Skip to content
Reviewed

Updated

Read Time

9 min read

Our age bandAdult
Reader rating
4.4 · 59,723 Amazon ratings
reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review
Front cover of Summer Island

Our review

Summer Island

Summer Island Review: An Estranged Mother, a Fogged Island (Kristin Hannah)

Kristin Hannah's Summer Island sends a bitter comedienne to care for the famous mother who abandoned her, with a first-love reunion waiting on the island. Reviewers split between a moving reconciliation and an overly tidy, preachy one.

Our age band: Adultparental abandonment · a family history of alcoholism

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Readers who want a quick, tear-prone family drama about estrangement and forgiveness with a secret twist, and who are comfortable with a tidy, emotionally satisfying resolution.

Worth it if

Worth reading if you want an easy, emotional reconciliation where the characters' healing arrives neatly and you don't need the road there to be fully convincing.

Skip if

Skip it if you want a prickly lead made believable or a reconciliation that costs something, since Kirkus Reviews found it preachy and syrupy and All About Romance found Ruby's quick change too convenient.

Reception is split, with the two most critical voices coming from Kirkus Reviews, which called it a "nobly preachy snifflefest", and All About Romance, which found the reconciliation sentimental and too easy. Several book bloggers were warmer, finding it enjoyable and moving, though one noted it falls short of Hannah's earlier works.

“Happy endings await almost everyone—except for readers of this nobly preachy snifflefest.”

— Kirkus Reviews
Sources: Kirkus Reviews, All About Romance, Review This Reviews, Every Free Chance
4.4from 59,723 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

Ask LuvemBooks

Was this helpful?

Summer Island sends a bitter comedienne to care for the famous mother who abandoned her. It is comfort reading for readers who want an easy, tear-prone family drama; reviewers split between those who found the reconciliation moving and those who found it syrupy and too tidy.
Is it worth reading?
It delivers best as an easy, emotional weekend read. The Roelia Reads blogger found it deeply moving and singled out Eric's storyline, and All About Romance found the writing smooth and no chore to read. The caveat is that some reviewers found it preachy, with characters who psychoanalyse themselves, and found the ending rushed. Readers wanting Hannah at her most accomplished are pointed elsewhere.
Similar books
Readers who want Hannah's heavier historical side can try The Nightingale. For a lighter, bookish emotional read from another author, This Book Made Me Think of You is a related pick. Firefly Lane is another Hannah title in the same vein but is not in our catalogue. Separately, All About Romance suggested Jennifer Weiner's Good in Bed for a more realistic exploration of maternal absence.
Who should read this?
It suits readers who want a story about estrangement, forgiveness and secrets on an island, and who don't mind a neat resolution. Some reviewers likened the mood to Hallmark films with more emotional depth. It suits less well readers who want unlikable characters or a reconciliation with real consequences.
What age is it for?
This is written for adults. The reviews describe maternal abandonment and an alcoholic father in the family history, with no sources flagging explicit content. No review we found gives a heat level for the romance, so check before handing it to a younger teen.
About Kristin Hannah
Kristin Hannah is an American writer.
How sad is it?
Sadness runs through it: maternal abandonment and an alcoholic father. Kirkus Reviews's "snifflefest" jab concedes the book is built to draw tears, though it meant that as a criticism. Whether the ending then lifts the mood or feels too neat is exactly where reviewers part ways.
Where is it set?
Most of the story unfolds at Summer Island in the San Juans, in Washington State. Some reviewers found the setting warm and nostalgic, and described the San Juan Islands backdrop as a calm contrast to the characters' emotional turmoil.
Summarize this book

Summarize this book

Nora Bridge, a radio host and columnist famous for moral advice, once walked out on her marriage and left her daughters behind. Her youngest, Ruby, a struggling comedienne, goes home under false pretenses to care for her after an accident and a tabloid scandal. Nora insists they retreat to the old family house on Summer Island in the San Juans, where Ruby meets the two boys she once counted as best friends and learns a truth that reframes the past.

Follow up

Is there a twist?
Is it a standalone?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

Ask LuvemBooks

What would you like to know about Summer Island?

Answers come from our editorial notes on this book. If we haven't covered something, we'll say so.

Readers often ask

Our Review

We review the evidence: published critics, reader verdicts and BookTube reviews, gathered and weighed with AI assistance and edited by LuvemBooks, rather than one reader's first-hand take.

A tearjerker about an estranged mother and daughter forced together in a childhood island house, with a first-love reunion running alongside. Reviewers split on whether the reconciliation is moving or too easy.

What is Summer Island about?

Nora Bridge walked out on her marriage and left her daughters behind. She has since become a famous radio talk-show host and newspaper columnist known for moral advice, according to the Penguin Random House listing.
Her youngest daughter, Ruby, is a struggling comedienne who mines her famous mother for bitter, cynical jokes.
When a scandal from Nora's past reaches the tabloids, Nora is injured in an accident and a glossy magazine offers Ruby a fortune to write a tell-all. Under false pretenses, Ruby goes home to care for the mother she hasn't spoken to in almost a decade.
Nora insists they retreat to the old family house on Summer Island in the San Juans.
There Ruby is reunited with her first love and his brother, the two boys she once counted as best friends.
The novel is a mother-daughter reconciliation story built on forced proximity, a family secret that reframes the past, and a first-love thread. The publication details above, including a November 2004 paperback from Random House Publishing Group, are for that later edition; the novel itself dates from 2001.

