Skip to content
Reviewed

Read Time

8 min read

Our age bandAdult
Reader rating
4.6 · 1,402 Amazon ratings, as of Nov 2026
reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review
Candy Slain Murder: A Jolly & Delightful Cozy Mystery (A Country Store Mystery) by Maddie Day front cover

Our review

Candy Slain Murder

Candy Slain Murder Review: A Cozy Christmas Double Mystery (Maddie Day)

by Maddie Day

Maddie Day's Candy Slain Murder, the eighth Country Store Mystery, sends Robbie Jordan after a Christmas murder and a decades-old skeleton in South Lick, Indiana. Reviewers found it comforting and well balanced but not surprising.

Our age band: Adult

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Fans of cozy culinary mysteries and the series' chatty ensemble who appreciate comforting holiday atmospheres and familiar tropes over fast-moving puzzles.

Worth it if

Worth reading if you want a mild holiday read with engaging characters and a dual murder setup, even if the pacing is slow and the culprit is predictable.

Skip if

Skip it if you prioritize unpredictable twists over familiar cozy tropes and a gentle holiday atmosphere.

Where reviewers agree and split

Readers rate it 4.6 on Amazon. The reviews we read that discuss it in depth split on some points:

  • Negative

    Kirkus Reviews · Press review: criticized as anemic mystery with only food descriptions standing out

  • Positive · 4 stars

    Lola's Reviews · Book blog: enjoyable cozy mystery with solid plot and comforting characters

  • Positive

    Happily Ever After Romance · Book blog: fun engaging mystery with charming characters and down-home appeal

All 3 reviews we read that discuss its characters find the cast comforting.

  • Characters

    3 find the cast comforting

Characters

Praise

“Large cast of side characters that all play a role”

— Lola's Reviews · Book blog
Praise

“Engaging characters I met here”

— Happily Ever After Romance · Book blog
Praise

“Robbie is a fun, lovable character”

— The Cozy Review · Book blog
Overall verdicts are our summary of each review we read, from its headline, rating and conclusion. Topic counts use only words we can quote (3 reviews: 3 book blogs).

Kirkus Reviews called the recipes a highlight of an 'anemic mystery,' while bloggers at Lola's Reviews and The Cozy Review praised the comforting cast and dual-mystery setup, noting the killer's reveal is unsurprising but the cozy holiday atmosphere delivers.

“The lavish food descriptions and appended recipes are the best parts”

— Kirkus Reviews
Sources: Kirkus Reviews, Lola's Reviews, The Cozy Review, Happily Ever After Romance
4.6from 1,402 Amazon ratings, as of Nov 2026— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

Ask LuvemBooks

Was this helpful?

Candy Slain Murder sends Robbie Jordan back to her South Lick, Indiana, café for a dual mystery involving a fresh murder and a decades-old skeleton uncovered during the holiday rush. While the culprit is predictable and the pacing leans gentle, the book delivers a comforting seasonal return to a warm ensemble cast and includes festive recipes. It is best suited for cozy mystery fans who prioritize character-driven comfort over a fast-moving, twist-heavy puzzle.
Is it worth reading?
The book is worth reading for those seeking a mild, comforting holiday mystery with a charming cast and included recipes. Reviewers praise the engaging characters and the balance between Robbie’s daily café life and the central case. However, readers who prioritize unpredictable twists may find the pacing deliberate.
Similar books
Readers who enjoy this series' focus on food and small-town charm might also like Tonya Kappes's Beaches, Bungalows & Burglaries for its cozy culinary setting, Katie Gayle's An English Garden Murder for its charming characters, or Carolyn L. Dean's Bed, Breakfast, and Bones for its gentle mystery.
Who should read this?
This book is written for adults who enjoy cozy mysteries and the Country Store Mystery series. It appeals to readers who value a warm group and a gentle mood over intricate plotting. Fans of Joanne Fluke and Leslie Budewitz will likely find Robbie Jordan’s investigations and the accompanying recipes particularly engaging.
What age is it for?
Written for adults, this cozy mystery contains mild themes and a background romantic thread but lacks graphic violence or explicit content. The gentle pacing and familiar tropes make it accessible to mature teen readers, though it is primarily marketed toward adult fans of the genre.
How is the pacing?
The pacing is gentle, reflecting the cozy mystery genre's emphasis on atmosphere over speed. Lola's Reviews noted the investigation moves slowly, with clues surfacing infrequently, which may frustrate readers. For fans of the series, the steady rhythm allows the holiday setting and characters to shine.
Does this book include recipes?
Yes, the book features culinary details that reviewers highlighted, and it includes recipes for readers to try. Kirkus Reviews specifically praised the appended recipes as a standout element of the novel. These culinary details complement the South Lick, Indiana, holiday setting and add to the book's comforting appeal.
Summarize this book

Summarize this book

Robbie Jordan returns to Pans 'N Pancakes for the Christmas trade in South Lick, Indiana, only to face a fresh murder and a skeleton exposed by a fire. As Robbie navigates a large, returning cast, she must untangle the cold case while balancing her personal life. The story balances cozy holiday charm with a dual mystery that rewards series fans more than seasoned puzzle solvers.

Follow up

What is the double mystery?
Can I read this as a standalone?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

Ask LuvemBooks

What would you like to know about Candy Slain Murder?

Answers come from our editorial notes on this book. If we haven't covered something, we'll say so.

