For the right reader, emphatically yes. The Printed Letter Bookshop earned ECPA bestseller status and finalist recognition at the 2020 Carol Award for Best Contemporary and the 2020 INSPY Award in General Fiction, and peer endorsers — including New York Times bestselling author Patti Callahan Henry — have praised its emotional texture with genuine enthusiasm rather than routine blurb-writing. The central premise of a contested bookshop inheritance gives familiar themes of grief and forgiveness a concrete dramatic shape that feels earned. The main caveat is pacing: the novel is contemplative rather than plot-driven, and its faith-informed sensibility will feel more natural to some readers than others.

Katherine Reay

Reviewed

October 20, 2026

Read Time

8 min read

Age & reading levelAdult

Reader rating

4.5

· 2,047 Amazon ratings

reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

Buy on Amazon

Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →

Share This Review

Our review

The Printed Letter Bookshop

Name: The Printed Letter Bookshop
Author: Katherine Reay
ISBN: 0785222006

The Printed Letter Bookshop by Katherine Reay Review: A Warm, Bookish Novel of Second Chances

by Katherine Reay

The Printed Letter Bookshop is a contemporary fiction novel by Katherine Reay in which Madeline Cullen inherits her estranged aunt's struggling small-town bookshop and must reckon with grief, bitterness, and two employees determined to save what she plans to sell. An ECPA bestseller and finalist for both the 2020 Carol Award and the 2020 INSPY Award in General Fiction, it has earned sustained enthusiasm from readers who love literary, character-driven women's fiction.

Buy on Amazon

Front and back cover of a contemporary fiction novel featuring colorful stacked books and a bookshop storefront illustration.

Front and back cover of a contemporary fiction novel featuring colorful bookshelf illustrations and synopsis text.

Front cover featuring the title in decorative typography surrounded by colorful illustrated book spines.

Tap to enlarge

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Bibliophiles and readers of character-driven women's fiction who are drawn to stories about grief, forgiveness, and community anchored in an independent bookshop setting — particularly those who enjoy authors like Nina George or Jenny Colgan, or who are looking for a meaningful book-club pick or gift for someone navigating a difficult transition.

Worth it if

Worth reading if you love fiction in which the bookshop itself is an emotional argument — a space where loss, forgiveness, and the restorative power of literature are treated as inseparable from one another.

Skip if

Skip it if you prioritise propulsive plotting or narrative complexity, as the pacing is deliberately contemplative, and its faith-informed sensibility — reflected in its INSPY and Carol Award recognition — may not align with what you're looking for in mainstream women's fiction.

What readers & critics say

Allaboutromance.com finds the novel "a pleasant enough story" that "anchors itself in the warmth of its main characters — three women from different worlds who come together to manage a bookstore," praising Reay's "very nice eye for small details," though noting it "trips over its own execution." Reader-reviewers at booktimistic.com and readingladies.com are more enthusiastic, with booktimistic.com calling it "a cozy, charming read" and "an ode to independent bookshops and book lovers," while readingladies.com awarded it 4.5 stars.

Sources: allaboutromance.com, booktimistic.com, readingladies.com, thegreenmockingbird.wordpress.com

4.5from 2,047 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

Preview the book

Ask LuvemBooks

Was this helpful?

The Printed Letter Bookshop follows Madeline Cullen, who inherits her estranged aunt's struggling independent bookshop and must choose between selling it and confronting the grief and bitterness she has carried for years — all while two devoted employees fight to keep the Printed Letter alive. An ECPA bestseller and finalist for both the 2020 Carol Award and the 2020 INSPY Award in General Fiction, it is essential reading for fans of literary, character-driven women's fiction who are drawn to stories about grief, forgiveness, and the restorative power of books. Readers who prioritise narrative momentum or are put off by a faith-informed sensibility may want to approach it with adjusted expectations.