Do reviewers find the Summer Island reconciliation moving or too easy?

The split is sharp. The Roelia Reads blogger found it a deeply moving story about broken relationships, forgiveness and second chances, though without the emotional impact or narrative skill of Hannah's later work.
The Roelia Reads blogger singled out Eric's storyline as the emotional centre.
The reviewer at Every Free Chance called it primarily a mother-daughter reconciliation story with a slow reveal that the past was not what it seemed. The Every Free Chance reviewer found it entertaining but not remarkable.
The reviewer at Review This Reviews found the story realistic and the voices clear, and recommended it.
Kirkus Reviews was harsher, calling it a "nobly preachy snifflefest" and saying happy endings await almost everyone except readers. All About Romance called it a reunion tale with a sentimental, too-easy solution to the problem of parental abandonment.
The publisher's own copy calls the book "poignant, funny, luminous". That is marketing language, not a critical verdict.
The Washington Post Book World blurb quoted on the bookclubs.com page, which the publisher also prints, praises Hannah as "superb at delving into the characters' psyches and delineating nuances of feeling." That is a line the publisher chose to print.

Is Ruby a character worth following?

The reviewers disagree most about the leads. The reviewer at All About Romance found Ruby "a real brat" and thought her transformation, which happens in about a week, too sudden to believe.
The same reviewer found Nora self-involved and questioned why she did not fight harder for her daughter during the years apart.
The Roelia Reads blogger found Ruby's bitterness one-note but said her vulnerability won the blogger over and that Nora grows more likeable too. The Roelia Reads blogger called their relationship messy and uncomfortable but real.
The Review This Reviews blogger read the book as a portrait of difficult mother-daughter relationships, with parents shown as flawed humans who were once someone's child.
A reader review on bookclubs.com called the characters flat. The All About Romance reviewer also found the first-love thread unnatural, saying Ruby and Dean's feelings never faded in eleven years and Dean is barely developed.

How does the writing hold up on the page?

The All About Romance reviewer called Hannah a competent writer whose story flows smoothly and was no chore to read. The same reviewer found her metaphors tedious over time and the book preachy, with a Family-Is-Everything message and characters who psychoanalyse themselves.
Some reviewers praised Hannah's ability to create flawed, emotionally honest characters. The Roelia Reads blogger also called the island setting warm and nostalgic.
The booksnreview.com blogger likewise described the San Juan Islands backdrop as a calm contrast to the characters' emotional turmoil.
The heresmyhart.com blogger found it an enjoyable read from an earlier stage of Hannah's career, before her more history-focused books. The Every Free Chance reviewer noted that Hannah writes about female relationships, and advised against reading her whole library back to back because the ideas start to feel reworked.
One reader review on bookclubs.com said the ending felt rushed. Another said they enjoyed it, "all tied up with a bow".

Is Summer Island worth reading?

Weighing these reviews, the tension is comfort against sentimentality. Readers who liked it describe an emotional, easy-to-read family story with a slow reveal and a cathartic ending.
Those who didn't, including Kirkus Reviews and All About Romance, describe the same ending as syrupy, preachy and too neat.
That points the book towards readers who want a quick, tear-prone story about estrangement, forgiveness and a family secret, set on an island, and who don't mind a tidy resolution. It points away from readers who want unlikable characters made believable, or a reconciliation that costs something.
Several readers who prefer Hannah's later work, such as The Women, also found this earlier novel less accomplished.
All About Romance suggested Good in Bed by Jennifer Weiner for a more realistic take on parental abandonment. The Roelia Reads blogger compared the mood to Hallmark films with more emotional depth.
Some reviewers read Hannah's other books, such as The Nightingale and The Great Alone.

Content notes and who it suits

The sources give no heat level for the romance, and none says how the first-love thread between Ruby and Dean resolves.
Some reviewers thought it suited readers who like family secrets, emotional reckoning and slow-burn forgiveness, and said it would work for a quiet weekend. Readers wanting a heavy, complex Hannah novel may find it lighter than expected, and the All About Romance reviewer warned the book is preachy about family reconciliation.

Sources & Further Reading

The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

  1. 1

    Kristin Hannah, LuvemBooks

  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11

    reviewthisreviews.com

  12. 12

    allaboutromance.com

Age & Reading Level

Our age band

Adult

Our age band groups books for browsing; it isn't an age a review gave.

Content to know about

parental abandonment
a family history of alcoholism
a character dying of cancer

Skip if you want a prickly lead made believable or a reconciliation that costs something rather than a tidy, sentimental ending

From our readers

Reader reviews

Be one of the first readers to answer.

Read it? Was it right for you?

Books like Summer Island

Curated picks for readers who enjoyed Summer Island, with our reasoning for each match.