Frankopan delivers a thoroughly researched challenge to Western-centric history that succeeds despite dense prose and uneven pacing, offering valuable insights for serious history readers.
What works
• Challenges Western-centric historical narratives by placing trade networks and connectivity at the center of world development
• Demonstrates extensive archival research and weaves together economic, political, and cultural threads across vast distances and time periods
• Effectively illustrates interconnectedness by jumping between regions and time periods to show how distant developments influenced each other
• Focuses on lesser-known but crucial facilitators like Mongols, Persian and Arab leaders, and Chinese officials rather than traditional "great men"
What doesn't
• Dense, scholarly writing style that isn't accessible popular history, requiring appetite for academic prose
• Chronological structure with frequent jumps between regions and time periods can feel scattered for readers seeking linear narrative