Is it worth reading?: For the right reader, emphatically yes. The Printed Letter Bookshop earned ECPA bestseller status and finalist recognition at the 2020 Carol Award for Best Contemporary and the 2020 INSPY Award in General Fiction, and peer endorsers — including New York Times bestselling author Patti Callahan Henry — have praised its emotional texture with genuine enthusiasm rather than routine blurb-writing. The central premise of a contested bookshop inheritance gives familiar themes of grief and forgiveness a concrete dramatic shape that feels earned. The main caveat is pacing: the novel is contemplative rather than plot-driven, and its faith-informed sensibility will feel more natural to some readers than others.
Similar books: Readers who love The Printed Letter Bookshop tend to be drawn to the same sub-genre of literary fiction in which the independent bookshop is as emotionally active as the characters. Veronica Henry's How to Find Love in a Bookshop and Gabrielle Zevin's The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry are both named as natural companions — books that treat bookselling and literary love as serious emotional territory. Libby Page's This Book Made Me Think of You sits in the same space of character-driven, community-rooted fiction. Reay's own The Undercover Bookshop is the most obvious next step for readers who want to stay in her fictional world, and Alison Espach's The Wedding People appeals to a similar women's fiction readership navigating grief and unexpected connection.
Who should read this?: The Printed Letter Bookshop is strongly suited to readers who love fiction about books and the people who sell, read, and are changed by them — the same audience drawn to Nina George, Jenny Colgan, Veronica Henry, or Gabrielle Zevin. It also works exceptionally well as a gift for a bibliophile, for someone navigating a difficult personal transition, or for a book-club group looking for a title that generates genuine discussion about forgiveness and belonging. Readers who prefer propulsive plotting, or who are not drawn to a faith-informed sensibility, will find it less suited to their tastes.
About Katherine Reay: Katherine Reay is a national bestselling and award-winning author of twelve novels and one non-fiction work. A Phi Beta Kappa graduate of Northwestern University, where she earned both a BA and an MS, she has enjoyed a lifelong affair with books and history. She has lived across the country and in Europe, and currently resides outside Bozeman, MT — and is also, notably, a tae kwon do black belt.
Is this a good book club pick?: The Printed Letter Bookshop is a strong book club choice. The contested bookshop inheritance gives the group a concrete dramatic situation to debate, while the deeper themes of grief, forgiveness, and the restorative power of books generate substantive discussion. The novel's own articulated thesis — that books 'are a conversation, and introduce us to ourselves and others' — is a natural discussion anchor. Patti Callahan Henry's comment that she wanted to 'give it to every woman I know' reflects the kind of enthusiastic word-of-mouth that makes it well-suited to group reading.
How does this compare to The Undercover Bookshop?: Both titles sit within Katherine Reay's world of character-driven, bookshop-centred fiction and share her hallmark strength — the rendering of interior life with precision, as noted by peer endorsers. The Printed Letter Bookshop is described as a natural entry point into Reay's work, while The Undercover Bookshop serves readers who want to continue in her fictional world. LuvemBooks has reviewed The Undercover Bookshop separately for readers looking to compare the two directly.

Summarize this book

Is it worth reading?

Who should read this?

About Katherine Reay

Is this a good book club pick?

How does this compare to The Undercover Bookshop?

Summarize this book

Madeline Cullen's warmest childhood memories centre on the Printed Letter Bookshop, her Aunt Maddie's quaint independent bookstore. Nearly twenty years later, after estrangement and accumulated losses have hardened her, Madeline inherits the shop — and her instinct is to sell quickly. Standing in her way are the shop's two employees, who are determined to save the Printed Letter, and that conflict between Madeline's guarded pragmatism and the lives already rooted in the shop forms the engine of the story. Katherine Reay uses the contested inheritance to dramatise themes of grief, forgiveness, and the idea — stated in the novel's own text — that books 'introduce us to ourselves and others.'

Follow up

Is there a sequel or companion novel?

What is the tone of the book?

How central is the bookshop to the story?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

Ask LuvemBooks

What would you like to know about The Printed Letter Bookshop?

Answers come from our editorial notes on this book. If we haven't covered something, we'll say so.

Readers often ask

Our Review

Katherine Reay's novel earns its devoted readership by weaving loss, forgiveness, and the restorative power of books into a story anchored in one small shop.

What the Story Is

Madeline Cullen's warmest childhood memory is working alongside her Aunt Maddie at the Printed Letter Bookshop, a quaint independent bookstore that felt like home.

Nearly twenty years later, Madeline inherits the shop — but family estrangement and her own accumulation of losses have hardened her against both her aunt's memory and the struggling business left in her care. Her instinct is to sell quickly, and to move on.

Standing in her way are the shop's two employees, who have no intention of letting the Printed Letter close without a fight. That conflict — between Madeline's guarded pragmatism and the lives already rooted in the bookshop — forms the engine of the novel's plot.

Front cover featuring the title in decorative typography surrounded by colorful illustrated book spines.

Place in the Genre

Reay is a national bestselling and award-winning author, and The Printed Letter Bookshop sits comfortably within a distinct lineage of fiction built around independent bookshops as sanctuaries of community. Endorsers have compared it to Nina George and Jenny Colgan — authors whose work similarly treats the bookshop as both setting and emotional argument.

The novel was an ECPA bestseller and earned finalist recognition at the 2020 Carol Award for Best Contemporary and the 2020 INSPY Award in General Fiction — two of the more prominent prizes in faith-informed literary fiction. A companion novel, Of Literature and Lattes, has since been published for readers who want to remain in Reay's fictional world.

What It Does Well

Reay's particular strength, according to endorsers on record with her publisher, is her ability to render interior life with precision. As novelist Rachel Hauck writes, the book is "both a powerful story and a dazzling experience" because Reay "has the rare ability to delve into her characters' private world with such clarity that they come alive on the page."

