Skip to content
Stephanie Garber, author portrait
Photo:Rhododendrites·CC BY-SA 4.0·
Commons

Stephanie Garber

American
Stephanie Garber is an American author of young adult fiction. She is known for two connected parts of that work: the Caraval books and the Once Upon a Broken Heart books. The connection matters because the later books are not a separate project; they grow out of the same setting and should be read as linked to Caraval rather than apart from it.
The Once Upon a Broken Heart titles are Once Upon a Broken Heart, The Ballad of Never After, and The Mirror of Infinite Endings. Caraval remains the earlier strand, while these three books carry the story world forward under the Once Upon a Broken Heart name. The safest description is bibliographic: name the books, note the link, and avoid assigning the group a fixed size or endpoint.
On LuvemBooks, we've reviewed 3 of Stephanie Garber's books, including The Ballad of Never After, The Mirror of Infinite Endings, and Once Upon a Broken Heart.
3
Books Reviewed

In Stephanie Garber's own words

Author Stephanie Garber introduces Once Upon a Broken Heart and discusses its fairy-tale world in an interview with Forbidden Planet TV.

Uploaded by Forbidden Planet TV, 2022 · Watch on YouTube ·

Guerilla book signing at Forbidden Planet

Garber recalls visiting London's Forbidden Planet store and secretly signing copies of her book straight off the display shelf without informing the staff.

The Great Gatsby inspired her aesthetic

After writing a bleak, unpublished space opera, Garber watched Baz Luhrmann's The Great Gatsby and decided she wanted to create vibrant, magical, and colorful worlds instead.

Creating an old-world fairy tale atmosphere

Garber explains that while Caraval felt like a carnival, she designed this setting to feel like stepping into an old-world fairy tale filled with subtle magic like tiny shoulder-perching dragons.

Drafting the sequel to Broken Heart

Garber reveals that the manuscript for the sequel is already written and undergoing edits, having mapped out the story arc while writing the first installment.

Also in this interview
In order

Stephanie Garber books in order

2 books; 2 reviewed on LuvemBooks. Dates and covers from Amazon.

  1. The Ballad of Never After cover
    2022
    Our review →
  2. The Mirror of Infinite Endings cover
    2025
    Our review →
Cover of The Ballad of Never After
The Ballad of Never After

4.6/5

reader rating · 33,702 ratings

The Ballad of Never After is the #1 New York Times bestselling second installment in Stephanie Garber's Once Upon a Broken Heart series, continuing the story of Evangeline Fox and the enigmatic Jacks, the Prince of Hearts, across a world of magic, mystery, and fractured trust.

Reviewed Aug 12, 2026

Cover of The Mirror of Infinite Endings: A Once Upon a Broken Heart Companion
The Mirror of Infinite Endings: A Once Upon a Broken Heart Companion

4.4/5

reader rating · 1,430 ratings

The Mirror of Infinite Endings is a companion novella to Stephanie Garber's #1 New York Times bestselling Once Upon a Broken Heart series, returning readers to the Magnificent North for a new tale of Jacks and Evangeline Fox — with more than twenty full-page illustrations by Lotusbubble. It is designed squarely for fans already invested in the series, and earns attention as an illustrated, story-forward addition to a beloved YA fantasy romance world.

Reviewed Oct 11, 2026

Cover of Once Upon a Broken Heart
Once Upon a Broken Heart

4.2/5

reader rating · 35,187 ratings

Once Upon a Broken Heart is the first novel in Stephanie Garber's #1 New York Times bestselling series of the same name, published by Flatiron Books on September 28, 2021. It follows Evangeline Fox, a true believer in love and happy endings, who strikes a perilous bargain with the wicked Prince of Hearts — trading three kisses for his help stopping her beloved's wedding — only to discover that dealing with an immortal Fate carries consequences far darker than she imagined. Kirkus Reviews calls it "a lushly written story with an intriguing heart," and reviewers praise Garber's "exquisitely imagined worldbuilding and her trademark heady romance," though Kirkus also notes that the fantasy world-building is unevenly developed and the writing can veer into the verbose. The series opener is designed to be accessible to readers new to Garber's Caraval universe while expanding it in significant new directions.

