Skip to content
Reviewed

Read Time

8 min read

Our age bandAdult
Reader rating
4.5 · 23,152 Amazon ratings
reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score
Curated & edited by

LuvemBooks Editorial

How we create our reviews →
Share This Review
Front cover

Our review

Lady of Darkness

Lady of Darkness by Melissa K. Roehrich Review: A Dark, Sprawling Fantasy Romance Series Opener

Lady of Darkness is the first book in Melissa K. Roehrich's series, following Scarlett Monrhoe — an assassin trained since childhood by a ruthless Assassin Lord — into a world of Fae magic, deadly secrets, and an enemies-to-lovers romance. It is a new adult dark fantasy romance that delivers high stakes, a large cast of supernatural factions, and a heroine whose personal mission is upended when children begin vanishing from her home.

Our age band: Adulton-page sex scenes · graphic violence

LuvemBooks Verdict

Best for

Readers already at home in the new adult dark fantasy romance space — particularly fans of possessive-Fae and enemies-to-lovers dynamics — who want a faction-rich, high-stakes opener to a complete six-book series.

Worth it if

Worth reading if you thrive on morally complex heroines, layered supernatural world-building, and slow-burn romantic tension and are happy to invest patience in dense mythology across a long series.

Skip if

Skip it if you prefer tightly focused narratives or restrained romance, as the sheer volume of factions, characters, and frank depictions of violence and possessive relationship dynamics may feel overwhelming rather than immersive.

Where reviewers agree and split

Readers rate it 4.5 on Amazon. The reviews we read that discuss it in depth split on some points:

  • Positive

    Writing The Universe · Book blog: enthusiastic series review with no criticisms (from its headline)

  • Positive

    Laurie Is Reading · Book blog: enjoyed the blind reading experience immensely (from its headline)

  • Negative

    All About Romance · Book blog: despite premise, struggles with execution and originality (from its headline)

  • Mixed

    Smut Report · Book blog: mixed series review with both interest and familiar trope elements (from its headline)

  • Positive

    Lace and Dagger Books · Book blog: enjoyed the book and intends to continue the series (from its headline)

    Overall verdicts are our summary of each review we read, from its headline, rating and conclusion.

    Reader responses have been broadly enthusiastic among the book's target audience: goodeyreads.com awarded a five-star rating and highlighted the novel's genre credentials, while allaboutromance.com offered a more measured view, finding that despite its intriguing premise the book struggles to deliver a fully interesting story and can feel like an attempt to mimic popular romantasy series such as Throne of Glass.

    Sources: goodeyreads.com, allaboutromance.com, writingtheuniverse.com, laceanddaggerbooks.com, sophrilreads.com, smutreport.com
    4.5from 23,152 Amazon ratings— reader ratings, not a LuvemBooks score

    Ask LuvemBooks

    Was this helpful?

