BOOKS
Published
Read Time
2 min read
Our Rating
4
Reviewed by
LuvemBooks
Share This Review
Great American Short Stories by Paul Negri Review: Dover Thrift Edition
Our Rating
4
A remarkably affordable and well-curated anthology of canonical American short fiction, held back only by the absence of editorial context or introductory notes — essential reading for literature lovers, but best used alongside supplementary resources.
In This Review
- What Works & What Doesn't
- An Embarrassment of Riches From American Literature
- Where to Buy
What Works & What Doesn't
What Works
- Extraordinary value — a large selection of canonical authors in a single affordable volume
- Genuinely broad tonal and stylistic range across a full century of American fiction
- Exposes readers to contrasting prose styles, making the evolution of American literature tangible
- Portable Dover Thrift format ideal for travel, commutes, or casual reading
- Strong curation choices that represent the breadth of the tradition rather than only the most familiar titles
What Doesn't
- No editorial apparatus — no introductions, contextual notes, or biographical sketches for individual authors
- Cover and physical design are functional but aesthetically modest
- Advanced prose styles (James, Hawthorne, Melville) may frustrate less experienced readers without guidance
- Scholars and serious students will outgrow it quickly and need richer scholarly editions
An Embarrassment of Riches From American Literature
Is this Dover Thrift edition worth reading? The rare anthology that earns its keep through curation, not bulk — canonical selections chosen to reward both casual readers and returning ones. For the price, it may be one of the best-value literary purchases available. Edited by Paul Negri, this anthology gathers short fiction from writers who collectively define the American literary tradition. Names like Edgar Allan Poe, Nathaniel Hawthorne, Ernest Hemingway, Willa Cather, Henry James, Herman Melville, Jack London, and Stephen Crane appear in a compact, richly layered collection that functions simultaneously as a survey course and a reading pleasure.
For readers familiar with similar anthologies, Paul Negri's selection distinguishes itself through its affordability and portability. Where multi-volume academic anthologies run to thousands of pages, this Dover Thrift Editions volume is genuinely compact in both form and price. That accessibility is part of its argument. Negri has made deliberate editorial choices here — favoring canonical works that reward both first-time and returning readers. The result succeeds admirably as an introduction to classic American short fiction.
Where to Buy
If you want a single compact volume that puts the essential American short story tradition in your pocket for under ten dollars, this is the one to reach for — the Amazon link in the sidebar has the current price.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is this Dover Thrift edition of Great American Short Stories worth reading?
According to the review, for the price it may be one of the best-value literary purchases available. The reviewer describes it as a compact, richly layered collection that functions simultaneously as a survey course and a reading pleasure.
Is this anthology worth buying at the $4.93 price point?
The reviewer strongly suggests yes, emphasizing that the affordability is part of the collection's core argument. The low price combined with the breadth of canonical authors makes it stand out as exceptional value.
Who edited this anthology and what editorial choices did they make?
The anthology was edited by Paul Negri, who favored canonical works that reward both first-time and returning readers. The reviewer notes that Negri made deliberate editorial choices aimed at broad accessibility.
Which authors are included in this collection?
The collection includes Edgar Allan Poe, Nathaniel Hawthorne, Ernest Hemingway, F. Scott Fitzgerald, Mark Twain, Willa Cather, Henry James, Ambrose Bierce, Herman Melville, Jack London, and Stephen Crane, among others. The reviewer notes these writers collectively define the American literary tradition.
Who is the target audience for this anthology?
The reviewer suggests it works well for both first-time readers new to American short fiction and returning readers already familiar with the tradition. As a Paul Negri book aimed at broad accessibility, it succeeds as an introduction to classic American short fiction.
How does this Dover Thrift edition compare to academic anthologies?
The reviewer contrasts it favorably against multi-volume academic anthologies that run to thousands of pages, noting that this volume is genuinely compact in both form and price. That compactness and portability are presented as distinguishing advantages.
Is this a good introduction to American short fiction for newcomers?
The reviewer says yes, describing the collection as succeeding admirably as an introduction to classic American short fiction. The editorial choices favor canonical works that are accessible to readers coming to these authors for the first time.
Can returning readers who already know these authors enjoy this collection?
Yes, the reviewer specifically notes that Paul Negri's selections reward both first-time and returning readers. The richly layered quality of the collection means it holds value even for those already familiar with American literary tradition.
How does this anthology function structurally as a reading experience?
The reviewer describes it as functioning simultaneously as a survey course and a reading pleasure, suggesting it works both as an educational overview and as an enjoyable read in its own right. This dual function is presented as one of the collection's key strengths.
What does the reviewer mean by calling it an embarrassment of riches?
The phrase refers to the density of major American literary names gathered in one compact, affordable volume. Writers like Poe, Hawthorne, Hemingway, Fitzgerald, and Twain appearing alongside Cather, James, Bierce, Melville, London, and Crane represents an unusually rich concentration of talent for the price.
Is the collection portable and practical to carry around?
The reviewer specifically highlights portability as a distinguishing feature of this Dover Thrift edition compared to larger academic anthologies. Its compact form is presented as part of what makes it an appealing purchase.
Does the anthology focus on canonical or lesser-known works?
According to the review, Paul Negri favored canonical works in his editorial selections. The reviewer presents this as a deliberate and successful choice rather than a limitation.
What rating did the reviewer give this anthology?
The reviewer awarded this anthology a 4 out of 5 stars, reflecting a strongly positive overall assessment. The rating aligns with the review's consistent praise for the collection's value, breadth, and editorial quality.
How does Paul Negri's selection distinguish itself from similar anthologies?
The reviewer says Negri's selection distinguishes itself primarily through its affordability and portability compared to similar anthologies. These practical qualities, combined with strong editorial choices, set it apart in a crowded field.
Does the anthology succeed at what it sets out to do?
The reviewer concludes that as a book aimed at broad accessibility, it succeeds admirably as an introduction to classic American short fiction. The combination of canonical selections, compact format, and low price all work together effectively toward that goal.
BEST DEAL
Related Reviews
Reviews of books we picked for readers who enjoyed Great American Short Stories.
Reader Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!