The Nightmare as the Series Protagonist
Gillig considers the entire duology to fundamentally belong to the Nightmare rather than Elspeth, noting that he operates as a quiet puppet master pulling strings throughout the narrative.
Rachel Gillig discusses her debut novel One Dark Window with UpperPen Podcast host Dakota, exploring its gothic tone, magic system, and characters.
Uploaded by UpperPen, 2023 · Watch on YouTube ·
Gillig considers the entire duology to fundamentally belong to the Nightmare rather than Elspeth, noting that he operates as a quiet puppet master pulling strings throughout the narrative.
Gillig reveals that side characters who have constrained roles in the first book, specifically Elm and Ione, receive significant focus and development in the sequel.
Tap a book for what it's about. Each series links to its full reading order. Browse all series →
Elspeth Spindle hides a secret in a mist-locked kingdom where magic means death. Touching a forbidden Providence Card let a five-hundred-year-old spirit called Nightmare into her mind. When a highwayman attacks her uncle's carriage, she and the mysterious Ravyn Yew must gather all twelve cards before the solstice to cure their kingdom's dark magic.
Read our review →Elspeth and Ravyn journey into a mist-shrouded woodland to locate the last Providence Card before Solstice. The monster inside Elspeth's mind, the Nightmare, serves as their guide through the perilous trees, but he grows unwilling to remain merely a voice in her head.
Read our review →
4.6/5
reader rating · 110,170 ratingsTwo Twisted Crowns is the concluding volume of Rachel Gillig's Shepherd King duology, following Elspeth and Ravyn as they race through a mist-cloaked forest to find the final Providence Card before Solstice — with the Nightmare, the monster sharing Elspeth's mind, as their only guide. An instant New York Times and USA Today bestseller, according to Hachette, it delivers a widely praised payoff to one of gothic romantasy's most distinctive recent series.
Reviewed Aug 1, 2026

4.5/5
reader rating · 101,260 ratingsRachel Gillig's debut gothic romantic fantasy, originally published by Orbit Books in 2022, introduces Elspeth Spindle and a five-hundred-year-old spirit called Nightmare in a mist-locked kingdom where magic is a death sentence — a premise that earned the novel a devoted BookTok following and mixed-but-engaged critical attention, with reviewers praising its evocative prose and magic system while flagging uneven pacing and a predictable romantic subplot.
Reviewed Apr 9, 2026
Who is Rachel Gillig?
Follow up
Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review
Press Enter to ask. Answers come from our editorial Q&A — start typing to see related questions.
Leigh Bardugo



Sarah A. Parker


Stephanie Garber



Amber V. Nicole


V. E. Schwab

Sarah J. Maas
Sarah Janet Maas is an American fantasy author associated with three series: Throne of Glass, A Court of Thorns and Roses, and Crescent City.
4 books reviewed

