readers drawn to the country-house mystery tradition of Austen and Agatha Christie seen through a fantastical lens, will find it a distinctive and rewarding combination. Those approaching Discworld for the first time can follow the rural mystery plot, but will miss the full significance of Vimes's accumulated character history and supernatural abilities.
- Similar books
- Readers who enjoy Snuff's blend of satirical fantasy and social commentary within the Discworld universe will find more of the same in Raising Steam by Terry Pratchett, another late-series Discworld novel, and Going Postal by Terry Pratchett, which shares the City Watch world's interest in institutional reform and the redemption of unlikely heroes. For urban fantasy with a similar police-procedural flavour, Rivers of London by Ben Aaronovitch is a natural companion, while The Eyre Affair by Jasper Fforde and Howl's Moving Castle by Diana Wynne Jones offer comparable wit and literary playfulness for fans of British comic fantasy.
- About Terry Pratchett
- Sir Terry Pratchett OBE (1948–2015) was an English author born in Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, best known for the satirical fantasy Discworld series.
- What's this book about?
- Snuff follows Commander Sir Sam Vimes of the Ankh-Morpork City Watch, who is dispatched by Lord Vetinari on a family holiday to the Ramkin rural estate. What begins as a fish-out-of-water comedy quickly becomes a murder investigation: dinner with the local gentry exposes deep contempt for goblins, a nocturnal trip to Hangman Hill turns up a severed goblin finger, and local constable Feeney Upshot arrives to arrest Vimes himself. The novel is simultaneously a country-house mystery, a police procedural, and a pointed satire of class prejudice, with the persecution of goblins serving as its moral backbone.
- Who is it for?
- Snuff is most rewarding for readers who have followed the City Watch arc from Guards! Guards! onward and enjoy satirical fantasy that takes its social themes — class, justice, prejudice — as seriously as its comedy. Fans of police procedurals, country-house mysteries in the tradition of Austen and Agatha Christie, and British comic fantasy will find its genre-blending particularly satisfying. First-time Discworld readers can follow the plot, but will miss nuances tied to Vimes's accumulated history and the Summoning Dark backstory from Thud!
- What are the main themes?
- The central theme of Snuff is the relationship between power and prejudice, dramatised through the treatment of goblins — dismissed by the local gentry as vermin rather than people — and Vimes's instinctive resistance to that consensus on behalf of the powerless. Pratchett uses the country-house setting to satirise the English class system with specific targets drawn from the traditions of Austen and Agatha Christie, with Vimes's urban-copper sensibility providing the ethical counterweight to the landed gentry's assumptions. The dual meaning of 'snuff' — as a refined social stimulant and as arbitrary, unpleasant death — ties the novel's comedy and its moral argument together. The Prometheus Award nomination recognised its libertarian-leaning themes around the rights and recognition of an oppressed group.
- What format or source is it?
- Snuff: A Discworld Novel is available as a print book (hardcover and paperback), an e-book, and an audiobook. It was originally published in 2011 and is a New York Times bestseller, widely stocked in major retailers. LuvemBooks' assessment is grounded in the book's contents and its published critical reception, including starred reviews from Publishers Weekly and coverage in The Guardian.
Summarize this book
Is it worth reading?
Who should read this?
About Terry Pratchett
What's this book about?
Who is it for?
What are the main themes?
What format or source is it?
Summarize this book
Snuff is the 39th Discworld novel and the eighth City Watch story by Terry Pratchett. Commander Sir Sam Vimes is sent by Lord Vetinari on a family holiday to the Ramkin rural estate, where he almost immediately senses wrongdoing: dinner with local gentry reveals widespread contempt for goblins, a nocturnal trip to Hangman Hill with his manservant Willikins turns up a severed goblin finger and blood, and local chief constable Feeney Upshot arrives to arrest Vimes himself for the suspected murder of blacksmith Jethro Jefferson. The novel weaves together a fish-out-of-water comedy, a police procedural, and a sharp satirical examination of class prejudice and the persecution of those — here the goblins — dismissed by the powerful as less than human. Figures including children's book author Miss Felicity Beedle and the goblin guide Stinky pull Vimes deeper into the countryside's hidden crimes as he simultaneously mentors the young Upshot in what it means to be a proper copper.
Follow up
What is the goblin storyline about?
What is the mentorship thread between Vimes and Feeney Upshot?
What does the title Snuff mean?
Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review
Press Enter to ask. Answers come from our editorial Q&A — start typing to see related questions.
Our Review
This review is based on the book's contents and published critical reception, not hands-on reading.