    Lady of Darkness is the opening volume of Melissa K. Roehrich's completed six-book dark fantasy romance series, following Scarlett Monrhoe — an assassin raised in captivity — as she races to rescue vanishing children while uncovering a vast conspiracy about Fae magic and power. The series is ideal for readers already at home in the possessive-Fae and enemies-to-lovers subgenres, offering multi-layered political, personal, and supernatural stakes that reward long-form investment. The key caveat: the sheer density of factions, characters, and mythology across 546 pages demands patience, and readers who prefer lighter romance or tightly focused narratives may find the intensity more than they bargained for.
    Is it worth reading?
    For readers already drawn to possessive-Fae and enemies-to-lovers dark fantasy romance, Lady of Darkness delivers on multiple fronts: a complex heroine in Scarlett Monrhoe, genuine stakes across political, personal, and supernatural dimensions, and the security of a completed six-book arc. The fact that the series grew from a self-published debut to a re-issued backlist title — driven by an organically built, devoted fanbase — speaks to its sustained appeal. The significant caveat is density: a world encompassing Fae, Witches, Shifters, and Vampires across 546 pages requires active engagement from the first chapter. Readers outside the dark romance subgenre, or those who find possessiveness and moral ambiguity in relationships off-putting, are less likely to find it a rewarding fit.
    Similar books
    Readers who enjoy Lady of Darkness will likely find kindred reads among several titles curated below. The Book of Azrael by Amber V. Nicole and Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber share the dark, high-stakes romantic tension and morally complex supernatural casts. One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig offers a similarly atmospheric dark fantasy with a heroine hiding dangerous secrets. When the Moon Hatched by Sarah A. Parker delivers comparable world-building ambition and an intense romantic core. Throne of Glass by Sarah J. Maas — though not currently in the LuvemBooks catalogue — is a widely cited comparison for its assassin heroine and faction-rich fantasy world.
    Who should read this?
    Lady of Darkness is squarely aimed at new adult readers who are already enthusiasts of dark fantasy romance — specifically the possessive-Fae and enemies-to-lovers subgenres that have built a strong following in BookTok and indie fantasy communities. Fans of faction-rich fantasy worlds populated by Fae, Witches, Shifters, and Vampires will find the scope appealing. It is also a strong pick for readers who prefer to commit to a series only once it is complete, since all six books are already published. Readers who prefer lighter romantic tension, tightly focused narratives, or minimal moral ambiguity in relationships are likely to find the book's density and intensity a poor fit.
    Is this part of a series?
    Yes — Lady of Darkness is the first book in a completed six-book series by Melissa K. Roehrich. The subsequent volumes are Lady of Shadows, Lady of Ashes, Lady of Embers, Lady of Starfire, and Winds of Darkness, all of which are already published. The series was originally self-published in September 2021 before being reissued by Tractors & Heels LLC in April 2023, a trajectory that reflects an organically built, devoted fanbase. The completed status of the series is noted as a significant advantage for readers who prefer to invest in long-form fantasy without waiting on future releases.
    How is the world-building?
    The world-building in Lady of Darkness is deliberately ambitious in scope — Roehrich constructs a setting that encompasses mortal lands, Fae magic, and a cast of supernatural factions including possessive Fae, Witches, Shifters, and Vampires. A key plot catalyst — the revelation that Fae magic is possible in the mortal lands — sends Scarlett deeper into the darker corners of a world where forgotten secrets are only beginning to surface. The review notes that this scope is purposeful: the first volume is designed to establish the mythology and geography that the subsequent five books will develop further. The trade-off is that the density of factions, named characters, and introduced mythology across 546 pages can be overwhelming for readers new to the series or to faction-rich fantasy.
    How dark is the content?
    Lady of Darkness earns its 'dark fantasy romance' label in full. The book carries publisher-acknowledged content advisories for sexual scenes, violence, and morally complex relationship dynamics — including possessiveness and love-hate tension that Roehrich and her publisher openly flag as central to the reading experience. Scarlett's backstory involves being raised from childhood to torture and kill under the ownership of a ruthless Assassin Lord, and the novel's plot involves children disappearing and a world of deadly secrets. The label 'new adult' signals that the content is aimed at readers who seek intensity over restraint. This level of darkness is a deliberate feature for the target audience, not an oversight.
    Summarize this book

    Summarize this book

    Lady of Darkness introduces Scarlett Monrhoe, who, alongside her two sisters, has been raised from childhood under the ownership of a ruthless Assassin Lord — trained to torture and kill, and regarded as the most feared trio on the continent. When children begin disappearing from Scarlett's home, she is forced to abandon her personal plans and confront a sprawling conspiracy involving Fae magic, Witches, Shifters, and Vampires. A mysterious newcomer whose arrival reshapes everything she thought she knew serves as the central romantic and plot catalyst. The novel is the first of a completed six-book series — followed by Lady of Shadows, Lady of Ashes, Lady of Embers, Lady of Starfire, and Winds of Darkness — giving readers a full arc from the outset.

    Follow up

    What order should I read the series?
    Does it work as a standalone?
    What is the tone like?

    Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

    Ask LuvemBooks

    What would you like to know about Lady of Darkness?

    Answers come from our editorial notes on this book. If we haven't covered something, we'll say so.

    Readers often ask

    Our Review

    We review the evidence: reader verdicts, gathered and weighed with AI assistance and edited by LuvemBooks, rather than one reader's first-hand take.

    A gripping but dense series opener, Lady of Darkness lays ambitious groundwork for a six-book dark fantasy romance saga.

    The Premise: A Killer's Cage and a Disappearing Innocence

    At the centre of Lady of Darkness is Scarlett Monrhoe, who, alongside her two sisters, has been raised from childhood under the ownership of a ruthless Assassin Lord — trained to torture and kill, and widely regarded as the most feared trio on the continent. Despite their fearsome reputation, the sisters exist in a kind of captivity, their freedom conditional and their futures uncertain.
    That already volatile situation is thrown into sharper crisis when children begin disappearing from Scarlett's home, forcing her to abandon her personal plans and race to protect those the world has forgotten. The book's own text captures Scarlett's ethos: "I am someone who has faced the darkness and found the beauty it had to offer. I am someone who can create stars in the void when the light has gone out."
    This dual identity — ruthless instrument and reluctant protector — sits at the heart of the novel's tension.

