Skip to content
Rachel Gillig, author portrait
Photo:Joe Peacock·CC BY-SA 4.0·
Commons

Rachel Gillig

American
Born 1989
Rachel Gillig is an American gothic romantic fantasy author. She is known for her duologies The Shepherd King and Stonewater Kingdom.
On LuvemBooks, we've reviewed 2 of Rachel Gillig's books, including Two Twisted Crowns and One Dark Window.
2
Books Reviewed

In Rachel Gillig's own words

Rachel Gillig discusses her debut novel One Dark Window with UpperPen Podcast host Dakota, exploring its gothic tone, magic system, and characters.

Uploaded by UpperPen, 2023 · Watch on YouTube ·

The Nightmare as the Series Protagonist

Gillig considers the entire duology to fundamentally belong to the Nightmare rather than Elspeth, noting that he operates as a quiet puppet master pulling strings throughout the narrative.

Elm and Ione in Book Two

Gillig reveals that side characters who have constrained roles in the first book, specifically Elm and Ione, receive significant focus and development in the sequel.

Also in this interview

Rachel Gillig's books in reading order

Tap a book for what it's about. Each series links to its full reading order. Browse all series →

The Shepherd King

The Shepherd King in order →

Ask LuvemBooks about Rachel Gillig

Rachel Gillig is an American gothic romantic fantasy author, and we've reviewed both books of their Shepherd King duology. Gillig's signature is a mist-locked kingdom where magic is a death sentence — in One Dark Window, debut heroine Elspeth Spindle shares her mind with a five-hundred-year-old spirit called Nightmare, a premise reviewers praised for its evocative prose and magic system. The follow-up, Two Twisted Crowns, carries a 4.6/5 reader rating from over 110,000 Amazon ratings, making it the higher-rated of the two.
Where should I start?
Start with One Dark Window. It's Rachel Gillig's debut and the first Shepherd King book, introducing Elspeth Spindle, the Nightmare spirit, and the mist-locked kingdom where magic is a death sentence — all essential groundwork for the sequel. Two Twisted Crowns is the concluding volume of the duology and picks up directly from there, so reading order matters here.
What's their writing style?
Rachel Gillig writes gothic romantic fantasy with a strongly atmospheric bent — mist-cloaked forests and a kingdom where using magic can get you killed. Reviewers of One Dark Window singled out the evocative prose and the magic system built around the Providence Cards, even as critical attention was mixed-but-engaged overall. The voice leans dark and eerie, anchored by Elspeth's uneasy coexistence with the Nightmare spirit inside her head.
Books we've reviewed
We've reviewed 2 Rachel Gillig books, both from the Shepherd King duology. One Dark Window (4.5/5 reader rating from 101,260 Amazon ratings) is the 2022 debut that launched the series and its BookTok following. Two Twisted Crowns (4.6/5 from 110,170 Amazon ratings) is the concluding volume and an instant New York Times and USA Today bestseller.
How do the two books compare?
One Dark Window is the scene-setter: it introduces Elspeth Spindle, the Nightmare, and the rules of a kingdom where magic is a death sentence, earning praise for its prose and magic system alongside mixed-but-engaged critical attention. Two Twisted Crowns shifts into a race-against-the-clock structure, with Elspeth and Ravyn hunting the final Providence Card before Solstice, guided by the Nightmare. Readers rated the sequel slightly higher — 4.6/5 versus 4.5/5 on Amazon — suggesting the payoff landed well.
What genre do they write?
Rachel Gillig writes gothic romantic fantasy — often shortened to 'gothic romantasy.' Their reviewed books combine a dark, mist-shrouded fantasy setting and a card-based magic system with a central romance, as seen in Elspeth and Ravyn's storyline across the Shepherd King books.
What should I read after Two Twisted Crowns?
Two Twisted Crowns is the concluding volume of the Shepherd King duology, so within Rachel Gillig's work as we've covered it, that's the end of the road — we've reviewed both books. If you finished the duology and want more of the same flavor, look for other gothic romantasy titles with atmospheric settings and romance-driven plots. We'll add more Gillig reviews to LuvemBooks if we cover further books.
Who is Rachel Gillig?

Who is Rachel Gillig?

Rachel Gillig is an American author of gothic romantic fantasy. Their debut, One Dark Window, was published by Orbit Books in 2022 and built a devoted BookTok following with its story of Elspeth Spindle and the ancient spirit sharing her mind. Its sequel, Two Twisted Crowns, became an instant New York Times and USA Today bestseller.

Follow up

What is the Shepherd King duology?
How popular are Rachel Gillig's books?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

​

Press Enter to ask. Answers come from our editorial Q&A — start typing to see related questions.