Skip to content
Alexander McCall Smith, author portrait
Photo:TimDuncan·CC BY-SA 4.0·
Commons

Alexander McCall Smith

British
Born 1948
Sir Alexander "Sandy" McCall Smith is a Rhodesian/Zimbabwean-Scottish legal scholar and author of fiction. He was born and raised in Southern Rhodesia and later became Professor of Medical Law at the University of Edinburgh, a post he no longer holds. The legal career came first. His academic work centered on medical law and bioethics, and he served on related British and international committees before fiction became his main public identity.
He is known as the creator of the No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series. By 2010 his books had sold more than 40 million copies in English, with translations into 46 languages. He is generally identified by that series rather than by his legal career. His books include The Big Cats Dance Party and The Great Hippopotamus Hotel.
On LuvemBooks, we've reviewed 2 of Alexander McCall Smith's books, including The Big Cats Dance Party and The Great Hippopotamus Hotel.
2
Books Reviewed

Ask LuvemBooks about Alexander McCall Smith

Alexander McCall Smith is best known for the No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series, and the two books we've reviewed show a consistent approach: gentle, character-driven cozy mysteries set in Botswana that prioritize warmth and serenity over tension. In The Great Hippopotamus Hotel, for instance, Mma Ramotswe and Mma Makutsi investigate a string of mishaps at a local hotel in a story that rewards patient readers rather than those seeking a fast-paced whodunit. Both reviewed titles hold strong reader ratings on Amazon — 4.6/5 and 4.7/5 respectively.
Where should I start?
The Great Hippopotamus Hotel is a good entry point: it follows Mma Ramotswe and Mma Makutsi investigating a string of mishaps at a Botswana hotel, and its serene, character-focused storytelling shows exactly what the series offers. It holds a 4.6/5 reader rating from over 4,600 Amazon ratings. Just know that this is a slow, gentle mystery rather than a fast-paced whodunit.
What's their writing style?
Across the two books we've reviewed, Alexander McCall Smith writes gentle, character-driven cozy mysteries with a serene Botswana setting. Their pacing is deliberately unhurried — warmth and familiar characters take priority over plot tension or twists. Readers who enjoy quiet, comforting mysteries will feel at home; those wanting suspense may find the stories too mild.
Books we've reviewed
We've reviewed 2 Alexander McCall Smith books, both from the No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series. The Great Hippopotamus Hotel (4.6/5 reader rating) sends Mma Ramotswe and Mma Makutsi to investigate mishaps at a Botswana hotel — serene and gentle, but slow for whodunit fans. The Big Cats Dance Party (4.7/5 reader rating), the 27th installment, pairs an elephant sanctuary investigation with a suspicious car wash subplot and mostly rewards long-time fans.
How do their books compare?
Both reviewed titles are gentle, character-driven cozy mysteries, but they differ in who they suit. The Great Hippopotamus Hotel offers a serene hotel-set investigation that works well for patient readers, including newcomers. The Big Cats Dance Party, the series' 27th installment, leans more on established warmth and rewards long-time fans, though its predictability may underwhelm first-time readers.
What genre do they write?
Both books we've reviewed by Alexander McCall Smith fall into the Cozy Mystery genre. Their mysteries are low on violence and tension, instead emphasizing gentle pacing, warmth, and recurring characters in a Botswana setting.
What should I read after The Great Hippopotamus Hotel?
The natural next step is The Big Cats Dance Party, the other No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency book we've reviewed. It follows Precious Ramotswe investigating a tarnished elephant sanctuary while Charlie runs a suspiciously profitable car wash. It holds a 4.7/5 reader rating and delivers the same warmth, though it's most rewarding for readers already fond of the characters.
Who is Alexander McCall Smith?

Who is Alexander McCall Smith?

Sir Alexander "Sandy" McCall Smith is a Rhodesian/Zimbabwean-Scottish legal scholar and fiction author. They are best known for The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series, and their books hold an average reader rating of 4.6/5 on Amazon.

Follow up

What is the No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency about?
How many Alexander McCall Smith books has LuvemBooks reviewed?

Synthesized from verified book data & published reviews · How we review

​

Press Enter to ask. Answers come from our editorial Q&A — start typing to see related questions.

Authors Like Alexander McCall Smith
Richard Osman

Richard Osman

Cozy Mystery

Richard Thomas Osman is an English television presenter, producer, and novelist.

4 books reviewed
The Last Devil to Die: A Thursday Murder Club Mystery
The Man Who Died Twice
The Bullet That Missed
C

Carolyn L. Dean

Cozy Mystery

Carolyn L. Dean is a USA Today bestselling author best known for her cozy mystery fiction. She has been writing stories since childhood and is the creator of the Ravenwood Cove cozy mystery series, whose first book launched in July 2016 and reached #1 among free books on Amazon. Her stated goal is to create worlds and characters that inspire, challenge, and entertain readers.

1 book reviewed
Bed, Breakfast, and Bones: A Ravenwood Cove Cozy Mystery
F

Fiona Grace

Cozy Mystery

Fiona Grace is an author of cozy mystery and romance fiction. Her debut series is the Lacey Doyle Cozy Mystery series, beginning with Murder in the Manor, and she has also written the Tuscan Vineyard, Dubious Witch, and Beachfront Bakery cozy mystery series.

1 book reviewed
Murder in the Manor
C

Clare Chase

Cozy Mystery

Clare Chase writes classic mysteries, as well as romantic suspense and women sleuth mysteries, often set in London and Cambridge. Brought up in the Midlands, she read English at London University and worked in book and author promotion in venues including schools, pubs and prisons.

1 book reviewed
Mystery on Hidden Lane
E

Ellery Adams

Cozy Mystery

Ellery Adams is a New York Times and USA Today bestselling mystery author, known for the Books by the Bay, Charmed Pie Shoppe, and Book Retreat mysteries. She grew up on a beach near the Long Island Sound and has held jobs including caterer, teacher, and tech writer. She lives in North Carolina.

1 book reviewed
Murder in the Mystery Suite
Louise Penny

Louise Penny

Louise Penny, is a Canadian crime-fiction author, best known for her Chief Inspector Armand Gamache series set in Quebec.

2 books reviewed
A World of Curiosities
The Madness of Crowds