New York Times bestselling author Patti Callahan Henry called it "powerful, enchanting and spirited," adding that she wanted "to give it to every woman I know." That level of peer endorsement reflects genuine enthusiasm for the novel's emotional texture rather than surface charm.

Front and back cover of a contemporary fiction novel featuring colorful stacked books and a bookshop storefront illustration.

The book also contains two passages — surfaced by reader sources — that capture its central argument about literature itself: "That's what books do, Maddie used to say; they are a conversation, and introduce us to ourselves and others." That sentence, drawn from the novel's own text, is the thesis the story spends its pages dramatising.

Themes and Emotional Terrain

The novel's core concerns are love, resilience, forgiveness, and human connection — themes familiar to the genre, but ones Reay handles through the specific mechanism of a contested inheritance rather than a more abstract premise.

Readers drawn to stories about grief processed alongside community — where the setting is as emotionally active as the characters — will find the bookshop itself functioning as a third argument in the novel's central debate. The stakes are personal for Madeline, but also communal for everyone the Printed Letter has served.

Front and back cover of a contemporary fiction novel featuring colorful bookshelf illustrations and synopsis text.

Some readers note that the novel is best approached as a lighter, though emotionally resonant, read. One independent reader source described it as "a great choice for a lighter but thoughtful read" — meaning those seeking propulsive plotting or narrative complexity may find the pacing more contemplative than they expect.

Who This Novel Is For

The Printed Letter Bookshop is strongly suited to readers who love fiction about books and the people who sell, read, and are changed by them — the same audience drawn to How to Find Love in a Bookshop or The Lost for Words Bookshop. Its faith-informed sensibility (reflected in its INSPY and Carol Award recognition) will feel natural to some readers and may simply register as warmth for others.

It works as a gift — to a bibliophile, to someone navigating a difficult transition, or to a book-club group looking for a title that generates genuine discussion about forgiveness and belonging. What the novel offers, above all, is exactly what Reay's endorsers promise: a story in which literary love and human repair are treated as the same project.

Sources & Further Reading

The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

Cited in this review
1
The Printed Letter Bookshop | Katherine Reay
katherinereay.com
2
The Printed Letter Bookshop [Book Review] - Reading Ladies
readingladies.com
3
Review: “The Printed Letter Bookshop” by Katherine Reay
thegreenmockingbird.wordpress.com
Further reading
4
The Printed Letter Bookshop by Katherine Reay – Porchlight Book Company
porchlightbooks.com
5
Summary of 'The Printed Letter Bookshop' by Katherine Reay
newbookrecommendation.com
6
Book Review: The Printed Letter Bookshop by Katherine Reay – Life Love Laughter Linds
lifelovelaughterlinds.ca
7
THE PRINTED LETTER BOOKSHOP Book Review - A Well-Read Tart
wellreadtart.com
8
The Printed Letter Bookshop - Book Review - Booktimistic
booktimistic.com
9
The Printed Letter Bookshop by Katherine Reay : All About Romance
allaboutromance.com
10
The Printed Letter Bookshop by Katherine Reay, Paperback
barnesandnoble.com

Age & Reading Level

Recommended age

Adult

Browse all Adult books

Tropes

found familyredemption arc

From how readers and romance sites describe it, not our own reading.

2 content notes · who it suits

Content to know about

grief and estrangement

family bitterness and unresolved loss

Skip if you want propulsive plotting or narrative complexity rather than contemplative, character-driven women's fiction

From our readers

Reader reviews

Be one of the first readers to answer.

Read it? Was it right for you?

Books like The Printed Letter Bookshop

Curated picks for readers who enjoyed The Printed Letter Bookshop, with our reasoning for each match.

More by Katherine Reay

On Amazon

The Undercover Bookshop

Katherine Reay

Reay returns to bookshop territory with a hidden-identity twist: another imperiled shop, more book talk, and a romance threaded through the rescue.

Reay builds this one around a bookshop in trouble and a newcomer whose real reasons for being there stay hidden, so the save-the-shop energy of The Printed Letter Bookshop gets an added layer of secrets and romantic tension. The warmth and affection for reading communities carry over, but the plot moves with more intrigue. It suits readers who wanted the same cozy stakes with a little more momentum.

If you liked The Printed Letter Bookshop

In our catalogue

This Book Made Me Think of You

Libby Page

A widow receives twelve books her late husband chose before he died, one each month — mourning worked through reading and new friendship.

On Amazon

How to Find Love in a Bookshop

Veronica Henry

A daughter inherits her late father's Cotswolds bookshop and discovers how many lives it held together — grief, community, and second chances.

On Amazon

The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry

Gabrielle Zevin

A grieving, grumpy island bookseller is softened by an abandoned child and a persistent sales rep — loss healed through books and found family.

Not your thing?

On Amazon

The Wedding People

Alison Espach

For readers who wanted more bite and pace: a sharper, darker, funnier second-chance story set over one chaotic wedding weekend.