Skip to content
M

Maddie Day

Maddie Day is a pseudonym of Edith Maxwell, an American mystery author who writes cozy mysteries, including the Country Store Mystery series. An Agatha-nominated bestselling author, she holds a PhD in Linguistics from Indiana University and is a member of Sisters in Crime and Mystery Writers of America.
On LuvemBooks, we've reviewed Candy Slain Murder.
1
Books Reviewed

Ask LuvemBooks about Maddie Day

Maddie Day is the cozy-mystery pseudonym of Edith Maxwell, and LuvemBooks has reviewed 1 of her books: Candy Slain Murder, where Robbie Jordan investigates a Christmas murder and a decades-old skeleton in South Lick, Indiana. The evidence points to a reassuring, balanced cozy rather than a twist-driven one: reviewers called it comforting and well balanced but not surprising, and it holds a 4.6/5 reader rating from 1,402 Amazon ratings.
Where should I start?
Start with Candy Slain Murder because it is the only Maddie Day book we have reviewed, with a 4.6/5 reader rating from 1,402 Amazon ratings. Its premise pairs a Christmas murder with a decades-old skeleton in South Lick, Indiana, and reviewers found it comforting and well balanced but not surprising. One caveat: the summary identifies it as the eighth Country Store Mystery, so readers who dislike entering mid-series may prefer an earlier entry.
What's their writing style?
Based on the one reviewed book, Maddie Day's cozy style favors steadiness over surprise: Candy Slain Murder was described as comforting and well balanced but not surprising. The story uses a seasonal small-town frame—Christmas in South Lick, Indiana—and puts Robbie Jordan on both a present murder and a decades-old skeleton. That suggests an appeal built from atmosphere and equilibrium rather than abrupt twists.
Books we've reviewed
We have reviewed 1 Maddie Day book. Candy Slain Murder: A Jolly & Delightful Cozy Mystery sends Robbie Jordan after a Christmas murder and a decades-old skeleton in South Lick, Indiana; reviewers found it comforting and well balanced but not surprising. It carries a 4.6/5 reader rating from 1,402 Amazon ratings.
What genre do they write?
Maddie Day writes cozy mysteries, and the reviewed Candy Slain Murder is categorized as Cozy Mystery. The bio also names the Country Store Mystery series, while the reviewed book adds the familiar cozy signals of a small-town setting and a seasonal Christmas case. The tone, per reviewers, leans comforting and balanced rather than startling.
What should I read after Candy Slain Murder?
Within LuvemBooks coverage, there is no next reviewed Maddie Day title after Candy Slain Murder; we have reviewed only that one. Because the summary calls it the eighth Country Store Mystery, readers who want series context may look backward rather than forward. The bio also lists Flipped for Murder as a notable work, though we have not reviewed it here.
Who is Maddie Day?

Who is Maddie Day?

Maddie Day is a pseudonym of Edith Maxwell, an American mystery author known for cozy mysteries including the Country Store Mystery series. The bio describes an Agatha-nominated bestselling author with a PhD in Linguistics from Indiana University and memberships in Sisters in Crime and Mystery Writers of America. On LuvemBooks, we have reviewed 1 Maddie Day book.

Follow up

Is Maddie Day the same writer as Edith Maxwell?
What is Maddie Day known for?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

​

Press Enter to ask. Answers come from our editorial Q&A — start typing to see related questions.

Authors Like Maddie Day
Richard Osman

Richard Osman

Cozy Mystery

Richard Thomas Osman is an English television presenter, producer, and novelist.

4 books reviewed
The Last Devil to Die: A Thursday Murder Club Mystery
The Man Who Died Twice
The Bullet That Missed
C

Carolyn L. Dean

Cozy Mystery

Carolyn L. Dean is a USA Today bestselling author best known for her cozy mystery fiction. She has been writing stories since childhood and is the creator of the Ravenwood Cove cozy mystery series, whose first book launched in July 2016 and reached #1 among free books on Amazon. Her stated goal is to create worlds and characters that inspire, challenge, and entertain readers.

1 book reviewed
Bed, Breakfast, and Bones: A Ravenwood Cove Cozy Mystery
K

Katie Gayle

Cozy Mystery

Katie Gayle is the writing partnership of South African writers Kate Sidley and Gail Schimmel. The pair began collaborating after agreeing it would be a lark to write a book together, which led to the character Epiphany Bloom. Katie Gayle marks both writers' debut in the cozy mystery genre.

1 book reviewed
An English Garden Murder
T

Tonya Kappes

Cozy Mystery

Tonya Kappes is a USA Today bestselling author of southern cozy mysteries, with more than 180 titles to her name, known for stories with southern charm and small-town settings. Raised in a small rural town in Kentucky, she lives in the Bluegrass state and is also a Woman's World Book Club pick twice.

1 book reviewed
Beaches, Bungalows & Burglaries
F

Fiona Grace

Cozy Mystery

Fiona Grace is an author of cozy mystery and romance fiction. Her debut series is the Lacey Doyle Cozy Mystery series, beginning with Murder in the Manor, and she has also written the Tuscan Vineyard, Dubious Witch, and Beachfront Bakery cozy mystery series.

1 book reviewed
Murder in the Manor
B

Benjamin Stevenson

Cozy Mystery

Benjamin Stevenson is an award-winning stand-up comedian and USA Today and million-copy best-selling author of mystery novels. He wrote his first novel at 17, later working as a comedian and at Curtis Brown Literary Agency before becoming a full-time novelist. His fiction is known for closed-circle mysteries that engage with golden age mystery tropes.

1 book reviewed
Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone: A Clever Take of the Classic Murder Mystery