Reviewed Apr 9, 2026

Ask LuvemBooks about Stephanie Garber

Stephanie Garber is an American young adult author best known for Caraval, and we've reviewed three of their books, all rooted in the Once Upon a Broken Heart world. Across those reviews, a clear pattern emerges: Garber builds romantic fantasy around dangerous bargains and fairy-tale logic, as in Once Upon a Broken Heart, where Evangeline Fox trades three kisses to the Prince of Hearts to stop her beloved's wedding. Readers on Amazon have responded strongly, with The Ballad of Never After holding a 4.6/5 reader rating from over 33,000 ratings.
Where should I start?
Start with Once Upon a Broken Heart, the first novel in the series. It introduces Evangeline Fox and her fateful bargain with Jacks, the Prince of Hearts, which sets up everything that follows in the books we've reviewed. It holds a 4.2/5 reader rating from over 35,000 Amazon ratings.
What's their writing style?
Based on the books we've reviewed, Garber writes romantic fantasy built on fairy-tale mechanics: bargains with dangerous magical figures, fractured trust, and a heroine who believes in happy endings colliding with a world that keeps breaking them. Their stories center on the push and pull between Evangeline Fox and the enigmatic Jacks, mixing magic and mystery in the Magnificent North. The Mirror of Infinite Endings also shows a fondness for lush presentation, with more than twenty full-page illustrations by Lotusbubble.
Books we've reviewed
We've reviewed three Stephanie Garber books. Once Upon a Broken Heart launches the series with Evangeline's three-kiss bargain with the Prince of Hearts (4.2/5 reader rating from 35,187 Amazon ratings). The Ballad of Never After continues Evangeline and Jacks' story and is the strongest rated of the three at 4.6/5 from 33,702 ratings. The Mirror of Infinite Endings is an illustrated companion novella aimed at existing fans, with a 4.4/5 reader rating from 1,430 ratings.
How do their books compare?
The two main novels form a continuous story: Once Upon a Broken Heart sets up Evangeline's bargain with Jacks, and The Ballad of Never After picks up the threads of magic, mystery, and fractured trust that follow. The sequel edges ahead in reader ratings — 4.6/5 versus 4.2/5 on Amazon — while reaching a similarly huge audience. The Mirror of Infinite Endings stands apart as a shorter, illustrated companion piece rather than a full novel, and it's best approached as a bonus for established fans.
Why is Once Upon a Broken Heart trending?
Once Upon a Broken Heart is currently trending on BookTok, where its mix of romantic fantasy and fairy-tale stakes has found a large, enthusiastic audience. The buzz is backed by numbers: the book holds a 4.2/5 reader rating from 35,187 Amazon ratings. Its premise — a believer in happy endings bargaining three kisses with the wicked Prince of Hearts — is exactly the kind of hook that spreads quickly on the platform.
What genre do they write?
Stephanie Garber writes young adult fiction, and the books we've reviewed fall into young adult and fantasy territory. Their Once Upon a Broken Heart books blend magical worlds — the Magnificent North, the Prince of Hearts — with central romantic storylines. If you like YA fantasy with fairy-tale elements and high romantic stakes, that's their lane.
What should I read after Once Upon a Broken Heart?
The natural next step is The Ballad of Never After, the second installment, which continues Evangeline and Jacks' story across a world of magic, mystery, and fractured trust — and holds a 4.6/5 reader rating from 33,702 Amazon ratings. After that, The Mirror of Infinite Endings offers a shorter, illustrated return to the Magnificent North for readers who want more time with these characters. That covers all three Garber books we've reviewed.
Who is Stephanie Garber?

Who is Stephanie Garber?

Stephanie Garber is an American author of young adult fiction, best known for the novel Caraval. On LuvemBooks, we've reviewed three of their books, all connected to the Once Upon a Broken Heart series, which has become a #1 New York Times bestseller. Their work blends fantasy and romance in a world called the Magnificent North.

Follow up

What is the Once Upon a Broken Heart series about?
How popular are Stephanie Garber's books?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

​

Press Enter to ask. Answers come from our editorial Q&A — start typing to see related questions.

Authors Like Stephanie Garber
Holly Black

Holly Black

Young Adult
Fiction
Fantasy
Holly Black's The Cruel Prince features a similarly lush, treacherous magical world and a romance built on distrust, framed by sharper political edges.
2 books reviewed
The Wicked King
The Cruel Prince
K

Kerri Maniscalco

Young Adult
Fiction
Fantasy

Kerri Maniscalco is the #1 New York Times and international bestselling author born and raised in the Hudson Valley of New York, who grew up in a semi-haunted house outside NYC. She is known for the gothic thriller Stalking Jack the Ripper quartet, the Kingdom of the Wicked fantasy romance trilogy, and her adult fantasy romance Prince of Sin series. She was raised to love reading by parents who took her to libraries and bookstores every weekend.

1 book reviewed
Kingdom of the Feared (Kingdom of the Wicked)
Rachel Gillig

Rachel Gillig

Fiction
Fantasy
Rachel Gillig’s One Dark Window delivers gothic romantic fantasy filled with slow-burn dread and dangerous bargains where deals with sinister entities cost more than promised.
2 books reviewed
Two Twisted Crowns
One Dark Window
V

V. E. Schwab

Fantasy
Fiction
V. E. Schwab's The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue also features a coercive bargain with a dark, morally ambiguous immortal, exploring the theme at its most devastating.
1 book reviewed
The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue
Amber V. Nicole

Amber V. Nicole

Fiction
Romance
Fantasy
Amber V. Nicole’s The Book of Azrael channels sharp romantic tension with dangerous immortals, adding a darker fantasy edge through morally gray characters and horror elements.
2 books reviewed
The Book of Azrael
The Throne of Broken Gods
Leigh Bardugo

Leigh Bardugo

Young Adult
Fiction
Fantasy

Leigh Bardugo is an Israeli-American author of young adult and fantasy fiction.

4 books reviewed
Crooked Kingdom: A Sequel to Six of Crows
Six of Crows
Ninth House