What the Book Is and What Happens
Snuff centres on Commander Sir Sam Vimes of the Ankh-Morpork City Watch, who is dispatched by Lord Vetinari on a family holiday to the Ramkins' rural estate — a fish-out-of-water premise that Pratchett mines for both comedy and crime fiction.
Almost immediately, Vimes senses wrongdoing. A dinner with the local gentry reveals widespread contempt for goblins; a visit to the local tavern leads to a confrontation with the blacksmith Jethro Jefferson; and a nocturnal trip to Hangman Hill with his manservant Willikins produces not Jethro but a severed goblin finger and a great deal of blood.
The mystery deepens when the local chief constable, Feeney Upshot, arrives to arrest Vimes himself for Jethro's suspected murder. Vimes declines the arrest and instead takes on the project of teaching Upshot what it means to be a proper copper — a mentorship thread that runs through the book alongside the main investigation.
Miss Felicity Beedle, a children's book author with a connection to goblin culture, and the goblin guide Stinky are among the figures who draw Vimes deeper into the countryside's hidden crimes. Pratchett noted that the title word "snuff" carries at least two meanings, and the plot honours both.
Its Place in the Discworld and City Watch Series
The Discworld novels are designed to be readable in any order, and publishers note that Snuff is no exception to that general accessibility. That said, it draws on continuity from earlier City Watch entries — notably Vimes's ability to see in the dark, a power granted to him by the Summoning Dark, the demon that briefly possessed him in Thud!
Pratchett (1948–2015) authored more than fifty bestselling books that have sold more than one hundred million copies worldwide, and the Discworld series stands as his central achievement. Snuff appeared in 2011, placing it among the later entries in that sequence and carrying the accumulated weight of a fully realised world.
The book was a New York Times bestseller and sold over 55,000 copies in its first three days of release — a commercial statement about the loyalty of the readership Pratchett had built over decades.
Critical Reception and Recognition
Critical response to Snuff was broadly positive. Critics laureate A. S. Byatt observed that the novel connects its two meanings of "snuff" — the refined social stimulant and the concept of arbitrary, unpleasant deaths — and, as Wikipedia's reception summary records, she called Pratchett a master storyteller.
Publishers Weekly awarded the novel a starred review, describing it as "a lively outing, complete with sly shout-outs to Jane Austen and gritty police procedurals." Critics called it "a treat no fan of Discworld — and there are boatloads of them — will want to miss."
The book was also a finalist for the 2012 Locus Award and was among the Prometheus Award finalists that year, recognising its libertarian-leaning themes. The official Pratchett website describes the book as "entertaining, with all Pratchett's genius on display."
Themes: Class, Prejudice, and the Thin Blue Line
Snuff uses the rural-crime-fiction format as a vehicle for social commentary, with the treatment of goblins — regarded by the local gentry as vermin rather than people — serving as the book's moral backbone. Vimes's instinctive siding with the powerless against the privileged is a character trait the City Watch series has developed across eight books, and here it finds one of its most pointed expressions.
The countryside setting allows Pratchett to satirise the English class system with the specificity of someone who has spent long enough in country-house fiction — from Austen to Agatha Christie — to know exactly which targets to pick. The juxtaposition of Vimes's gritty urban-copper sensibility against the landed gentry's assumptions provides the engine for much of the book's comedy and its ethical argument.
Who This Book Is For
Readers who have followed the City Watch arc from Guards! Guards! onward will find Snuff a richly contextualised entry, stocked with payoffs that reward series familiarity. Those coming to Discworld for the first time will find the self-contained rural mystery plot navigable on its own terms, though some backstory — particularly around the Summoning Dark — will land with less force without prior acquaintance with Thud!
Fans of satirical fantasy that takes its social themes seriously alongside its comedy, or readers drawn to the intersection of police procedural and comic fiction, are the natural audience here. The book's blending of Austenian country-house conventions with Pratchett's Discworld machinery is, as critics noted, a distinctive combination.
Sources & Further Reading
The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.
- Cited in this review
- 1
Open Library
- Further reading
- 2
Terry Pratchett, Wikipedia
- 3
Age & Reading Level
Recommended age
Adult
Reading level
Adult
Tropes
found familymorally greyredemption arc
From how readers and romance sites describe it, not our own reading.
2 content notes · who it suits
Content to know about
class-based persecution and dehumanisation of an oppressed group
depictions of violent crime including murder
Skip if you want a standalone fantasy with no prior-series context required
From our readers
Reader reviews
Be one of the first readers to answer.
Read it? Was it right for you?
Books like Snuff
Curated picks for readers who enjoyed Snuff, with our reasoning for each match.
More by Terry Pratchett
If you liked Snuff
