3 min read
4.7
· 742 Amazon ratingsShare This Review
The Amazing Generation by Jonathan Haidt and Catherine Price Review: A Smart Tween Guide to Screen Freedom
The Amazing Generation is a practical handbook for tweens aged 9–12, co-authored by social psychologist Jonathan Haidt and health journalist Catherine Price, designed to help young readers reclaim friendship, freedom, and fun from the pull of smartphone addiction — and reviewed here on the basis of its content and published critical reception, not hands-on use.
LuvemBooks Verdict
Best for
Tweens in grades 4–7 who are already feeling uneasy about their screen habits, and families looking for a shared, research-grounded starting point for honest conversations about smartphones and social media.
Worth it if
The young reader (or the adult reading alongside them) is genuinely open to reflecting on their relationship with devices and willing to engage actively with the book's practical strategies — not just read it passively.
Skip if
Older teenagers already deep into social-media culture, or children younger than the 9–12 target range, are likely to find the tone and pitch a less precise fit for where they actually are.
What readers & critics say
Kirkus awarded the book a starred review, calling it "a persuasive argument for disillusioned smartphone users" and singling out its "upbeat, encouraging approach" and "kid-friendly strategies" as what makes it stand out (kirkusreviews.com). School critical coverage echoed that verdict, labelling it "a fresh, motivating guide recommended for students and educators who want to encourage independence, curiosity, and real-world adventures" (slj.com). ParentMap praised Haidt and Price for not shying away from placing responsibility squarely on tech companies and the "greedy wizards" who run them, calling that frankness refreshing (parentmap.com). Slate tested the book with actual tween readers and found the most persuasive argument was the idea that apps are built by people who profit from grabbing their attention — though the "wizards" framing struck the adult reviewer as a little hokey (slate.com).
“The winning argument for tween test-readers was the idea that apps are created by people who make money from grabbing their attention — though the 'wizards' framing struck me as a little hokey.”
— SlateIn This Review
- What Works & What Doesn't
- What the Book Is and Where It Comes From
- The Core Argument and What It Covers
- Critical Reception and Standout Strengths
- The Authors' Credibility and the Book's Broader Significance
- Who This Book Is For — and One Genuine Limitation
What Works & What Doesn't
What Works
- Grew out of Jonathan Haidt's widely discussed The Anxious Generation (2024), giving the advice a well-documented research foundation
- Kirkus awarded it a starred review, praising its 'upbeat, encouraging approach' and kid-friendly strategies
- Oprah Daily calls it an 'eye-roll–proof script for calmer boundaries and fewer power struggles,' pointing to practical family usefulness
- The Boston Globe highlights it as readable for both tweens and parents, giving it genuine cross-audience reach
- Co-author Catherine Price, founder of Screen/Life Balance and author of How to Break Up with Your Phone, adds focused practical expertise in digital wellness
What Doesn't
- Tightly calibrated to the 9–12 / grades 4–7 range, so older teenagers or younger children may find it a less precise fit
- As a how-to handbook, its real value depends entirely on how the individual reader engages with and applies its strategies — something no review can test in advance

What the Book Is and Where It Comes From
The Core Argument and What It Covers
Critical Reception and Standout Strengths
The Authors' Credibility and the Book's Broader Significance
Who This Book Is For — and One Genuine Limitation
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources & Further Reading
The key facts and claims in this review are grounded in the retrieved, verified sources listed below.
- Cited in this review
- 1
kirkusreviews.com
- 2
- 3
- Further reading
- 4
anxiousgeneration.com
- 5
theamazinggenerationbook.com
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
Reader Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!