Andrea Catalano
1
Books ReviewedAndrea Catalano books in order
1 books; 1 reviewed on LuvemBooks. Dates and covers from Amazon.
2025Our review →
Ask LuvemBooks about Andrea Catalano
- Where should I start?
- Start with The First Witch of Boston — it's Catalano's debut and the only book we've reviewed. The novel tells the true story of Margaret Jones through her journals and her husband Thomas's memories, and it carries a 4.3/5 reader rating from 36,134 Amazon ratings. Be aware that its themes are heavy, so it suits readers comfortable with somber historical material.
- What's their writing style?
- Catalano writes archival historical fiction: The First Witch of Boston is constructed from real diaries and court records, then dramatized through Margaret Jones's discovered journals and her husband Thomas's memories. That dual structure lets her blend a witch-trial drama with a decades-spanning love story. The tone leans toward the somber — the historical record drives the story rather than being softened by it.
- Books we've reviewed
- We've reviewed 1 Andrea Catalano book: The First Witch of Boston (Lake Union, 2025), which reconstructs the true 1648 case of Margaret Jones through her journals and her husband's memories — equal parts love story and witch-trial drama, with heavy themes. It holds a 4.3/5 reader rating from 36,134 Amazon ratings.
- What genre do they write?
- Andrea Catalano writes historical fiction, specifically fiction rooted in real archival sources. The First Witch of Boston dramatizes the actual 1648 witchcraft case of Margaret Jones using diaries and court records, blending the historical record with a love-story narrative.
- Is The First Witch of Boston based on a true story?
- Yes. Margaret Jones was the first woman executed for witchcraft in Boston, in 1648, and Catalano reconstructs her case from actual diaries and court records. The novel imagines her inner life through discovered journals while her husband Thomas's memories carry their decades-long relationship.
- What should I read after The First Witch of Boston?
- The natural next step is Catalano's forthcoming second novel, The Lacemaker's Fortune, also from Lake Union Publishing. We haven't reviewed it yet, so for now The First Witch of Boston remains the only Catalano book on the site — a good moment to reread its journal-and-memory structure with the historical record in mind.
Who is Andrea Catalano?
Follow up
Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review
Press Enter to ask. Answers come from our editorial Q&A — start typing to see related questions.
Authors Like Andrea Catalano
Elizabeth George Speare
Elizabeth George Speare was an American writer of children's historical fiction, including two Newbery Medal winners, recognizing the year's "most distinguished contribution to American literature for children".
1 book reviewed
Kiran Millwood Hargrave
Kiran Millwood Hargrave is the author of "The Deathless Girls," a young adult novel that reimagines the Dracula mythos through the perspective of the vampire women in Bram Stoker's original tale. The book blends gothic atmosphere with feminist themes, off
1 book reviewed
Brenda Davies
Jeff Carson
Jeff Carson is the Amazon-bestselling author of the mystery-thriller David Wolf Series and Ali Falco Series. He lives in Colorado with his wife and two sons. His wife is from Italy, and he has spent time traveling between Italy and the United States. His David Wolf books are set in the high country of Colorado and the mountain west.
2 books reviewed
Laura Vogt
Laura Vogt studied literature, history, and attended the University of Iowa Writers' Workshop. She is the author of the debut novel *In the Great Quiet* (Lake Union), which reached 55,000 readers in its first four months and was an Amazon First Reads Editors' Pick. She has also written works originally in German, including *So einfach war es also zu gehen* (2016) and *Was uns betrifft* (2022).
1 book reviewed
Amanda Skenandore
Amanda Skenandore is an award-winning author of historical fiction and a registered nurse. Her novels, which have been translated into multiple languages, include Between Earth and Sky—winner of the American Library Association's Reading List Award for Best Historical Fiction—The Undertaker's Assistant, The Second Life of Mirielle West, The Nurse's Secret, and The Medicine Woman of Galveston. Her work has been recognized by organizations including Reader's Digest and Silicon Valley Reads.
1 book reviewed