Readers often ask

Our Review

We review the evidence: book bloggers and reader verdicts, gathered and weighed with AI assistance and edited by LuvemBooks, rather than one reader's first-hand take.

Candy Slain Murder is a comforting holiday cozy whose double mystery, a fresh body and a decades-old skeleton, earns it four-star reactions from the bloggers who covered it, even if the culprit is not a shock. It is best as a seasonal return visit to Robbie Jordan's South Lick, Indiana, café rather than a puzzle that will stump seasoned mystery readers.
Candy Slain Murder: A Jolly & Delightful Cozy Mystery (A Country Store Mystery) by Maddie Day front cover
Candy Slain Murder: A Jolly & Delightful Cozy Mystery (A Country Store Mystery) by Maddie Day front cover

Candy Slain Murder: Plot Summary and Characters

The eighth Country Store Mystery by Maddie Day finds Robbie Jordan's country store and café, Pans 'N Pancakes, busy with Christmas trade in December. Two odd events arrive close together: a man turns up claiming to be the long-lost half-brother of Robbie's assistant, and a fire destroys the home of a controversial anesthesiologist, exposing skeletal remains in his attic.
Robbie, drawn in against her better judgement, has to untangle a decades-old mystery while the holiday rush goes on. The publisher frames it as a hunt for a killer harder to crack than a stale gingerbread man.
The cast around her is large and returns from earlier books. Lola's Reviews names Robbie's aunt Adele and her partner Samuel, Dana's mother Corinne, Detective Buck and Detective Octavia, and Robbie's beau Abe, whose son Sean gets more page time here.

How Critics Rated the Mystery in Candy Slain Murder

Kirkus Reviews issued a negative verdict, criticizing the novel as an anemic mystery where only the food descriptions stand out. The publication noted that the best parts of this anemic mystery were the food descriptions.
Lola's Reviews provided a positive assessment, writing "My Rating: 4 stars" and noting a solid plot with comforting characters. The blogger specifically praised the Large cast of side characters that all play a role.
Similarly, Happily Ever After Romance delivered a positive review, describing the novel as a charming, engaging story with a down-home appeal. Finally, The Cozy Review offered positive feedback, focusing on the cast by noting that Robbie is a fun, lovable character.
The critical reception divides between professional criticism and blog coverage, with the former dismissing the mystery and the latter emphasizing the engaging cast.
That reviewer also called the murderer's reveal not too surprising, and the reviewer at The Cozy Review likewise wrote that the killer isn't a surprise. Neither treated this as a serious flaw: Lola's Reviews said it didn't mind much and called it a solid mystery.
Marsha at Happily Ever After Romance, also giving four stars, had her own suspect for one of the two puzzles and suspicions about the second. She said the fun lay in watching Robbie sort through clues rather than in sharpening her own detective skills.

Robbie, South Lick and the Series Comfort Factor

The series' appeal, as these reviewers describe it, is the familiar setting and cast. Lola's Reviews called it one of its favourite cozy series and said returning to South Lick and Robbie's store feels comforting.
The same review praised the balance between Robbie's daily life, side-character storylines and the central case.
The Cozy Review called Robbie a fun, lovable character and said readers know she will place herself in danger, solve the murder and catch the bad guy. That predictability is presented as part of the pleasure, with an ending that should leave fans smiling with holiday cheer.
The half-brother subplot gets particular mention at Lola's Reviews, which liked the uncertainty over whether he is who he says he is and how the characters react.

Is Candy Slain Murder Good for Newcomers and Holiday Reading?

Marsha's review answers the starting-point question directly: Candy Slain Murder was her first Country Store Mystery. She still had to work out some relationships along the way, but what she needed was explained in dialogue or narrative, and she planned to go back to the earlier books.
On the Christmas angle, Lola's Reviews described a mild, subtly handled holiday theme that still adds cheer, rather than a book saturated in tinsel. The Cozy Review called it a quick, easy read for the Christmas season.
Food is part of the draw too. Kirkus Reviews, as quoted on the publisher's page, called the lavish food descriptions and appended recipes the best parts, and the publisher notes the book includes recipes to try.

Is Candy Slain Murder Worth Reading? Our Take

Weighing these reviews, the tension is between comfort and surprise. Every reviewer who touched on the solution said the killer is guessable, yet each still recommended the book, so the case is for coziness, a warm cast and a seasonal setting rather than for a twist.
That points the book toward fans of cozy culinary mysteries who want an easy December read and a chatty ensemble, and toward series readers who will enjoy more of Abe's family and the extended cast. It points away from readers who want a fast-moving puzzle, since one reviewer found the investigation slow and the culprit unsurprising.
The Cozy Review placed it alongside Sarah Fox's Literary Pub Mystery series and Leslie Budewitz's Food Lovers' Village Mysteries as older holiday cozies, and the publisher pitches it at fans of Joanne Fluke. Nothing in these sources suggests heavy romance or high suspense; the romantic thread is a background relationship, not the draw.

Sources & Further Reading

The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

  1. Cited in this review
  2. 1
  3. Further reading
  4. 2
  5. 3

    kensingtonbooks.com

  6. 4
  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8

    kirkusreviews.com

Age & Reading Level

Our age band

Adult

Our age band groups books for browsing; it isn't an age a review gave.

From our readers

Reader reviews

No LuvemBooks readers have answered yet.

Read it? Was it right for you?

Books like Candy Slain Murder

Curated picks for readers who enjoyed Candy Slain Murder, with our reasoning for each match.

Discussion

Reader comments