    World-Building: Fae Magic, Multiple Factions, and Forgotten Secrets

    Roehrich constructs a sprawling world that encompasses mortal lands, Fae magic, and a cast of supernatural factions including possessive Fae, wicked Witches, Shifters, and Vampires. A key plot catalyst arrives in the form of a mysterious newcomer who claims that Fae magic is possible in the mortal lands — a revelation that sends Scarlett deeper into the darkest corners of her world.
    Forgotten secrets surface as the story unfolds, and the darkness, the novel makes clear, extends far beyond Scarlett's own kingdom. The scope is deliberately vast, designed to establish the mythology and geography that the subsequent books in the series will develop further.

    Romance and Genre Dynamics: Enemies-to-Lovers at Its Core

    The book is squarely positioned as a new adult, enemies-to-lovers fantasy romance, and its romantic architecture follows that blueprint closely. Scarlett navigates relationships with old friends, a jilted former lover, and the enigmatic newcomer whose arrival reshapes everything she thought she knew.
    The interpersonal dynamics are charged with love-hate tension, jealousy, and possessiveness — elements Roehrich and her publisher openly flag as central to the reading experience. Content advisories accompany the book for sexual scenes, violence, and morally complex relationship dynamics, signalling that the novel is aimed at readers who seek intensity over restraint in their romantic fiction.
    The genre label "dark fantasy romance" is not incidental; it is the organising principle of every major relationship in the story.
    Lady of Darkness: Lady of Darkness Series, Book 1_main_0

    Strengths: Ambition, Stakes, and Series Architecture

    What Lady of Darkness does with confidence is establish genuine stakes on multiple fronts simultaneously — political, personal, and supernatural. Scarlett's mission to rescue disappearing children runs parallel to a larger conspiracy about the nature of magic and power, keeping the plot from resting on romance alone.
    Some reader responses collected by book review sites have been enthusiastic, with at least one reviewer awarding a five-star rating and praising the novel's blend of fantasy and romance. The book is also the foundation of a completed six-book series — Lady of Shadows, Lady of Ashes, Lady of Embers, Lady of Starfire, and Winds of Darkness follow — meaning readers who commit to Scarlett's story have a full arc waiting for them, a significant advantage for fans of immersive, long-form fantasy series.

    Limitations and Who It's For

    The novel's ambition is also its primary challenge for some readers. A world populated by multiple supernatural factions, a large ensemble of named characters, and a mythology introduced across 546 pages demands patience and active engagement from the outset.
    Readers who prefer tightly focused narratives or slower-burn romance with minimal darkness may find the book's density and its frank depictions of violence and morally fraught relationships more than they bargained for. Lady of Darkness is designed for readers already comfortable in the new adult dark fantasy romance space — particularly those drawn to the possessive-Fae and enemies-to-lovers subgenres that have found a strong readership in the BookTok and indie fantasy communities.
    It was originally self-published in September 2021 before being reissued by Tractors & Heels LLC in April 2023, a trajectory that speaks to an organically built, devoted fanbase rather than a traditionally marketed debut.

    Sources & Further Reading

    The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.

    1. Cited in this review
    2. 1
    3. 2
    4. Further reading
    5. 3
    6. 4
    7. 5
    8. 6
    9. 7
    10. 8
    11. 9
    12. 10
    13. 11

    Age & Reading Level

    Our age band

    Adult

    Our age band groups books for browsing; it isn't an age a review gave.

    Heat level

    Steamy · rated 3/5 spice by readers

    Tropes

    enemies to lovers

    From how readers describe it, not our own reading.

    Content to know about

    on-page sex scenes
    graphic violence
    morally complex and possessive relationship dynamics
    child abduction as plot catalyst
    childhood captivity and coerced violence

    Best for: Adults / mature 17+ — explicit sexual content, graphic violence, and morally complex relationship dynamics including possessiveness and coercive power structures

    Skip if You prefer light or slow-burn romance without possessiveness, moral ambiguity, or intense darkness.

    From our readers

    Reader reviews

    No LuvemBooks readers have answered yet.

    Read it? Was it right for you?

    Books like Lady of Darkness

    Curated picks for readers who enjoyed Lady of Darkness, with our reasoning for each match.

    Discussion

    Reader comments